Well, I've tried the antenna. I can get CBS (12), ABC (16), and PBS (29) in good, and the rest not so good. FOX is extremely weak, and I've never been able to bring in even a weak signal for NBC (3). So going with a provider was my only option. I contemplated comcast, since they were the only ones offering locals, but I just couldn't being myself to go back to cable. Now that dish has finally added the locals in hd, I should be good. I'm sure since dish has worked out the local contracts, directv will be right behind.</p>