Those 3 options are really all nonexistent.
We’re not a “flip the roster through the portal” type of school, for obvious reasons. And even if we were, we were already very late in the portal cycle when Arnett came on board, and we were already past it when Barbay joined.
Hire an OC with a proven track record? Sure, like Kendall Briles? We tried and failed. Anyone else with a proven track record that we didn’t call?
Regarding the final option….its been said before but people still just don’t get it…there is no other variation / knock-off / derivative / whatever of the Air Raid that works with Rogers. Rogers was a Leach Air Raid archetype, to a T. Go look at every Leach QB ever. All of them are unathletic, awkward, bumbling, non-physical players with no real measurables that nobody wanted….except they could all throw pretty accurately and on time on short and intermediate routes. With those guys, you throw the ball 70 f-ing percent of the time because you have to. It neutralizes every talent disadvantage. All those elite LB’s and DE’s can’t blitz because you’ll get eaten alive on the checkdowns. That’s what made the Leach Air Raid what it was, the ability to get above average results out of players who, quite frankly, aren’t good. Mediocre talent at QB could be replaced over and over with more mediocre QB talent, with consistent results. That’s why Leach worked at MSU, because our offensive recruiting has sucked left hind tit for 120 years compared to our league counterparts, and there is no sign of that ever changing….but it didn’t matter with his system.
In today’s college football….if you aren’t Alabama or UGA or Ohio State, you can’t run the ball at all if you don’t have a running QB. That means us this year. You go to a “modified Air Raid” and ask Will to start checking into zone reads and shít, how well do you really think that’s going to work? There was no transition to a system that works with this godawful group of offensive talent. That is THE problem, whether anyone wants to admit it or not. Blame Leach or Moorhead or our boosters or whoever, but that is the real issue. We don’t have good football players on offense, at all, outside of Tulu and Marks. And I’ll tell you two people who certainly aren’t responsible for that….Arnett and Barbay.
That doesn’t mean I love the job they are doing so far. Hell, the defense has been pure trash, too, which is the biggest indictment on Arnett that nobody really wants to talk about for whatever reason. But people don’t really seem to grasp how much of a shìt hand they were dealt with this awful roster on offense.