9 Bama players entered the portal

adcoop

Well-known member
Jul 3, 2023
900
1,050
93
Would you take Edmond back? There is precedent for guys going to another school and transferring back to their original school when it didn't work out. Edmond did show some signs at the end of 2022.
 

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
Would you take Edmond back? There is precedent for guys going to another school and transferring back to their original school when it didn't work out. Edmond did show some signs at the end of 2022.
No. He’s not good enough to make room for. I think we’re good at edge. Especially if we’re going to run 3-3-5 more.
 

92Pony

Joined Jan 18, 2011
Jan 20, 2022
2,466
6,509
113
Would you take Edmond back? There is precedent for guys going to another school and transferring back to their original school when it didn't work out. Edmond did show some signs at the end of 2022.
My initial reaction would be to tell him to kick rocks if he even hinted at being interested in returning. But, I don’t know. As someone else noted above, he showed flashes here in ‘22. I think he could be of use to us. But, obviously that would be Beamer’s call.
 

18IsTheMan

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2022
14,149
12,144
113
Doesn’t matter. They have obvious problems in their organizations. That’s what I learned today. 😎

Obviously requires a holistic assessment. I'm sure you can understand that.

It's like saying there's no difference between people jumping off a ship that just crashed into an iceberg and people getting off a ship that just docked in port.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingWard

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
Obviously requires a holistic assessment. I'm sure you can understand that.

It's like saying there's no difference between people jumping off a ship that just crashed into an iceberg and people getting off a ship that just docked in port.
Yes. It was tongue in cheek. But there has been some that have suggested that big time programs don’t have transfers out. It’s just not true. They have people transferring out for more PT and NIL just like we do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: will110

Harvard Gamecock

Well-known member
Jan 20, 2022
2,192
2,056
113
Would you take Edmond back? There is precedent for guys going to another school and transferring back to their original school when it didn't work out. Edmond did show some signs at the end of 2022.
Can you share or give examples of this precedent.
 

adcoop

Well-known member
Jul 3, 2023
900
1,050
93
Can you share or give examples of this precedent.
This happens more in Basketball than Football. Read an article a year ago listing all the players that left via the transfer portal and transferred back to their original school when things didn't work out. Of course, some fence mending would be needed, but in this era of total free agency chaos, I think you need to take the best players you can regardless of feelings.
 

Chicken Soup

Member
Jan 4, 2024
87
33
18
I used to work with a guy who predicted the last 2 recessions, twelve times.

I don't understand why but we seem to have a lot of fans (maybe they're just posters and not really fans) who seem to believe that other teams situations, issues or problems make us a better team.

LOL ... Come to think about it, there always seems to be discussion about bringing back previous coaches, as well. i.e. Brad Lawing, Joe Lee Dunn, Ernest Nix, Bobby Cremins, Ellis Johnson
 

Big JC

Well-known member
May 12, 2023
1,240
905
113
I used to work with a guy who predicted the last 2 recessions, twelve times.

I don't understand why but we seem to have a lot of fans (maybe they're just posters and not really fans) who seem to believe that other teams situations, issues or problems make us a better team.

LOL ... Come to think about it, there always seems to be discussion about bringing back previous coaches, as well. i.e. Brad Lawing, Joe Lee Dunn, Ernest Nix, Bobby Cremins, Ellis Johnson
There are also a lot of posters who automatically assume that any talented player going in the portal is one we should go after and can get. Most talented, proven players in the portal are not looking to go to a middling to losing program. Rattler was talented but he had lost his starting position and knew he wasn't going to play much, if any, at OK.

Until we start making some sort of noise as even a dark horse contender in the SEC, we aren't at the top of the list for portal players who have a lot of options.
 

Harvard Gamecock

Well-known member
Jan 20, 2022
2,192
2,056
113
There are also a lot of posters who automatically assume that any talented player going in the portal is one we should go after and can get. Most talented, proven players in the portal are not looking to go to a middling to losing program. Rattler was talented but he had lost his starting position and knew he wasn't going to play much, if any, at OK.

Until we start making some sort of noise as even a dark horse contender in the SEC, we aren't at the top of the list for portal players who have a lot of options.
Harsh.
But honest. I like that.
 

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
There are also a lot of posters who automatically assume that any talented player going in the portal is one we should go after and can get. Most talented, proven players in the portal are not looking to go to a middling to losing program. Rattler was talented but he had lost his starting position and knew he wasn't going to play much, if any, at OK.

Until we start making some sort of noise as even a dark horse contender in the SEC, we aren't at the top of the list for portal players who have a lot of options.
Just curious but do you know what options our transfers have had? You don't think Rattler had options?? Do you see the amount of backup QBs who have never played in the portal that are getting interest?? We kicked the tires on 2 of them. We are chasing a Furman OT. I'm sure if he commits, many of you will laugh at us "only being able to get FCS players". And will ignore the fact that he's deciding between USC and FSU. Deandre Jules chose us over UF. Kyle Kennard chose us over FSU. Jared Brown chose us over AU. Rocket didn't even entertain anyone else, but would have attracted a lot of options. Are there some that don't have a lot of options? Sure. But to insinuate that the guys we get don't have any other options is just wrong.