I love it Backer. If we were really cheating under Orgeron (which I don't think we were any more than anyone else to be sure), don't you think we'd have done better in recruiting? Go back and tell me how many guys we legitimately beat the big time programs to get. Other than a handful in 2006, there really aren't that many. And the majority of the big recruiting coups we did manage to land were guys that were borderline on grades and therefore weren't top priorities for teams like LSU, USC, Florida, etc.
For that matter, I'll do it for you. Here is a list of the 4 and 5 star guys we landed under Orgeron:
2005:
Michael Oher - beat Tennessee primarily, was a big grade risk, primarily signed with us due to living with an Ole Miss family
Jerrell Powe - beat out Auburn and LSU, though they both were shooting him straight about being a sign and place, while Orgeron convinced him he could get him in school sooner
2006:
Brent Schaeffer - Juco - beat out NC State and Wisconsin - probably one of the only big coups of the Orgeron era, though he did end up with grade issues
Cordera Eason - beat out Auburn - from Mississippi and actually had his grades
Jonathon Cornell - beat out some west coast schools including apparently USC - had grade issues and barely made it to campus
Kentrell Lockett - beat out Alabama - was a definite grade risk, barely made it to school
Allen Walker - beat out Florida - was borderline on grades and made it in with a late jump in his ACT score
John Jerry - had been a sign and place at Hargrave from the previous class
Aubrey McPhadden - Juco - really had no other offers due to grades, didn't make it
Terry Levy - had no other major offers due to grades, didn't make it
Jerrell Powe - no comment needed
2007:
Rod Davis - got attention from other schools, but didn't have his grades, never made it to campus
Ashlee Palmer - Juco - never really had any competition for him
Tony Fein - Juco - beat out Michigan State - had his grades, was overrated as a 4 star
Lionel Breaux - beat out LSU, Alabama, and Nebraska - actually had his grades fairly well in order
AJ Jackson - Juco - claimed other offers but had really bad grade issues, never made it
Ted Laurent - had other offers, had grade issues and just barely made it
Chris Strong - had offers, but obviously didn't have his grades in order, took a miracle to get him in
That's 3 players rated at 4 stars or better in 2007 that had no real grade issues, two of which were Jucos. You could argue that maybe 2 or 3 of our 2006 4 or 5 star players were in decent standing with grades. And obviously both of our 5 star guys in 2005 were big grade risks.
In reality, almost all of the big names we signed under Orgeron were either not that high on the board for the big programs, or they had grade risks that bumped them down in priority for the big name schools.
Don't you think that if we were buying Hummers, we'd have been able to steal some actual recruits that the big schools wanted?