If you were Damar Hamlin, would you play again?

18IsTheMan

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2022
14,162
12,152
113
He was fully cleared by doctors to return to playing. But, man, I don't know how I'd be able to do it. He essentially died out there, and probably would have stayed that way if he had that cardiac arrest in any other location outside of a hospital. He's only alive b/c there was medical staff on-site who intervened immediately. I guess I'm looking at it as a 45 year old with a wife and 3 kids. He's 25 and single. I guess you play the odds and say "how likely is it die on the football field TWICE?" I hope he stays strong, healthy and has a long career.

Side note, if you're the Bills, can you ever trade or cut the guy? I mean, he died playing football for you.
 

Uscg1984

Well-known member
Jan 28, 2022
1,778
2,356
113
Was his death really football-related or did that just happen to be the time his heart decided to do what it did? It seems different to me from the Sterling Sharpe situation where there is a significant chance he could get hit in just the right way that would leave him permanently paralyzed. If multiple doctors (not just the team doctor) tell Hamlin that there was nothing specific about that football play that triggered his heart attack, then I'd think there's nothing to stop him. Having said that, I don't think it'd be unreasonable for him to say "no, I'm good" and calling it a career.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maxcy

18IsTheMan

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2022
14,162
12,152
113
Was his death really football-related or did that just happen to be the time his heart decided to do what it did? It seems different to me from the Sterling Sharpe situation where there is a significant chance he could get hit in just the right way that would leave him permanently paralyzed. If multiple doctors (not just the team doctor) tell Hamlin that there was nothing specific about that football play that triggered his heart attack, then I'd think there's nothing to stop him. Having said that, I don't think it'd be unreasonable for him to say "no, I'm good" and calling it a career.

Yeah, who knows what the cause is? They won't release that. It seems to me it would be highly statistically improbable that the cardiac arrest was totally unrelated to the game action, but I guess if the doctors could show him that 100%, then there's no reason not to.

He's gotta have Comeback Player of the Year sewn up for 2023 doesn't he? Who's gonna top him?
 

Prestonyte

Well-known member
Jun 1, 2022
5,261
5,214
113
If he does come back, will he be himself or be timid and gun shy about contact?
 

Gradstudent

Joined Feb 11, 2006
Feb 2, 2022
1,131
1,719
113
Seemed like the Heart attack was related to him getting hit hard right at the very specific spot of the heart for him. The Bengal WR drove his helmet right into that area. Coincidence?

I would take a hint and not play again, he is a fairly undersized player.

Just speculation but plenty of articles from cardiologists with this theory and explanation of commotio cordis


What may have caused Buffalo Bills’ Damar Hamlin to go into cardiac arrest? A local cardiologist explains​



Jacksonville cardiologist Samer M. Garas, MD explains what went wrong, and right, Monday night during the Bills-Bengals game.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – Buffalo Bills defensive back Damar Hamlin was in critical condition Tuesday morning after the team said his heart stopped following a tackle during a Monday Night Football game.
In a chilling scene, Hamlin was administered CPR on the field while surrounded by teammates. Some of them were in tears while they shielded Hamlin from public view. After about an hour delay, the game was indefinitely postponed.


Hamlin, 24, was hurt while tackling Cincinnati Bengals receiver Tee Higgins on a seemingly routine play that didn’t appear unusually violent.
While waiting for official word, News4JAX is looking into what may have happened on the field Monday night.
Samer M. Garas, MD, a cardiologist with Ascension St. Vincent’s, joined The Morning Show to discuss what may have caused Hamlin to go into cardiac arrest.
“There’s something called commotio cordis which basically is an injury to the heart where — at a single, specific point — you can affect the heart rhythm, and when the heart rhythm is disturbed, the heart stops beating and you can have ventricular fibrillation or ventricular tachycardia,” Garas said.

Garas said the situation could also be different depending on if Hamlin had any underlying heart conditions.

“Assuming he has a normal heart... (the cardiac arrest) that could happen can happen with a baseball hitting the chest, a hockey puck hitting the chest. In this case, it was a shoulder or helmet hitting right into the heart. But it has to be in a specific timing, a specific vulnerable spot that caused the heart rhythm to go out of order.”

News4JAX asked if it was odd that he stood up and appeared to be fine for a couple of seconds before he collapsed.

“No, not at all. The heart rhythm was starting to basically go out of order likely. And then he was able to stand up for a second and his blood pressure just went down. And then he collapsed. That’s most likely what happened,” he said.

 
Last edited:

Maxcy

Joined Jun 20, 2011
Jan 31, 2022
1,085
1,900
113
Yeah, who knows what the cause is? They won't release that.

Well, considering what we've all been through since March 2020, it isn't that hard to figure out what happened...and why the cause isn't being released. You're a smart guy...
 
  • Haha
Reactions: frank.bank

CockofEarle

Well-known member
Jan 31, 2022
1,068
707
113
He was fully cleared by doctors to return to playing. But, man, I don't know how I'd be able to do it. He essentially died out there, and probably would have stayed that way if he had that cardiac arrest in any other location outside of a hospital. He's only alive b/c there was medical staff on-site who intervened immediately. I guess I'm looking at it as a 45 year old with a wife and 3 kids. He's 25 and single. I guess you play the odds and say "how likely is it die on the football field TWICE?" I hope he stays strong, healthy and has a long career.

Side note, if you're the Bills, can you ever trade or cut the guy? I mean, he died playing football for you.
Take the money and raise a family.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bcaldw01

paladin181

Joined Aug 28, 2014
Jan 17, 2022
8,370
24,369
113
This is his dream. Of course he comes back. Freak accidents happen. You gotta jump back on that horse some day.
 

CWW

Joined Dec 2, 2013
Feb 1, 2022
463
480
63
I can’t imagine an insurance company wanting to insure him. I think the team is stuck…how can you release a player that got all of that attention? I wish they would offer him an off field position and he would accept it.
 

Gamecock Lincoln

Joined Nov 10, 2007 • Garnet Trust Supporter
Jan 18, 2022
733
1,804
93
I thought the cause was released. If you're hit in the chest during a certain phase of the cardiac cycle, it can cause the heart to stop (commotio cordis). It has been documented in sports, like baseball, for years. It would be scary to return to professional sports but the odds of it happening again are probably slim to none. I know there are some that want to tie everything to the COVID vaccine but that's ignorant.

https://www.sportsmedtoday.com/commotio-cordis-va-88.htm
 
Last edited:

paladin181

Joined Aug 28, 2014
Jan 17, 2022
8,370
24,369
113
lol, dying on the field is a bit more than a freak accident.
No, it isn't. It was a freak accident that stopped his heart, most likely resulting from a particular impact at a particular moment interrupting his heartbeat. If there is no underlying cause in him, there's not much reason for him to be fearful it could happen again. Though, I'm not sure about how it would affect him psychologically, if he wants to get back out there, he should.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Go Gamecocks

Go Gamecocks

Well-known member
Jan 24, 2022
798
701
93
…how can you release a player that got all of that attention?
Guys come back from injuries all the time.
Why would you release a starter that is an inspiration to the rest of your team and fan base? :oops:
 

Go Gamecocks

Well-known member
Jan 24, 2022
798
701
93
Though, I'm not sure about how it would affect him psychologically, if he wants to get back out there, he should.
Well he basically stood back up and fainted. Doesn't seem to be residual effects from fainting for most. They just don't remember anything.
 

18IsTheMan

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2022
14,162
12,152
113
Well he basically stood back up and fainted. Doesn't seem to be residual effects from fainting for most. They just don't remember anything.

Well, he had cardiac arrest and, in the words of doctors, "died on the field". That's not fainting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: paladin181

ToddFlanders

Well-known member
Jan 20, 2022
947
936
93
I thought the cause was released. If you're hit in the chest during a certain phase of the cardiac cycle, it can cause the heart to stop (commotio cordis). It has been documented in sports, like baseball, for years. It would be scary to return to professional sports but the odds of it happening again are probably slim to none. I know there are some that want to tie everything to the COVID vaccine but that's ignorant.

https://www.sportsmedtoday.com/commotio-cordis-va-88.htm

Exactly. It’s a freak accident. The odds of it happening once is astronomical - twice to the same person is a near impossibility.

So if it were me, and football was my only source of income, I’d play again. Get some big paydays for a couple of years to build a nest egg to help start the second part of my working life.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gamecock Lincoln
Sep 29, 2022
29
28
13
Definitely - the cause of the event and circumstances surrounding same were so freakish that the possibility of what happened taking place again is so remote or beyond mathematical computation that as long as my doctors found nothing else wrong - for sure I would play again. Nothing in the way of other med reports have ever noted any other health issues...go for it