Namely JR, Peaches, and fishwater.
I've got two words for you fishwater: Christian Laettner. Great college player, hit one of the biggest shots in NCAA Tournament history, won back to back titles with Duke. Was he a great pro? Nope. I'll give you a modern example: Tyler Hansbrough is arguably the best player in the nation but many think he'll last 3-4 years in the pros before washing out. Does that lessen his college career which has been fantastic? Absolutely not. You see, college and professional leagues are different. The typical way to play is different, the competition is different, the rules are different in most cases, excelling at one level doesn't ensure excellence at the next level. We didn't retroactively go back and name Vince Carter an elite college basketball player because he blew up in the NBA. Danny Wuerrfel's inability to make it in the NFL doesn't lessen his stellar college career. Papelbon's success at Boston doesn't improve his college career, which was pretty modest by comparison. Success at one level should be viewed separately from success at a different level.
I still find myself asking if you guys can post something without exaggeration and the answer is still no.