Firstly I appreciate your input even after I self promoted. Genuinely I do. And as much as I wish the game was still centered the traditions, regionality and tribalism that way of the game is just no more like you said. Human nature to not like change but it has to happen.
Correct, change is apparent. Maybe this change is what younger fans want. Because let's be honest, what older people opine for is the tribalism, the 'us vs them', aspect of it. Portal hurts in this way, you can't even pretend that these are 'your guys'. And it seems students today care less about it than ever before, except for how it affects their next party. They just move on.
The days of 'following the program' and getting worked up over it are gone. The traditional signing days, crazy January visits, all gone. Hanging by a thread over a recruit, Chad Story pissing himself, etc. What TV has done is create this simple entertainment platform. It used to be about much more than that. But hey, the $$ says different. I mean I just described the NFL - entertainment - and they are the biggest sports business on the planet.
I still think, that even with rev share (or maybe especially with rev share)......if they'd work the portal back, and make you sit for a year again pre-graduation......that would restore order. It would work well with the 5 years of eligibility that we're about to receive. Then, fans that care about the program, but are disenfranchised with the sport in general....would come back. Just my theory. It would make it more 'college' again.
And for God's sake, fix the playoff by either going to 16 or taking out conference title byes. You can't really stabilize conference realignment, is what it is.