A long read, but illuminating for those who are interested (PSU BOT related)

PSUFTG2

Well-known member
Jul 1, 2023
700
1,569
93
Along the same plot lines of all the "PSU Operating in Secret" stuff going down right now.

Untitled (rcfp.org)

Cliff's Notes:
PSU's stance is that because the "information" is "electronic" - ie: It is available to the trustees in question via on-line file share system : as opposed to being a hard copy on a piece of paper, that is sitting on the trustee's desk - it is not really in the trustee's possession, and therefore not subject to being discovered or subject to RTK.
The pleading further goes on to remind the court that such an argument was recently pled in the Bagwell Case (Ryan Bagwell case, of which many Penn Staters are familiar) with the courts/OOR (Office of Open Records) finding that argument to be incorrect and specious.
"“When Department secretaries are granted access to Diligent [PSU's internal file share system],” the OOR determined that “they clearly receive the documents and information necessary to enable them to perform their duties.”

[Legal Eagles welcome to comment further]
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: fairgambit

fairgambit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,765
5,799
113
Not that long. Certified to be 12,487 words and it is, after all, called a Brief. :)
 

PSUFTG2

Well-known member
Jul 1, 2023
700
1,569
93
Cliff's Notes:

PSU's stance is that because the "information" is "electronic" - ie: It is available to the trustees in question via on-line file share system : as opposed to being a hard copy on a piece of paper, that is sitting on the trustee's desk - it is not really in the trustee's possession, and therefore not subject to being discovered or subject to RTK.
The pleading further goes on to remind the court that such an argument was recently pled in the Bagwell Case (Ryan Bagwell case, of which many Penn Staters are familiar) with the courts/OOR (Office of Open Records) finding that argument to be incorrect and specious.
"“When Department secretaries are granted access to Diligent [PSU's internal file share system],” the OOR determined that “they clearly receive the documents and information necessary to enable them to perform their duties.”
 

SleepyLion

Well-known member
Sep 1, 2022
1,350
1,786
113
I do not see how anyone that works with RTK would not readily give access to these documents.

Fighting this is a waste of resources and time.

There are some frivolous uses of RTK, but this is not one of them.