going to get you to a World Series. How does Zambrano, Lilly, Dempster match up against Webb, Haren, and a healthy Johnson? Not too well. Look at the complete rotation. The best starter outside of Zambrano so far this year has been Lieber. He has been the team MVP so far. Might be forced to move him into the rotation if Lilly continues to blow.
We could even throw Fukodome into the leadoff spot if we had to. His career OBP (even though it is in Japan) is higher than Soriano's. Soto is emerging as a solid hitter as well. Everyone has to stay healthy though. Soriano's stats are plastic anyway. He racks them up in meaningless games and can't be relied upon to get a clutch hit. There is some sarcasm there but there is some truth in it too.
The question is what starting pitcher could you realistically get for Soriano that would be worth it? His salary is so high you can only move him to a few teams. That's the problem.