gone to hell. It started out as a way to encourage people to play & play competitively against people of like ability. It is not just MS's system--the same problems exist in TN, LA, AR, etc. But you are right, it has gotten significantly worse since they allowed self-rating. I dont much care about guys/teams that sandbag because they usually either get DQ'd or shamed into playing their own level. Besides, if they get far enough,--regionals & on, it pretty much takes care of itself because most players that get that far are playing well above their level. I have found at the regional level it is much more competitive & even in terms of ability. More responsibility/authority should be placed on the local coordinator to ensure that when people sandbag, they are dealt with harshly, i.e. suspended from USTA play for one year, etc. (not a rule but should be). My biggest gripe is the inconsistency of the computer adjusted ratings. ALL USTA play should be considered & not just spring league play.
I play 4.5 in Memphis and many of our 5.0s have been pushed down to 4.5 and many 4.0s pushed up to 4.5 which creates a much larger pool of 4.5 players but with a wide range of actual ability. The 4.0s is pretty much strong 4.0s or guys who really should be playign 3.5--not much middle ground.
If you have ever made it to regionals, you have likely seen teh vast difference avility wise in teh GA teams, specifically Atlanta teams. Atlanta plays AALTA in the spring & USTA leagues in teh fall. Many of these stronger players get bumped up @ year end after USTA play and play AALTA @ their new higher rating level. They then are allowed to go back to tehir fall rating & play State/Regionals, etc. USTA told teh GA Tennis Assoc. that they had to change & they basically told teh USTA to pound sand since they have 500,000 USTA members in Atlanta alone. When faced with the possibility of losing $12.5mm in dues, the USTA backed off.
Overall, the system sucks & I have been playing in it for 15 years--it has steadily gotten worse. If not for the love of the game, I would probably quit playing NTRP leagues & tournaments.