Still Some Concerns With Run Game?

Steelhead52

Member
Sep 23, 2021
77
175
33
It's pretty hard to NitPick Saturday's results. Some "experts" were calling for an upset. The offense moved creatively. The whole team was fun to watch on both sides of the ball. My concern after game 1 is still the run game. I know the o-line which played well is a work in progress with 3 new starters but I'm still expecting more out of the guards and center. Take away Singleton's 2 long runs and Allar's tuck and runs and we averaged 1.7 yards per carry. Even Singleton's explosive touchdown run was kind of triggered by the right tackle making a great block down the line with the TE sealing the other end of the hole giving Singleton a beautiful lane. But with two backs like Allen and Singleton, we have way too many runs stuffed at the line considering the caliber of those backs. I would appreciate some expert opinion on the issues. I was a player in high school and O-line was always the most complex to me. It just seems that if those 1-2 yard runs become 4-5 yard runs, this offense will really explode. It just seems we can't dominate in the middle (guards and center) and that always bites us against the great teams. One thing I really did like is that when we were 3rd and 7 it felt like the first down was achievable where last year, not so much.
 

NavyBlue

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2021
1,188
2,313
113
It's pretty hard to NitPick Saturday's results. Some "experts" were calling for an upset. The offense moved creatively. The whole team was fun to watch on both sides of the ball. My concern after game 1 is still the run game. I know the o-line which played well is a work in progress with 3 new starters but I'm still expecting more out of the guards and center. Take away Singleton's 2 long runs and Allar's tuck and runs and we averaged 1.7 yards per carry. Even Singleton's explosive touchdown run was kind of triggered by the right tackle making a great block down the line with the TE sealing the other end of the hole giving Singleton a beautiful lane. But with two backs like Allen and Singleton, we have way too many runs stuffed at the line considering the caliber of those backs. I would appreciate some expert opinion on the issues. I was a player in high school and O-line was always the most complex to me. It just seems that if those 1-2 yard runs become 4-5 yard runs, this offense will really explode. It just seems we can't dominate in the middle (guards and center) and that always bites us against the great teams. One thing I really did like is that when we were 3rd and 7 it felt like the first down was achievable where last year, not so much.
I think it's too early to start worrying, but here are some other numbers to say what you did. Interesting that in 2023, Singleton/Allen/Potts averaged 4.54 ypc, had a median carry of 4 yards and a most common (mode) carry of 5 yards against WVU. With the 2 long runs this year, the ypc was 4.93, but the median was only 2 yards and the mode was 1. Yea for the explosive plays!
 

Nitt1300

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
5,206
9,894
113
I don't think that you can do that (take the big gains out of your evaluation)

It's too early to make any sweeping observations, but anytime that you have as balanced an attack as we had Saturday, that's a pretty good indication of being on the right track.
 

PSU87

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,715
3,511
113
It's pretty hard to NitPick Saturday's results. Some "experts" were calling for an upset. The offense moved creatively. The whole team was fun to watch on both sides of the ball. My concern after game 1 is still the run game. I know the o-line which played well is a work in progress with 3 new starters but I'm still expecting more out of the guards and center. Take away Singleton's 2 long runs and Allar's tuck and runs and we averaged 1.7 yards per carry. Even Singleton's explosive touchdown run was kind of triggered by the right tackle making a great block down the line with the TE sealing the other end of the hole giving Singleton a beautiful lane. But with two backs like Allen and Singleton, we have way too many runs stuffed at the line considering the caliber of those backs. I would appreciate some expert opinion on the issues. I was a player in high school and O-line was always the most complex to me. It just seems that if those 1-2 yard runs become 4-5 yard runs, this offense will really explode. It just seems we can't dominate in the middle (guards and center) and that always bites us against the great teams. One thing I really did like is that when we were 3rd and 7 it felt like the first down was achievable where last year, not so much.
While you're not wrong per se, last year we had a middling run game and almost no explosive plays.
I will take a middling run game with explosive plays as a step in the right direction.
 

Bones80

Well-known member
Oct 19, 2021
990
1,424
93
I will gladly take averaging 1.3 yards per play with the exception of 4 long distance runs for TDS every day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbrown

PSUFTG2

Well-known member
Jul 1, 2023
700
1,569
93
Typical 1st game - always some good and some that needs work.

The good:
Two long runs from Singleton: Good, yes, thank you! Very much missing last year, for any number of reasons.

The Needs Work:
Other than those two carries: 30 carries by the three RBs - evenly distributed among Singleton (11), Allen (10), and Wallace (9) - for a total of 78 yards: Needs to be better and more consistently productive to have an effective run game.
 

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,896
15,767
113
Typical 1st game - always some good and some that needs work.

The good:
Two long runs from Singleton: Good, yes, thank you! Very much missing last year, for any number of reasons.

The Needs Work:
Other than those two carries: 30 carries by the three RBs - evenly distributed among Singleton (11), Allen (10), and Wallace (9) - for a total of 78 yards: Needs to be better and more consistently productive to have an effective run game.

Yeah, but the run game is a boxing match; you keep hitting the body and after they’re worn down and sore you go for the knock out. So, prefer to think there is some strategy here. YPC is misleading - it’s about points.
 

PhillyBillyReprise

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2021
583
1,000
93
If the opponent plays to stop the run, you
pass. If the pass works, the next opponent plays to stop the pass and runs open up. Then the next opponent has to worry about the run and the pass. The pass and run both open up.
 

BiochemPSU

Well-known member
Oct 30, 2021
941
1,240
93
We now have two very experienced RBs back there plus a QB with experience who looks more comfortable and in control. Singleton looks like he actually cares this year, finally. I saw some stat during the game that he didn't have a single run of 40+ yards all of last year. He is way more patient and disciplined now, which will give him the chance to pop a few each game. This may be the case where this season the RBs make the O-line look good. I hate those delayed read/mesh handoff things that we love to do when Saquon was here, but it may not matter against anyone not named OSU.
 

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
17,755
26,776
113
Time to move on from Kotelnicki. I’ve seen enough. We gave him a chance.
 

Bvillebaron

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,643
1,793
113
We now have two very experienced RBs back there plus a QB with experience who looks more comfortable and in control. Singleton looks like he actually cares this year, finally. I saw some stat during the game that he didn't have a single run of 40+ yards all of last year. He is way more patient and disciplined now, which will give him the chance to pop a few each game. This may be the case where this season the RBs make the O-line look good. I hate those delayed read/mesh handoff things that we love to do when Saquon was here, but it may not matter against anyone not named OSU.
Singleton may not have had a great year last year but implying he didn’t care last year is ridiculous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Whart and LionJim

Bwifan

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,580
2,839
113
It's pretty hard to NitPick Saturday's results. Some "experts" were calling for an upset. The offense moved creatively. The whole team was fun to watch on both sides of the ball. My concern after game 1 is still the run game. I know the o-line which played well is a work in progress with 3 new starters but I'm still expecting more out of the guards and center. Take away Singleton's 2 long runs and Allar's tuck and runs and we averaged 1.7 yards per carry. Even Singleton's explosive touchdown run was kind of triggered by the right tackle making a great block down the line with the TE sealing the other end of the hole giving Singleton a beautiful lane. But with two backs like Allen and Singleton, we have way too many runs stuffed at the line considering the caliber of those backs. I would appreciate some expert opinion on the issues. I was a player in high school and O-line was always the most complex to me. It just seems that if those 1-2 yard runs become 4-5 yard runs, this offense will really explode. It just seems we can't dominate in the middle (guards and center) and that always bites us against the great teams. One thing I really did like is that when we were 3rd and 7 it felt like the first down was achievable where last year, not so much.
I would have more concern if it was Akron. WVU was not a pushover. The run game will come over the next several weeks.
 

Drunkatmydesk

New member
Jul 3, 2023
8
19
3
If the opponent plays to stop the run, you
pass. If the pass works, the next opponent plays to stop the pass and runs open up. Then the next opponent has to worry about the run and the pass. The pass and run both open up.
This ^^^ Once pass was established, run game opened up!
Also …. First time in years that I thought we looked like a well coached team.
 

J.E.B

Well-known member
Oct 30, 2021
1,697
2,261
113
Good first game but keep it real until they travel to USC on the second weekend in October. Polls mean little until October. By then we’ll know who’s got it and who doesn’t.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

leinbacker

Well-known member
Oct 13, 2021
2,075
3,355
113
Good first game but keep it real until they travel to USC on the second weekend in October. Polls mean little until October. By then we’ll know who’s got it and who doesn’t.
By the time that game is played, USC will be battle tested against LSU, Michigan, and Wisconsin. PSU on the other hand plays Bowling Green or something.
 

Psu00

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,253
1,783
113
Good first game but keep it real until they travel to USC on the second weekend in October. Polls mean little until October. By then we’ll know who’s got it and who doesn’t.

True. After watching SC last night they seem much improved. That game will really tell a lot with regard to PSU’s progress.
 

bbrown

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
10,223
21,519
113
It's pretty hard to NitPick Saturday's results. Some "experts" were calling for an upset. The offense moved creatively. The whole team was fun to watch on both sides of the ball. My concern after game 1 is still the run game. I know the o-line which played well is a work in progress with 3 new starters but I'm still expecting more out of the guards and center. Take away Singleton's 2 long runs and Allar's tuck and runs and we averaged 1.7 yards per carry. Even Singleton's explosive touchdown run was kind of triggered by the right tackle making a great block down the line with the TE sealing the other end of the hole giving Singleton a beautiful lane. But with two backs like Allen and Singleton, we have way too many runs stuffed at the line considering the caliber of those backs. I would appreciate some expert opinion on the issues. I was a player in high school and O-line was always the most complex to me. It just seems that if those 1-2 yard runs become 4-5 yard runs, this offense will really explode. It just seems we can't dominate in the middle (guards and center) and that always bites us against the great teams. One thing I really did like is that when we were 3rd and 7 it felt like the first down was achievable where last year, not so much.
A couple things. We had some OL that missed parts of training camp, Donkoh for one, and we had a lot of new starters. IMO they did pretty well.
I hate the "just take away his long runs" Yea, you can't do that. They happened, one was a score and the other led to a score. I mean you take away the big runs Barry Sanders wouldn't be in the HOF. Plus those big runs force you to change your defense and maybe not have as many in the box. Also Kayton is not up to full speed yet. So I view it as a very good start but still a work in progress.
 

BCrum

Well-known member
Aug 19, 2022
647
1,340
93
Sounds a lot like the Saquan Barkley era.

+ 1, + 1, - 2, + 3, +45 TD.

I for 1 will take it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

J.E.B

Well-known member
Oct 30, 2021
1,697
2,261
113
Franklin is now 41-5 in the seasons first five games not including CoVid year. Five times he has started 5-0, 3 times 4-1, and once 3-2 which was the B1G championship team!
 

Bwifan

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,580
2,839
113
A couple things. We had some OL that missed parts of training camp, Donkoh for one, and we had a lot of new starters. IMO they did pretty well.
I hate the "just take away his long runs" Yea, you can't do that. They happened, one was a score and the other led to a score. I mean you take away the big runs Barry Sanders wouldn't be in the HOF. Plus those big runs force you to change your defense and maybe not have as many in the box. Also Kayton is not up to full speed yet. So I view it as a very good start but still a work in progress.
Exactly good point. You can't take away the short runs. Those are a major contributor to the long runs. You pound away and soften up the defense get them tired and you will break a long one. It's why good running teams stick with the run even if its not "successful" in the first half because the 2nd half it will start to pay dividends.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LB99 and bbrown

Nittany1865Farmer

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,251
1,906
113
The night before… baked beans and hot dogs. The next morning 2 cups of coffee. It never fails… they will have the runs all day!!!
I would recommend a steady diet of Taco Bell. Once that kicks in, nobody is gonna block you from your dash to the porcelain throne..
..
pipe GIF
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Bkmtnittany1

bdgan

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,325
2,265
113
It's pretty hard to NitPick Saturday's results. Some "experts" were calling for an upset. The offense moved creatively. The whole team was fun to watch on both sides of the ball. My concern after game 1 is still the run game. I know the o-line which played well is a work in progress with 3 new starters but I'm still expecting more out of the guards and center. Take away Singleton's 2 long runs and Allar's tuck and runs and we averaged 1.7 yards per carry. Even Singleton's explosive touchdown run was kind of triggered by the right tackle making a great block down the line with the TE sealing the other end of the hole giving Singleton a beautiful lane. But with two backs like Allen and Singleton, we have way too many runs stuffed at the line considering the caliber of those backs. I would appreciate some expert opinion on the issues. I was a player in high school and O-line was always the most complex to me. It just seems that if those 1-2 yard runs become 4-5 yard runs, this offense will really explode. It just seems we can't dominate in the middle (guards and center) and that always bites us against the great teams. One thing I really did like is that when we were 3rd and 7 it felt like the first down was achievable where last year, not so much.
It depends what you mean by concerned. This was just 1 game and I think it shows we should be clear favorites to win most of our games. It's not an indication that we're ready to beat USC & OSU.

Run game needs to be more consistent at getting 3+ ypc and pass game needs more than Wallace.