Of all the infield positions, 3B is not a difficult position to play

PrestonyteParrot

Well-known member
May 28, 2024
1,370
1,348
113
I played it myself throughout my BB career starting in Little League.
Can't believe we do not have someone on our roster capable of playing that position who can field the ball, make a decision and throw to the proper base.
 

PrestonyteParrot

Well-known member
May 28, 2024
1,370
1,348
113
The hot corner? You have to have great reflexes to play there.....hit balls come at you fast....which is true of SS and 2nd also, but 3rd seems to get more than their fair share of them.
True, but you get used to it.
SS, 2B and 1B have a lot more involvement in things other than ground balls and line drives than 3B.
 

PrestonyteParrot

Well-known member
May 28, 2024
1,370
1,348
113
I played middle infield, mostly SS, and I never wanted to be at 3rd. First base I always believed was the "easiest"..., though not easy.
Yea, it always seemed the biggest and slowest good hitters ended up at first base but dealing with all the wild throws isn't easy..
With middle infielders, being in the right position to cover 2B all the time requires a lot of concentration.
Watching Clete Boyer attracted me to 3B.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rogue Cock

Rogue Cock

Joined Sep 11, 2000
Jan 22, 2022
10,011
14,863
113
Yea, it always seemed the biggest and slowest good hitters ended up at first base but dealing with all the wild throws isn't easy..
With middle infielders, being in the right position to cover 2B all the time requires a lot of concentration.
Watching Clete Boyer attracted me to 3B.
Never had the arm for third.....didn't have the proper wrist action to make the throw without an arc. Barely did for SS and that was only up to a certain level and could use a 3/4 throwing motion.
 

Harvard Gamecock

Well-known member
Jan 20, 2022
2,185
2,050
113
True, but you get used to it.
SS, 2B and 1B have a lot more involvement in things other than ground balls and line drives than 3B.
Having played 2B from Little League through HS, and American Legion Ball (you oldtimers will remember), I'll grant you there is more involvement at 2B, but fielding a hot shot on the 3B foul line and making the cross field throw to 1B in time, is not at all easy, and not many can make that throw.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LexCock11

PrestonyteParrot

Well-known member
May 28, 2024
1,370
1,348
113
Having played 2B from Little League through HS, and American Legion Ball (you oldtimers will remember), I'll grant you there is more involvement at 2B, but fielding a hot shot on the 3B foul line and making the cross field throw to 1B in time, is not at all easy, and not many can make that throw.
In my experience at 3B from LL - Legion ball, the key at 3B is quick reflexes fielding the ball and being patient with your throws. The ball gets there so quickly most of the time, patience with the throw and not rushing it is required.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rogue Cock

Whiterockcock69

Joined Sep 12, 2010
Jan 31, 2022
641
1,011
93
I’m not a coach but I have played a bit of baseball and I respectfully disagree. The ball is on you many times in an instant. You may have more time to throw but it’s also the longest throw. I just don’t see how you can say it is the easiest infield position to play. Frankly they all have unique challenges.
 

PrestonyteParrot

Well-known member
May 28, 2024
1,370
1,348
113
I’m not a coach but I have played a bit of baseball and I respectfully disagree. The ball is on you many times in an instant. You may have more time to throw but it’s also the longest throw. I just don’t see how you can say it is the easiest infield position to play. Frankly they all have unique challenges.
Maybe not the easiest, but easier in many ways. Unlike 2B and SS, 3B is field the ball and throw. Quick reflexes and patience for strong, accurate throws are needed. 2B and SS require a lot more movement and premeditated thought on responsibilities requiring potential positioning and base coverages as well as essentially having short outfield responsibilities on bloopers and soft liners. 1B has its challenges with all the wild and crazy throws, holding runners while also fielding the position and coordination with the pitcher on base coverages.
 

PrestonyteParrot

Well-known member
May 28, 2024
1,370
1,348
113
I have to say, I don't entirely agree with that premise. Lots of tough chances and lots of long throws.
Having played all the infield positions, I found 3B to be challenging but also the easiest in terms of responsibilities which I guess was my point with that comment. A good arm was never a problem as I eventually evolved into a pitcher in HS and college.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blues man

kidrobinski

Active member
Jan 30, 2022
475
479
63
I read this post when it first appeared and started to say something but others debunked so I laid off. Like others here I played up through American legion and a similar level called palmetto majors (71-72) which I’m not sure still exists. I was primarily a pitcher and short but I played a couple at third when our guy was out and was surprised at how quick the ball gets on you. I wouldn’t term any position ‘easy’, and certainly not third.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rogue Cock

SSIGamecock

Garnet Trust Supporter
Feb 3, 2022
3,612
7,292
113
Is catcher not considered an infield position?
no.

IF is 1b, 2b, ss, 3b.

3b is definitely easier than SS or 2b. I'd say 1b is probably tougher as well due to the sheer quantity of plays you're involved with comparatively due to throws incoming. Most of the balls hit to 3b are going to get there quicker, which leaves less time to react, but also has less hops involved which is much easier to field. Yes, they come at your faster, but most times it's not so fast that it's any more difficult.

I'd definitely not say it's easy, however, the OP didn't say that, just said it was easy relative to the others.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1716918328

KingWard

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2022
6,862
7,214
113
Having played all the infield positions, I found 3B to be challenging but also the easiest in terms of responsibilities which I guess was my point with that comment. A good arm was never a problem as I eventually evolved into a pitcher in HS and college.
It's less situational, I'll give you that, but it demands outstanding athletic attainments to play well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1716918328

KingWard

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2022
6,862
7,214
113
I don't disagree, but only 1b demands less athleticism.
First base is where they used to put some ball players to extend careers. Sometimes they used right field for that. In the AL, the damnable DH is the first mode of career prolongment now.
 

vacock

Joined Oct 26, 1998 • Garnet Trust Supporter
Jan 20, 2022
6,047
8,676
113
Isn’t first base easier? Who’s on first?
 

SSIGamecock

Garnet Trust Supporter
Feb 3, 2022
3,612
7,292
113
First base is where they used to put some ball players to extend careers. Sometimes they used right field for that. In the AL, the damnable DH is the first mode of career prolongment now.
Well the post is about the infield, so that's what I was speaking of.

Also, the DH is in both the NL and the AL.
 

Blues man

Joined Jul 1, 2009
Jan 22, 2022
1,681
1,666
113
I don't disagree, but only 1b demands less athleticism.
1st base was historically the one spot on defense where you could put one of the top two guys you recruited specifically for their bat. One of those guys takes up the DH spot the other presumably more athletic guy plays 1st. So yeah, all he has to do is be more athletic than one guy... unless the other guy is left handed, then he may be screwed. lol
 
Last edited:

SSIGamecock

Garnet Trust Supporter
Feb 3, 2022
3,612
7,292
113
1st base was historically the one spot on defense where you could put one of the top two guys you recruited specifically for their bat. One of those guys takes up the DH spot the other presumably more athletic guy plays 1st. So yeah, all he has to do is be more athletic than one guy... unless the other guy is left handed, then he may be screwed. lol
Lol yeah that is my point. Anyone who would try to say 3b is tougher or more athletic than 2b or ss is just wrong from a generic approach. Yes, A Rod or Arenado were/are probably more athletic than many at the other 2, but in general, that's how it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blues man
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login