Can we just fix WTF happened on this play?

SLion_on3

Member
Apr 12, 2022
95
148
33


Re-watching games on youtube bc I enjoy pain. IA, Illinois, MSU, OSU- all painful but this game irritates me the most. We went toe to toe, defense mostly kept UM in check. Haskins was extremely tough back and everything flowed through him on O. We actually ran the ball decently but bone-headed fake FG and horrendous protection sealed it. The final TD for UM was unlucky as ref got in way and players collided on cross. Good call by Jimbo, CJF outcoached again. Still we take the FG instead of fake and not searching for TD at end. This play summarizes the clusterf of 2021. Can someone explain what Rasheed Walker was possibly thinking? I can't fathom it. Did he think Wilson was supposed to pull around? It makes no sense.
 

nittanyfan333

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
2,883
5,682
113
ya know, I think this pretty much sums up Walker for me. All the physical traits in the world, but he just wasn't all there mentally. No idea if it was a cognitive issue, a focus issue, both, something else.... but he just didn't seem to care. I'd love to get @SJLuvsLions and @TFrankCarr X's and O's/coaching take on this. Based on what my eyes tell me from what Wilson did and Miranda's reaction, it sure smells like Walker was clueless.... THIRD YEAR, HIGHLY TOUTED WALKER, was clueless.... I'm so glad he's gone....
 

SoCalLion

Member
Jun 23, 2022
78
95
18
Crappy and underperforming offensive lines --- a hallmark of all eight years of the Franklin era.

Maybe it's STILL the fault of the sanctions though.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: PSU73

CvilleElksCoach

Well-known member
Oct 8, 2021
1,073
2,930
93
I think it is one of two things. The center made the wrong call. But by his reaction, I don’t think so. Or Walker made a mental error attempting to double with the guard versus handling the end. I would agree with the comment that Walker was not always locked in mentally. He was looks like Tarzan thinks like cheetah.
 

nittanyfan333

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
2,883
5,682
113
i keep watching this and it's not like the DL even ran games. All Ojabo did was straight up rush the passer. He even paused momentarily like "uuuuuuhh..... ok?"
 

TheBigUglies

Well-known member
Oct 26, 2021
1,041
1,631
113
LT definitely a misunderstanding(not knowing) the assignment. Maybe there is a similar call where the back or TE in motion would be picking up the defensive end but the last minute changes at the LOS(instead of a huddle) are confusing some players or some are not mentally there to make the quick adjustment based on the play call and the center adjusting/modifying things based on defensive front. I am sure the LT has the physically ability to make the block, the majority of the problems of the OL is knowing who is blocking who(knowing their assignments). I chalk this problem up to the Offensive Line(or some players) not being prepared for what they are going to see in the game. They should be prepared for the defensive front they will see from each opponent and how to adjust the plays, this is what game week practice is for. I don't think we can just blame the player here.
 

SLion_on3

Member
Apr 12, 2022
95
148
33
i keep watching this and it's not like the DL even ran games. All Ojabo did was straight up rush the passer. He even paused momentarily like "uuuuuuhh..... ok?"

I am not expert on OL blocking schemes but I agree. Ojabo lined up across from Walker and RW said 'mehh, someone else has him. I believe this play requires me to step in front of guard and block no one"
 
  • Like
Reactions: NB4PSU and razpsu

SLion_on3

Member
Apr 12, 2022
95
148
33
LT definitely a misunderstanding(not knowing) the assignment. Maybe there is a similar call where the back or TE in motion would be picking up the defensive end but the last minute changes at the LOS(instead of a huddle) are confusing some players or some are not mentally there to make the quick adjustment based on the play call and the center adjusting/modifying things based on defensive front. I am sure the LT has the physically ability to make the block, the majority of the problems of the OL is knowing who is blocking who(knowing their assignments). I chalk this problem up to the Offensive Line(or some players) not being prepared for what they are going to see in the game. They should be prepared for the defensive front they will see from each opponent and how to adjust the plays, this is what game week practice is for. I don't think we can just blame the player here.

It is really this. Watching the protection breakdowns, it really appeared that OL just ran the play and really struggled with adjusting to D front changes. I thought RW was really bad last year. I am sure MY's system probably confused hell out of him. The RB blocking was also some of worst I have ever seen. Lovett and Lee whiffed so many times that I am shocked Cliff is still playing football. It was that bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NB4PSU

Bison13

Well-known member
Oct 13, 2021
1,955
3,317
113
I don’t wanna pick on Rasheed too much but we played against him in high school. I don’t think he was ever taught how to play the line correctly. He was a big strong kid who could move but he had poor technique.

It’s back when I believe he was still in junior high but it’s the same coaching staff, we were playing them in a playoff game and noticed some crazy things on film. They were undefeated and a heavy favorite to get to The 4a state championship game. we noticed that they regularly ran a lot of plays where they weren’t lined up correctly and had ineligible receivers down the field.

Defensively their coaches also made crazy play calls where they went worse than cover zero, they would go cover negative one. By that I mean if we had two receivers lined up they would blitz everybody except the corner covering one receiver, so if your quarterback could pick up which receiver was being blitzed from then you had a free touchdown, which we did in the playoff game.

So my guess is that he just had no idea of a mental side of how to play football because of such poor coaching in high school.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ODShowtime

Bwifan

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,503
2,739
113
Walkers stock was so high he would have been much better leaving for the NFL a year earlier.... his stock just plummeted last season as each game wore on... all the physical traits in the world yet mentally just seemed lost.
 

s1uggo72

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
5,511
4,322
113


Re-watching games on youtube bc I enjoy pain. IA, Illinois, MSU, OSU- all painful but this game irritates me the most. We went toe to toe, defense mostly kept UM in check. Haskins was extremely tough back and everything flowed through him on O. We actually ran the ball decently but bone-headed fake FG and horrendous protection sealed it. The final TD for UM was unlucky as ref got in way and players collided on cross. Good call by Jimbo, CJF outcoached again. Still we take the FG instead of fake and not searching for TD at end. This play summarizes the clusterf of 2021. Can someone explain what Rasheed Walker was possibly thinking? I can't fathom it. Did he think Wilson was supposed to pull around? It makes no sense.

somebody messed up. The LT? blocks run, so did he not get the call. The LG? who knows what he is doing. the QB? he has a free runner, does not see him, does not go hot. CJF? for a poorly designed play? for poor communication?
Now to me this play is more concerning..... QB take too long? Receivers not open? RB definitely takes the wrong man. He was 1-1 on LBer, and that is who made the play.

 

s1uggo72

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
5,511
4,322
113
Walkers stock was so high he would have been much better leaving for the NFL a year earlier.... his stock just plummeted last season as each game wore on... all the physical traits in the world yet mentally just seemed lost.
revisionist history. HIs stock plunged when he played hurt, plus he never recovered, couldnt work out at the combine or his pro day at PSU. Injuries took their toll. Hope he is better for camp.
 

Bwifan

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,503
2,739
113
revisionist history. HIs stock plunged when he played hurt, plus he never recovered, couldnt work out at the combine or his pro day at PSU. Injuries took their toll. Hope he is better for camp.

Everyone has their own opinion and knowledge of what the problems were... we will just agree to disagree. (y)
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUFTG

s1uggo72

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
5,511
4,322
113
Everyone has their own opinion and knowledge of what the problems were... we will just agree to disagree. (y)
so you are saying its my opinion that he was hurt, and that it is my opinion he couldnt work out at the combine, and it is my opinion he couldnt work out at PSU pro day? Do I have that right? TIA
 

NB4PSU

Active member
Oct 30, 2021
194
275
63
And here i was thinking... wait, it's 3rd down and there's still 14:50 on the freaking clock? Guess we planned well for controlling the action...

yes, i'm making light of an awful sequence of plays in a must win game. That was how we came out of the locker room... clearly prepared (roll eyes). And still it was a game we had a shot at... that of itself was amazing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

TheBigUglies

Well-known member
Oct 26, 2021
1,041
1,631
113
somebody messed up. The LT? blocks run, so did he not get the call. The LG? who knows what he is doing. the QB? he has a free runner, does not see him, does not go hot. CJF? for a poorly designed play? for poor communication?
Now to me this play is more concerning..... QB take too long? Receivers not open? RB definitely takes the wrong man. He was 1-1 on LBer, and that is who made the play.


If I am looking at the correct play(where the LB comes up the middle and sacks QB), there could be several issues with this. I recall some blocking schemes call for Big on Big which means OL is only responsible for the guys down in a 3 pt stance and the RB is responsible for LB if he blitzes. In this case, the LB blitzed(a little delayed) and the RB was already looking outside to help out when he should have seen the LB blitzing. OR the center could have peeled off the double team with the LG and picked up blitzing LB which would have allowed QB to step up into pocket to buy a little more time. This looked like deep QB drop which tells me the routes being run by receivers could take little longer. Also, if LB was blitzing, the middle drag route should have been open for him to dump it off. Isn't it a fundamental thing that a receiver should be open where the blitzing player is coming from? It seems like the players are not being taught all they need to be aware of for each weeks opponents when it comes to the offense. I mean will struggle with the lesser teams too when we should be blowing them away with superior athletes and coaching right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: NB4PSU

s1uggo72

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
5,511
4,322
113
If I am looking at the correct play(where the LB comes up the middle and sacks QB), there could be several issues with this. I recall some blocking schemes call for Big on Big which means OL is only responsible for the guys down in a 3 pt stance and the RB is responsible for LB if he blitzes. In this case, the LB blitzed(a little delayed) and the RB was already looking outside to help out when he should have seen the LB blitzing. OR the center could have peeled off the double team with the LG and picked up blitzing LB which would have allowed QB to step up into pocket to buy a little more time. This looked like deep QB drop which tells me the routes being run by receivers could take little longer. Also, if LB was blitzing, the middle drag route should have been open for him to dump it off. Isn't it a fundamental thing that a receiver should be open where the blitzing player is coming from? It seems like the players are not being taught all they need to be aware of for each weeks opponents when it comes to the offense. I mean will struggle with the lesser teams too when we should be blowing them away with superior athletes and coaching right?
nail meet hammer!! I agree
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheBigUglies

Ram20

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
369
702
93
I am mostly a Clifford defender, but the single thing that bothered me most about that entire game was the last series. We are down 4 points, plenty of time on the clock. Nobody in the stadium or watching on TV thought our offense would possibly punch in a TD and win that game, but that last series didn't even try. Not one first down even and just the offensive equivalent of a white flag. Here is what I got:

1st & 10: Deep pass to Cam Sullivan Brown(?) into double coverage. Not a bad throw, but would have needed to be perfect...incomplete
2nd & 10: Little cross and sit by Melik Meiga(?) catches it for 8 yards, falls down like he was shot.
3rd & 2: Clifford locks onto Dotson who beat his man inside but throws a high bullet and the saftey was cheating to dotson all the way, he meets dotson as does the ball and dislodges the ball and maybe knocks dotson unconscious.
4th & 2: Clifford just says "fug" it and launches yet another deep pass to Cam Sullivan but throws it out of bounds so Cam doesn't even have a chance at a miracle catch.
GAME

2 receivers who barely play all year long get targeted 3 times, two passes of which were very low percentage down field passes. There is 3:00 on the clock so a run is an option(although I guess we had given up on running the ball entirely). No Parker Washinton, nothing out of the back field, no tight ends, no creativity. I don't know if MY had surrendered play calling at that point or what, but whoever called those plays with that personnel was paid way too much for that series of calls.
 

SLion_on3

Member
Apr 12, 2022
95
148
33
I am mostly a Clifford defender, but the single thing that bothered me most about that entire game was the last series. We are down 4 points, plenty of time on the clock. Nobody in the stadium or watching on TV thought our offense would possibly punch in a TD and win that game, but that last series didn't even try. Not one first down even and just the offensive equivalent of a white flag. Here is what I got:

1st & 10: Deep pass to Cam Sullivan Brown(?) into double coverage. Not a bad throw, but would have needed to be perfect...incomplete
2nd & 10: Little cross and sit by Melik Meiga(?) catches it for 8 yards, falls down like he was shot.
3rd & 2: Clifford locks onto Dotson who beat his man inside but throws a high bullet and the saftey was cheating to dotson all the way, he meets dotson as does the ball and dislodges the ball and maybe knocks dotson unconscious.
4th & 2: Clifford just says "fug" it and launches yet another deep pass to Cam Sullivan but throws it out of bounds so Cam doesn't even have a chance at a miracle catch.
GAME

2 receivers who barely play all year long get targeted 3 times, two passes of which were very low percentage down field passes. There is 3:00 on the clock so a run is an option(although I guess we had given up on running the ball entirely). No Parker Washinton, nothing out of the back field, no tight ends, no creativity. I don't know if MY had surrendered play calling at that point or what, but whoever called those plays with that personnel was paid way too much for that series of calls.
Hardly Clifford to blame. He got pounded all game and obviously the play-call was quick throws to avoid rush. Why is CSB even in there on critical series? This is CJF/MY.
 

Ram20

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
369
702
93
Hardly Clifford to blame. He got pounded all game and obviously the play-call was quick throws to avoid rush. Why is CSB even in there on critical series? This is CJF/MY.
100%, but Clifford does deserve blame for throwing the ball out of bounds on 4th down. A Franklin mortal sin. Gotta give your guy a chance there
 
  • Like
Reactions: NB4PSU

Bison13

Well-known member
Oct 13, 2021
1,955
3,317
113
100%, but Clifford does deserve blame for throwing the ball out of bounds on 4th down. A Franklin mortal sin. Gotta give your guy a chance there
True cause you never know he might get a pass interference penalty, That is if you’re anybody except Penn State.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

Ram20

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
369
702
93
True cause you never know he might get a pass in a fair and penalty, That is if you’re anybody except Penn State.

On fourth and two in a must score situation I can't imagine anyone thinks there is a worse option than throwing the ball out of bounce.
 
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login