So how is a penalty called …

DAWGSANDSAINTS

Well-known member
Oct 10, 2022
1,677
1,430
113
On a play that was ruled down by contact?
At that point, the play should have been dead and stopped.
I don’t get the personal foul penalty on the O on a dead ball.
 

DAWGSANDSAINTS

Well-known member
Oct 10, 2022
1,677
1,430
113
But the play after the fact - if called correctly as down as they reviewed, would have never happened and thus no penalty- 15 yards or half the distance whatever it was.
 

DesotoCountyDawg

Well-known member
Nov 16, 2005
22,114
9,472
113
But the play after the fact - if called correctly as down as they reviewed, would have never happened and thus no penalty- 15 yards or half the distance whatever it was.
It’s a dead ball foul so it doesn’t matter if the play happened or not.

If it wasn’t that way then players would have free reign to do whatever.
 

UpTheMiddlex3Punt

Well-known member
May 28, 2007
16,714
1,903
113
Dead ball fouls are considered serious enough that it doesn't matter what happened during the play. Let's say a defender picks off a pass (but was actually slightly out of bounds which was only seen later on review) and the returning team holds while the defense returns it for a touchdown. After the play, an offensive lineman puts a cheap shot on the returner and draws an unsportsmanlike conduct foul. Upon review, the touchdown and interception are negated. Assessing the holding penalty makes no sense because it was a live ball foul that occurred in the context of the play and there's nowhere to really assess the penalty from. The unsportsmanlike conduct penalty stands even though the lineman probably wouldn't have delivered that cheap shot if it were simply an incomplete pass. However, it doesn't really matter why the offending player delivered the hit. It can be assessed as a fifteen yard penalty after the previous play completed, whether it's a pick six, an interception with a return because by a holding call, or an incomplete pass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: drumrcraig
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login