Here is the video of the play.
https://twitter.com/11point7/status/1500247301629095941?s=21
On second glance it’s not QUITE as bad by us as it originally seemed. McGowan was on the warning track and off balance when he caught it. The throw home was not very strong but Yeager was pretty deep in the grass when he threw it. They had just put a pinch runner on second and that guy obviously had some speed. Just kind of a perfect storm of things.
To me, it looks like McGowan overran that fly ball and had to reach back for it. He should have been slowing down more as he got ready to make the catch. If he had, then he could have stopped and made the throw much quicker than he did.
After McGowan caught the ball, he took way too many steps to get situated to make the throw. As an outfielder in that situation, he HAS to know that the runner on 2nd base might try to score. And thus, he has to stop and get the ball to the cutoff man ASAP.
McGowan was sorta stumbling around from the get-go as soon as the ball was hit. He never did really "get a bead" on that ball.
He may have taken a bad angle on the ball which caused him to be off-balance the whole time he was tracking that ball, which led to his delay in making the throw.
I certainly admit that sun had to be tough on that ball. I'm sure the sun was 17'ing with McGowan the whole time he was running it down.
And I agree that it was sort of a "perfect storm" that led to the runner at 2nd scoring.
However, I'd also say there's no 17'ing way last year's right fielder would have let that happen.