If you are not mad about NIL yet, let the NCAA do the honor

[Fowlmoodin99]

I don't know where to start. The gist of this article is essentially that the NCAA can do nothing with third party involvement-----the big, big money, but can go after the small collectives just trying to compete.


"The deals are being done with third parties. And the NCAA obviously has no jurisdiction over those third parties," said Mit Winter, a former college basketball player and now a sports law attorney for Kennyhertz Perry. "[The NCAA] can talk to and gather information from schools and the athletes. But any incriminating information is most likely going to be among people that either work for or have some involvement with third parties."

.........

"I could see the NCAA wanting to gather information from the schools to see if there is any relationship between the school and its employees and the collectives," Winter said. "I can see the NCAA being very interested in that."

The NCAA is a worthless, toothless monstrosity in this new age. They add nothing to the conversation.

Redirect Notice

 

[Go Gamecocks]

Only a matter of time before creative people find and exploit loopholes.

 

[Harvard Gamecock]

I don't know where to start. The gist of this article is essentially that the NCAA can do nothing with third party involvement-----the big, big money, but can go after the small collectives just trying to compete.


"The deals are being done with third parties. And the NCAA obviously has no jurisdiction over those third parties," said Mit Winter, a former college basketball player and now a sports law attorney for Kennyhertz Perry. "[The NCAA] can talk to and gather information from schools and the athletes. But any incriminating information is most likely going to be among people that either work for or have some involvement with third parties."

.........

"I could see the NCAA wanting to gather information from the schools to see if there is any relationship between the school and its employees and the collectives," Winter said. "I can see the NCAA being very interested in that."

The NCAA is a worthless, toothless monstrosity in this new age. They add nothing to the conversation.

Redirect Notice

In case you have not kept up with the legal aspect of this issue, the NCAA lost their case against NIL in Federal Court and before SCOTUS.
Legally there is very little they can do at this point. Third parties have no incentive to co-operate with the NCAA.

See article below.
The NCAA has lost an additional federal court battle on name, image, and likeness (NIL) compensation for student-athletes just days after the U.S. Supreme Court’s unanimous decision confirming the Ninth Circuit’s ruling that the NCAA’s limitation on education-related benefits for student-athletes violates federal antitrust laws.

https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/the-hits-keep-coming-ncaa-loses-another-8490423/

 

[Viennacock]

Only a matter of time before creative people find and exploit loopholes.

Loopholes? The entire NIL is the loophole. No need for a loophole inside the loophole.

 

[Fowlmoodin99]

In case you have not kept up with the legal aspect of this issue, the NCAA lost their case against NIL in Federal Court and before SCOTUS.
Legally there is very little they can do at this point. Third parties have no incentive to co-operate with the NCAA.

See article below.
The NCAA has lost an additional federal court battle on name, image, and likeness (NIL) compensation for student-athletes just days after the U.S. Supreme Court’s unanimous decision confirming the Ninth Circuit’s ruling that the NCAA’s limitation on education-related benefits for student-athletes violates federal antitrust laws.

https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/the-hits-keep-coming-ncaa-loses-another-8490423/

Yep, I'm aware of the SC action. The fact that the NCAA sulks into their corner and tries to narrow down the field of offenders exhibits the obvious uselessness of their existence and the irony of their "maintaining order." They should stand down or be shut down. They have been legislated into oblivion with the current NIL landscape.

 

[Rogue Cock]

Yep, I'm aware of the SC action. The fact that the NCAA sulks into their corner and tries to narrow down the field of offenders exhibits the obvious uselessness of their existence and the irony of their "maintaining order." They should stand down or be shut down. They have been legislated into oblivion with the current NIL landscape.

They simply are trying to maintain the amateur status of college sports. Lose that status....you have a plethora of other legal issues to deal with.

 

[Go Gamecocks]

Loopholes? The entire NIL is the loophole. No need for a loophole inside the loophole.

Ya gotta wonder if the NCAA considered the 3rd party bag men when they opened that Pandora's box.

 

[Rogue Cock]

Ya gotta wonder if the NCAA considered the 3rd party bag men when they opened that Pandora's box.

Federal courts opened the NIL loophole, not the NCAA. NCAA fought against it and lost.

 

[King Ward]

Federal courts opened the NIL loophole, not the NCAA. NCAA fought against it and lost.

It's stupefying how people distort things.

 

[Fowlmoodin99]

They simply are trying to maintain the amateur status of college sports. Lose that status....you have a plethora of other legal issues to deal with.

And in applying whatever rules they may still apply they make the playing field more uneven. The ship has sailed. The old cause is dead for them.

NIL signals the end of the NCAA’s purpose

Like the ponytail that’s been growing since your barber closed shop back in March of last year, it’s time to cut off the NCAA. Those people who hold their glance a few seconds too long when walking past you on the street? Those aren’t stares of admiration – the time has come and gone. The...

wfuogb.com

 

[Gamecock Jacque]

It's stupefying how.people distort things.

I have to confess that I'm no longer stupefied.

 

[Rogue Cock]

And in applying whatever rules they may still apply they make the playing field more uneven. The ship has sailed. The old cause is dead for them.

NIL signals the end of the NCAA’s purpose

Like the ponytail that’s been growing since your barber closed shop back in March of last year, it’s time to cut off the NCAA. Those people who hold their glance a few seconds too long when walking past you on the street? Those aren’t stares of admiration – the time has come and gone. The...

wfuogb.com

The field was uneven when the USSC made its decision. Agree that the NCAA may have lost its purpose for the larger P5 schools...if this trend grows. I believe eventually tne P5 schools will leave the NCAA of their own accord or the NCAA will cut them loose to protect the smaller schools.

And Mr. Zimmerman didn't even begin to delve into the issues the loss of amateur status would involve. He compared them rightly to professionals, but he didn't get into what professionalism would mean. And he is wrong that they don't prepare players for life after sports.....that is exactly why they are in college or danged well should be....to get a freakin' free education.

 

[Go Gamecocks]

Federal courts opened the NIL loophole, not the NCAA. NCAA fought against it and lost.

Shows how much I know. Thanks for the correction!