College Softball Pitcher Rankings: May 2025

Who are the best pitchers in college softball heading into May? We dive into the numbers for Softball America’s in-season position rankings. We also incorporate the eye-test and strength of schedule in our rankings. We broke down our rankings between pitchers and two-way players. NiJaree Canady, Karlyn Pickens and Lyndsey Grein continue to lead the group in the circle. While Jordy Bahl and Devyn Netz are still in the Player of the Year race.