PIAA ordered to release thousands of documents relating to financial matters in Right to Know case.

Nittany1865Farmer

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,249
1,899
113
In a two year fight in the court system, a Pennsylvania judge ordered the PIAA to release thousands of documents, including financial statements related to District 4 under the state's Right to Know Law. The judge ruled that the PIAA is a "public institution" and therefore its records are open to the public. This case will have a major impact across the state as more filings are being considered for financial purposes of how monies are spent in the PIAA. https://www.dailyitem.com/news/in-wake-of-court-ruling-piaa-must-release-thousands-of-documents/article_4838c5b2-d0d7-11ee-a6e8-4fecdc52f140.html#:~:text=The state Supreme Court ruled,who requested them in 2021.

HARRISBURG — Based on a decision handed down today by the state Supreme Court, the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association (PIAA) must now produce thousands of documents, including financial statements from District 4, to a Bucks County man who requested them.

The state Supreme Court ruled today in a court case that has been going on for two years that the PIAA is a public agency and subject to the Right to Know Law.

Therefore, the PIAA must provide documents to Simon Campbell, who requested them in 2021. The requested documents, which the court ruled are public, include receipts or bank statements from PIAA for money spent at a private home in Mifflinburg where District 4 officials at the time held a meeting to discuss Valley athletics.


Some of the records also include various receipts for meetings held at the Buffalo Wild Wings restaurant in Williamsport, and the Sullivan County Country Club, in Sullivan County, where food and alcohol was purchased.

"This is a win for not only for myself and reporters, but for the state of Pennsylvania," Campbell said today.

"The line was now drawn in the sand and after seeing The Daily Item requests, I decided to jump in and help, not just the newspaper but everyone."

Campbell said the victory is important for the state.


"We now have it affirmed that anyone has access to these records," he said. Citizens, reporters, parents, taxpayers can get access to these documents, that’s the most important aspect of this decision."

Campbell said he spent tens of thousands of dollars to get the victory, and he will be seeking the thousands of documents, sooner rather than later.

"I will also be filing another Right to Know here on other things I have come to learn since the time of the first filing," he said.

PIAA officials have not spoken to The Daily Item about the issue, and Executive Director Robert Lombardi refuses comment to the newspaper.

Campbell said he will be speaking to his attorney about when he can expect the original documents he requested from the PIAA.

Campbell said he was saddened because PIAA spent money on attorney fees, the same money PIAA collects from taxpayers.

"That's the shameful part of this," he said. "We paid twice for this."
 

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,852
15,702
113
In a two year fight in the court system, a Pennsylvania judge ordered the PIAA to release thousands of documents, including financial statements related to District 4 under the state's Right to Know Law. The judge ruled that the PIAA is a "public institution" and therefore its records are open to the public. This case will have a major impact across the state as more filings are being considered for financial purposes of how monies are spent in the PIAA. https://www.dailyitem.com/news/in-wake-of-court-ruling-piaa-must-release-thousands-of-documents/article_4838c5b2-d0d7-11ee-a6e8-4fecdc52f140.html#:~:text=The state Supreme Court ruled,who requested them in 2021.

HARRISBURG — Based on a decision handed down today by the state Supreme Court, the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association (PIAA) must now produce thousands of documents, including financial statements from District 4, to a Bucks County man who requested them.

The state Supreme Court ruled today in a court case that has been going on for two years that the PIAA is a public agency and subject to the Right to Know Law.

Therefore, the PIAA must provide documents to Simon Campbell, who requested them in 2021. The requested documents, which the court ruled are public, include receipts or bank statements from PIAA for money spent at a private home in Mifflinburg where District 4 officials at the time held a meeting to discuss Valley athletics.


Some of the records also include various receipts for meetings held at the Buffalo Wild Wings restaurant in Williamsport, and the Sullivan County Country Club, in Sullivan County, where food and alcohol was purchased.

"This is a win for not only for myself and reporters, but for the state of Pennsylvania," Campbell said today.

"The line was now drawn in the sand and after seeing The Daily Item requests, I decided to jump in and help, not just the newspaper but everyone."

Campbell said the victory is important for the state.


"We now have it affirmed that anyone has access to these records," he said. Citizens, reporters, parents, taxpayers can get access to these documents, that’s the most important aspect of this decision."

Campbell said he spent tens of thousands of dollars to get the victory, and he will be seeking the thousands of documents, sooner rather than later.

"I will also be filing another Right to Know here on other things I have come to learn since the time of the first filing," he said.

PIAA officials have not spoken to The Daily Item about the issue, and Executive Director Robert Lombardi refuses comment to the newspaper.

Campbell said he will be speaking to his attorney about when he can expect the original documents he requested from the PIAA.

Campbell said he was saddened because PIAA spent money on attorney fees, the same money PIAA collects from taxpayers.

"That's the shameful part of this," he said. "We paid twice for this."

Someone spent thousands of dollars to get access to the documents? What kind of wild misappropriation of funds are we talking here? The way this guy talks PIAA fatcats are out there spending money on mansions and women.....what am I missing?
 

Nittany1865Farmer

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,249
1,899
113
Someone spent thousands of dollars to get access to the documents? What kind of wild misappropriation of funds are we talking here? The way this guy talks PIAA fatcats are out there spending money on mansions and women.....what am I missing?
I thought the same thing. What is the guy digging for besides food and drink expense vouchers?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Karl_Havok

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
3,361
6,911
113
Someone spent thousands of dollars to get access to the documents? What kind of wild misappropriation of funds are we talking here? The way this guy talks PIAA fatcats are out there spending money on mansions and women.....what am I missing?

I'm not sure what he's looking to find but if he wants to spend his own money fighting this then I have no problem with that. And frankly I think he's right in that the records should be made publicly available under the RTK laws. And if he makes the RTK request, gets the records and find nothing then he wasted his own money, which he is free to do.

However, if he finds that things were not done on the up and up then I think it's money well spent. There is far too much corruption that goes on behind closed doors when people are given any amount of power so I feel like this is a win for the public.
 

TheBigUglies

Well-known member
Oct 26, 2021
1,062
1,668
113
Since PA is such a corrupt state I am guessing this guy heard of shenanigans going on in the PIAA(which I am sure we have all suspected for several decades now) and this guy wants to bring a spotlight public institution(that rules all of PA high school sports) in hopes of maybe making it better? Just spit balling here. I am sure there are good people at the PIAA that have nothing but keeping high school sports, athlete safety, and fair play as its top priority. I would be curios to see what kind of kickbacks sites got from hosting PIAA championships and the outrageous admission prices they charge for district playoffs(which I was told by people working at the school that the host school doesn't see any of but I don't know how true that is).
 

TheBigUglies

Well-known member
Oct 26, 2021
1,062
1,668
113
I'm not sure what he's looking to find but if he wants to spend his own money fighting this then I have no problem with that. And frankly I think he's right in that the records should be made publicly available under the RTK laws. And if he makes the RTK request, gets the records and find nothing then he wasted his own money, which he is free to do.

However, if he finds that things were not done on the up and up then I think it's money well spent. There is far too much corruption that goes on behind closed doors when people are given any amount of power so I feel like this is a win for the public.
Yeah, they should fall under the RTK and by them not turning over documents when a request is made certainly gives the appearance they are hiding something.
 

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,852
15,702
113
Since PA is such a corrupt state I am guessing this guy heard of shenanigans going on in the PIAA(which I am sure we have all suspected for several decades now) and this guy wants to bring a spotlight public institution(that rules all of PA high school sports) in hopes of maybe making it better? Just spit balling here. I am sure there are good people at the PIAA that have nothing but keeping high school sports, athlete safety, and fair play as its top priority. I would be curios to see what kind of kickbacks sites got from hosting PIAA championships and the outrageous admission prices they charge for district playoffs(which I was told by people working at the school that the host school doesn't see any of but I don't know how true that is).

How well do you think this corruption is documented? And what rules are there around the spending of this money? Anything preventing them from paying a site to host an event?
 

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
17,676
26,682
113
So much time and money spent to uncover what amount to nothing more than misunderstandings.
 

Nittany1865Farmer

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,249
1,899
113
So much time and money spent to uncover what amount to nothing more than misunderstandings.
Very true. The Buffalo Wild Wings at Williamsport is not even that good. You think the PIAA would be better patrons of finer B-Dub eateries than that one.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

Nothing Special

Active member
Dec 14, 2021
172
273
63
Don't know how it works within District 4, but the PIAA pays the host site, game workers and officials for all state-level events. A little confused with the statement that PIAA collects money from tax payers. Maybe the dues that schools pay? All other monies is revenue from athletic events and contracts with business entities.

Sounds like this started as a concern within District 4, maybe there's more to it.
 

Piketownman

Active member
Oct 8, 2021
169
347
63
I'm not sure what he's looking to find but if he wants to spend his own money fighting this then I have no problem with that. And frankly I think he's right in that the records should be made publicly available under the RTK laws. And if he makes the RTK request, gets the records and find nothing then he wasted his own money, which he is free to do.

However, if he finds that things were not done on the up and up then I think it's money well spent. There is far too much corruption that goes on behind closed doors when people are given any amount of power so I feel like this is a win for the public.
Maybe his kid was denied a transfer for athletic reasons 🤷🏻‍♂️
 

MtNittany

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,633
2,216
113
Very true. The Buffalo Wild Wings at Williamsport is not even that good. You think the PIAA would be better patrons of finer B-Dub eateries than that one.....
It's less than not even that good. It's bad. Rivals is a mile away and has better, cheaper wings anyway.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Nittany1865Farmer
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login