The most discouraging aspect of the 2021 football season?

PSUFTG

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
1,456
2,262
113
Look at the "devolvement" of the offense throughout the year.

Go back and look at the tape of the Auburn game - three games into Yurcich's tenure.
Did everything work - certainly not - but the varied pace, the diversity of sets and interesting combinations of play calls and formations. It was all very intelligently designed, and clearly showed a high degree of preparation and attention to detail.

By November? It looked like the most Pop Warner level offensive scheme in the country (much like the KirK C offense devolved into "Let's run QB power with Levis 25 times a game" by the end of 2020). The 2020 season, maybe, one can sort of excuse due to the distraction of COVID (though every other team in the country had to deal with that as well).

This year, no excuses. It was a complete mailing-it-in, for the second year in a row, particularly on the offensive side of the ball. Each Saturday the offense took the field looking as if they had simply packed up the gear from the previous week, taken a week off, and trotting back out there the following Saturday - unprepared, un-schemed, zero attention to detail or improvement. After the Iowa game - when there were several glaring concerns raised (including how to deal with Clifford's status), the staff spent the off week jetting (and helicoptering) around "recruiting". That was very telling - and the results were predictable. Maybe the most embarrassing loss in the last 50 years of Penn State football - to an awful Illinois team (on homecoming). Really sad to see, truly.
Mike Yurcich - like Kirk C before him - had both shown throughout their careers the ability to compose offenses that at least approached maximizing the output of their available talent. But something, something very systemic and pervasive, has dry-rotted the squad. That can only start from the top. How is that going to change?
It would be much easier to feel the program just needed a talent infusion or some such (relatively) easily addressable issue. But that is not the case, obviously. I get it.
 
Last edited:

Ram20

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
369
702
93
Every offense we have eventually reverts back to James franklin/Ricky Rahne ball. Hallmarks of that? Injured QB, QB draws, couple pointless shots down the field that never had a prayer, muddled up blocking schemes and ineffective run game. Over focus on getting the ball to one reciever. Many different coordinators, each with well called games, all end up back to Jimmy Franklin ball. Yes, very encouraged with MY early in the season and his work with Clifford. Yesterday, back to Clifford running around, confused, "add libbing" and then ultimately injured.
How allar decided to come play qb in this offense is besides me. I suppose he wants to be a cam newton clone and get pummeled 20 times a game.
 

PSUJam

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
10,537
18,798
113
Look at the "devolvement" of the offense throughout the year.

Go back and look at the tape of the Auburn game - three games into Yurcich's tenure.
Did everything work - certainly not - but the varied pace, the diversity of sets and interesting combinations of play calls and formations. It was all very intelligently designed, and clearly showed a high degree of preparation and attention to detail.

By November? It looked like the most Pop Warner level offensive scheme in the country (much like the KirK C offense devolved into "Let's run QB power with Levis 25 times a game" by the end of 2020). The 2020 season, maybe, one can sort of excuse due to the distraction of COVID (though every other team in the country had to deal with that as well).

This year, no excuses. It was a complete mailing-it-in, for the second year in a row, particularly on the offensive side of the ball. Each Saturday the offense took the field looking as if they had simply packed up the gear from the previous week, taken a week off, and trotting back out there the following Saturday - unprepared, un-schemed, zero attention to detail or improvement. After the Iowa game - when there were several glaring concerns raised (including how to deal with Clifford's status), the staff spent the off week jetting (and helicoptering) around "recruiting". That was very telling - and the results were predictable. Maybe the most embarrassing loss in the last 50 years of Penn State football - to an awful Illinois team (on homecoming). Really sad to see, truly.
Mike Yurcich - like Kirk C before him - had both shown throughout their careers the ability to compose offenses that at least approached maximizing the output of their available talent. But something, something very systemic and pervasive, has dry-rotted the squad. That can only start from the top. How is that going to change?
It would be much easier to feel the program just needed a talent infusion or some such (relatively) easily addressable issue. But that is not the case, obviously. I get it.
This was surprising to me:

'Penn State football only trailed at halftime three times during the 2021 season — by a combined 11 points. The Nittany Lions’ overall halftime margin was 141-82, but they lost six games."

 
  • Like
Reactions: PSU86 and SurgeOne

ManxomeLion

Well-known member
Aug 24, 2017
934
1,375
93
Throughout the regular season it was difficult to gauge improvement on offense with Clifford not being 100% healthy. The bowl performance though showed very little if any progress on offense. Issues like the oline seem systemic. With Clifford's return and Franklin's contract renewal not sure what will change.
 

PAgeologist

Active member
Oct 19, 2021
285
348
63
I agree. Wonder how long until Yurchich tells Franklin to go pound sand, take his chunk plays and shove them up his a**. Big OC positions open up every year and he wouldn't have to put up with Franklin's meddling.
 

ManxomeLion

Well-known member
Aug 24, 2017
934
1,375
93
I agree. Wonder how long until Yurchich tells Franklin to go pound sand, take his chunk plays and shove them up his a**. Big OC positions open up every year and he wouldn't have to put up with Franklin's meddling.
Well perhaps the silver lining is Mike Yurcich's allure certainly didn't go up in 2021. Not sure who would look at Penn State's 2021 offense and think "we want that". (With the exception of the NY Giants)
 

PAgeologist

Active member
Oct 19, 2021
285
348
63
Well perhaps the silver lining is Mike Yurcich's allure certainly didn't go up in 2021. Not sure who would look at Penn State's 2021 offense and think "we want that". (With the exception of the NY Giants)
True. Which is also why Yurchich might leave sooner than later. His stock goes down every game with Franklin's meddling.
 

CDLionFL

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
1,524
2,282
113
To me, the biggest disappointment was the offensive line. Despite having experience returning with a full supply of offseason practices and meetings, this unit may have been WORSE than 2020's edition. When the o-line sucks, the running game suffers and then the QB is running for his life because pass protection is no good. What's funny is that in the first 5-6 games of the year, I thought the pass protection was at least pretty decent but their run blocking was atrocious. When we couldn't run the ball against freakin Villanova, I had a feeling that it was going to be curtains for the rest of the season. Either we have just crap players at those positions or they're not being developed the way they should be to make them a cohesive unit that wins the line of scrimmage on a consistent basis. When teams struggle, everyone wants to look at the shiny objects like QB or playcalling or lack of defensive stars but a team's success begins and ends with the guys up front and PSU has struggled in this department for a long time.
 

PSUFTG

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
1,456
2,262
113
Well perhaps the silver lining is Mike Yurcich's allure certainly didn't go up in 2021. Not sure who would look at Penn State's 2021 offense and think "we want that". (With the exception of the NY Giants)
Yurcich's past track record would generate plenty of offers for him, despite this one year Dog's Breakfast at Penn State. Hell, Penn State hired Manny Diaz as their defensive coordinator (Maybe that isn't a great example? :) )
 

WestSideLion

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
3,254
3,586
113
Throughout the regular season it was difficult to gauge improvement on offense with Clifford not being 100% healthy. The bowl performance though showed very little if any progress on offense. Issues like the oline seem systemic. With Clifford's return and Franklin's contract renewal not sure what will change.
I think Clifford bears much of the blame. He got hurt…unlucky, but he was our only viable QB. He also was responsible for many of the reads on offense. There was improvement there early in the year, but late on, it was the same old with Sean.

The staff needs to significantly upgrade the QB spot. Clifford coming back for a sixth year clouds that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSU86 and JoeBot409

VaDave4PSU

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,989
2,322
113
The air seemed to go out of the team after Clifford missed a wide open Johnson and the poorly executed fake punt.

The team wasn't gassed at that point. Halftime was shortly after. Ark went to the zone read game and dominated. 3rd quarter probably zapped em.

I'd have taken a time out and tried something different, but the one time we lined up 8 in the box, they instantly went to a quick out pass for 8 yards burning the soft coverage.

Sometimes, you are just outmanned.

The biggest white flag wave was when CV came in and handed off the ball with us down 14, 8 minutes left. Our RBs had 8 rushing attempts prior to that, mostly successful ones. And to run twice on first down at a critical point of the game where we should have been running the 2 minute drill...

I don't know what day the players told JF they were opting out, but that is the day this game was lost. One month to prepare and we didn't try anything new. Knowing full well that Ark would run right at us and we didn't get aggressive and force them to run against 9 in the box.

Pitiful coaching effort even if we were outmanned.
 

JoeBot409

Well-known member
Oct 26, 2021
681
525
93
I think Clifford bears much of the blame. He got hurt…unlucky, but he was our only viable QB. He also was responsible for many of the reads on offense. There was improvement there early in the year, but late on, it was the same old with Sean.

The staff needs to significantly upgrade the QB spot. Clifford coming back for a sixth year clouds that.
He might be coming back, but the coaches don't have to play him.
 

CyphaPSU

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
860
1,397
93
This was surprising to me:

'Penn State football only trailed at halftime three times during the 2021 season — by a combined 11 points. The Nittany Lions’ overall halftime margin was 141-82, but they lost six games."

I’m old enough to remember when the hallmark of the PSU offense was the opposite. As frustrating as it was during the second quarter of games, PSU still won a conference title doing it. CJF and co. need to get back to it.
 

PSUMichFan

Member
Oct 28, 2021
37
74
18
Losing total confidence in our coaching staff. The MSU game (although snowing and bad weather plagued both teams) totally did it for me. MSU's secondary was very poor at pass defense and JF decides to run near 50% of the time; when we don't have a running game or an O-line to support it!!! Go figure! Sorry but James Franklin is never going to be a minority coach that wins a National Championship at the Division 1 level! Based on what we witnessed on New Years day and the negative press I'm reading about our new defensive coordinator, 2022 may be a rough year!
 

Tom_PSU

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2021
1,125
3,563
113
Jumping wad of tobacco juice spit. We can argue all year long, but until we can actually run the ball nothings going to change on offense. Not next year, not ever. Holy Mother of Starkville even Mike Leach the mad bombers team can run the ball in a pinch. We can’t, so we suck when we play a team with a pulse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LookSharp

FrontierLion

Active member
Oct 12, 2021
234
451
63
Could it be that Sean Clifford doesn’t comprehend the offense as well as he should? OP stated how the offense never seemed to evolve over the course of the season as it should have. Every week new concepts / plays / formations are usually introduced. For the second straight year, under different OC’s, this didnt happen.

Maybe Cliff just doesn’t have a grasp on the concepts and It limits what the OC feels comfortable with on the field? I certainly don’t know if this is true, just throwing it out there as a possible explanation.
 

loinfan01

Active member
Oct 25, 2021
148
271
63
The Rutgers game was the most discouraging aspect of the season. Not the result, not CV's performance. It was the fact that Penn State had someone who appeared to be a viable backup, yet he didn't see any action during the Iowa or Illinois games. Perhaps he wasn't ready, but I don't know that a few more weeks taking backup reps in practice is what put him over the top.
 

PSU87

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,655
3,375
113
Most discouraging to me is seeing the same things year after year despite new players, coordinators and position coaches
- poor tackling
- inability to run the ball
- no offensive flow....chunk plays surrounded by 10 inept plays
- blowing leads
 
  • Like
Reactions: ODShowtime

ManxomeLion

Well-known member
Aug 24, 2017
934
1,375
93
OP stated how the offense never seemed to evolve over the course of the season as it should have. Every week new concepts / plays / formations are usually introduced. For the second straight year, under different OC’s, this didnt happen.
Perhaps it was a softer schedule towards the end of 2020 but I definitely recall that the offense seemed to be coming together and improving.
In 2021 it was hard to tell if the offense was improving with Clifford banged up. The bowl game answered that question.... the offense seemed as discombobulated as ever.
 

LookSharp

Member
Oct 25, 2021
183
159
43
The most discouraging aspect of PSU football? I won't sugarcoat it. The contract extension without a doubt. That single act has the college football world, sans the PSU sycophants and xenophobes, scratching its collective head. I always felt CJF caught lightening in a bottle in 2016. My suspicion is confirmed with each subsequent snap of the football. Expect more Illinois-like losses as CJF's winning percentage slips below 66%. There's nothing like guaranteed income to motivate someone.

I never thought I'd see the day when I would pine for the head coaches of "lesser" programs, such as Baylor and Iowa State. Yet here we are. CJF is a good recruiter by non-SEC standards, but poor in preparation and even worse as a tactician. If you really watched other teams play then it wouldn't take eight years to come to the same conclusion.
 

PSUFTG

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
1,456
2,262
113
Perhaps it was a softer schedule towards the end of 2020 but I definitely recall that the offense seemed to be coming together and improving.
In 2021 it was hard to tell if the offense was improving with Clifford banged up. The bowl game answered that question.... the offense seemed as discombobulated as ever.
The back end of the 2020 schedule was a circus.
If one remembers, the Illinois team that came here for the season finale - which was a horrible team to start with - had fired their coach, and several of the top players on that team ("top" being a relative term) didn't even make the trip - because they simply didn't want to. They preferred to simply go home. That is the caliber of team Penn State was playing - and, if you recall, that junior varsity Illinois team actually put up some big offensive plays on Penn State early in the game.

The rest of those back-enders were a Michigan team (which won two games) that was in-and-out of COVID, and the Penn State game would prove to be the last game they played. - Rutgers, enough said - and Michigan State, another 2-win trainwreck that was dancing around COVID.
And all four of those games were competitive. Sure, you'd rather be on the winning side than the losing side, but those games showed absolutely nothing - and, in fact,
I believe Penn State's performance over most of the back half was actually worse than it was in Week 1. Week 1, against a pretty solid Indiana team where a lot of things bounced the wrong way for Penn State, was probably the BEST game Penn State played all year. Much like this year, where the second half against Wisconsin, and week three against Auburn were the high-water marks. That, peaking out in your first real game of the year, and then receding as you develop your squad, is not a positive indicator.
 
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login