Do we think Caitlin Clark.....

[Saban_Says]

should be in the 'GOAT' conversation without winning a NCAA Women's Basketball Championship?

 

[Bigwilly64]

We all know where the OP is going with this….yes she is the GOAT Women’s player and yes, she is white.

 

[Chuck Nasty]

why not? Pistol Pete is in the GOAT conversation in mens college hoops and he never won one. Wilt never won one at Kansas. Oscar Robertson at Cincy

 

[Saban_Says]

why not? Pistol Pete is in the GOAT conversation in mens college hoops and he never won one. Wilt never won one at Kansas. Oscar Robertson at Cincy

Never ever heard mention of any of them in the NCAA 'GOAT' conversation - NEVER!

 

[Chuck Nasty]

Never ever heard mention of any of them in the NCAA 'GOAT' conversation - NEVER!

seriously? Pete is the D1 all time leader for points scored... without the 3pt line. Wilt averaged 30 and 18 without the shot clock getting triple teamed all game. The Big 0 was 3x scoring champion while averaging 15 boards and 7 assists

 

[Saban_Says]

seriously? Pete is the D1 all time leader for points scored... without the 3pt line. Wilt averaged 30 and 18 without the shot clock getting triple teamed all game. The Big 0 was 3x scoring champion while averaging 15 boards and 7 assists

Buuuuutttttttttttttttt - NO CHAMPIONSHIP = NO GOAT! Just a great player who put up great numbers!

 

[Saban_Says]

They will keep it classy and professional, but - there are countless other NCAA womens basketball players of the same background as her who actually carried their teams to one or more Championships and put up great numbers too!

H3ll the Paige Beckers young lady from UConn is just as good if not arguably better!

 

[Chuck Nasty]

Buuuuutttttttttttttttt - NO CHAMPIONSHIP = NO GOAT! Just a great player who put up great numbers!

Seems like a pretty casual way to think about a team sport but you do you

 

[Bigwilly64]

Seems like a pretty casual way to think about a team sport but you do you

Right. So every player from those UConn teams is the GOAT.

 

[paladin181]

I think she's the best player of a generation, and it's not close.

 

[MattUGA1]

Only white players can be considered goats.

 

[dp rtr]

Never ever heard mention of any of them in the NCAA 'GOAT' conversation - NEVER!