Am I the only one concerned?

FootballLVR

Member
Sep 25, 2023
398
237
43
We all joke about FSU and that team in the upstate are getting left out of conferences. We laugh that they are stuck in the ACC. My concern is that the SEC will start culling teams that are underperforming and pick up teams that bring more eyes to TV's. We could be one of the culls. B1G could start culling too to strengthen their teams. Maybe I'm wrong and hope I am. We need to perform better to keep this possibility out of the options.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spot The Ball

18IsTheMan

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2022
14,149
12,144
113
Well, of course that’s going to happen. Money is the name of game, increasingly so. How much longer are the revenue generators going to be content sharing revenue with teams like us and Mississippi State and Vandy?

i’m not really concerned about it. In the sense of whether or not it’s going to happen. It’s just a matter of when.
 

KingWard

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2022
6,887
7,218
113
We all joke about FSU and that team in the upstate are getting left out of conferences. We laugh that they are stuck in the ACC. My concern is that the SEC will start culling teams that are underperforming and pick up teams that bring more eyes to TV's. We could be one of the culls. B1G could start culling too to strengthen their teams. Maybe I'm wrong and hope I am. We need to perform better to keep this possibility out of the options.
I could see it happening once conferences hit saturation at ,say, 20 to 24 teams. If I were the SEC, I could see me taking the opportunity to give our @$$e$ the boot in favor of a football school of superior relevance and recent achievement. It would depend on what the optimal number of teams is in the future. Every league is going to have some teams or schools worth culling, but suitable replacements might not be available.
 

gamecock stock

Well-known member
Jan 21, 2022
2,572
2,296
113
We all joke about FSU and that team in the upstate are getting left out of conferences. We laugh that they are stuck in the ACC. My concern is that the SEC will start culling teams that are underperforming and pick up teams that bring more eyes to TV's. We could be one of the culls. B1G could start culling too to strengthen their teams. Maybe I'm wrong and hope I am. We need to perform better to keep this possibility out of the options.
Don't know. But who wants to take that chance? That's why I say Beamer better win next season.....tough schedule or not. It will be his 4th season. Drink produced in his 4th season at Missouri. Kiffin began producing at Ole Miss in season 2.
 

Jonesz2

Joined Aug 9, 2005
Jan 21, 2022
1,362
1,982
113
We all joke about FSU and that team in the upstate are getting left out of conferences. We laugh that they are stuck in the ACC. My concern is that the SEC will start culling teams that are underperforming and pick up teams that bring more eyes to TV's. We could be one of the culls. B1G could start culling too to strengthen their teams. Maybe I'm wrong and hope I am. We need to perform better to keep this possibility out of the options.
My concern is we will never take fb seriously and not be culled
 

1vagamecock

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2022
1,300
922
113
I could see it happening once conferences hit saturation at ,say, 20 to 24 teams. If I were the SEC, I could see me taking the opportunity to give our @$$e$ the boot in favor of a football school of superior relevance and recent achievement. It would depend on what the optimal number of teams is in the future. Every league is going to have some teams or schools worth culling, but suitable replacements might not be available.
Queue the "Relegation zone" ideas again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingWard

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
If y’all think that 20-24 teams are just going to break away and just ignore money programs like us generate you’re delusional. RELAX!! The SEC extended us an invite for a reason. On the field results aren’t going to dictate this. $$ is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VZVZ

Gradstudent

Joined Feb 11, 2006
Feb 2, 2022
1,130
1,716
113
Vandy has been a member since 1932. SEC is more then football.

 

Kawalski

Well-known member
Jan 30, 2022
1,030
2,683
113
Its a moot point, we cant keep our top players in this system, they are killing us so we are screwed in conference. Our damn kicker transferred for Gods sake! You people blaming Beamer are barking up the wrong tree, Every time we start to build some continuity its gets shattered by schools with more money or a better History. NIL sucks and the NCAA better do something about this. Why cant they reinstate the transfer rule where you have to sit a year? That would put an end to most of this crap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nm7710

KingWard

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2022
6,887
7,218
113
Its a moot point, we cant keep our top players in this system, they are killing us so we are screwed in conference. Our damn kicker transferred for Gods sake! You people blaming Beamer are barking up the wrong tree, Every time we start to build some continuity its gets shattered by schools with more money or a better History. NIL sucks and the NCAA better do something about this. Why cant they reinstate the transfer rule where you have to sit a year? That would put an end to most of this crap.
That's toothpaste back in the tube. Unlikely, difficult, and not in the spirit of making players equal with coaches, which is what all this is about, however stupid it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mickray

Atlanta_Cock

Member
May 29, 2023
215
137
43
That's toothpaste back in the tube. Unlikely, difficult, and not in the spirit of making players equal with coaches, which is what all this is about, however stupid it is.
Correct. For those complaining, I suggest you do as I am considering. Find a new sport or a new hobby. CFB is no longer fun for me. We've never really been anything above mediocre, but we are now a permanent have not under the current system. As KingWard sez, that toothpaste is out of the tube.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingWard

Big JC

Well-known member
May 12, 2023
1,240
905
113
The most likely course for the future is the 60 or so team super conference for football only that is not affiliated with the NCAA or conferences in any way. These top 60 teams will have a true playoff to determine a legitimate national champion. All other sports will be NCAA sports and will be affiliated with conferences and those conferences will return to their logical geographic nature. The remaining 70+ football programs will compete within the conferences and will play in traditional bowls at the end of the season.

Depending on how you see it; the good or bad news is, USC will most likely NOT be in the new super conference. USC, Miss St., UK, Vandy, Missouri, Arkansas and possibly Ole Miss will remain in the "new" SEC.
 

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
The most likely course for the future is the 60 or so team super conference for football only that is not affiliated with the NCAA or conferences in any way. These top 60 teams will have a true playoff to determine a legitimate national champion. All other sports will be NCAA sports and will be affiliated with conferences and those conferences will return to their logical geographic nature. The remaining 70+ football programs will compete within the conferences and will play in traditional bowls at the end of the season.

Depending on how you see it; the good or bad news is, USC will most likely NOT be in the new super conference. USC, Miss St., UK, Vandy, Missouri, Arkansas and possibly Ole Miss will remain in the "new" SEC.
You understand there are only 65 P5 teams in the country right? What you are proposing is literally what we have right now, more or less. The only difference is that the G5 would have their own championship, which is probably a good idea.
 

Yard_Pimps

Well-known member
Jul 11, 2022
1,050
557
113
Its a moot point, we cant keep our top players in this system, they are killing us so we are screwed in conference. Our damn kicker transferred for Gods sake! You people blaming Beamer are barking up the wrong tree, Every time we start to build some continuity its gets shattered by schools with more money or a better History. NIL sucks and the NCAA better do something about this. Why cant they reinstate the transfer rule where you have to sit a year? That would put an end to most of this crap.
Because you want to reinstate that rule and they are currently fighting the single transfer rule in court. There is an injunction right now allowing everyone to transfer as much as they want. The ncaa is powerless.
 

Prestonyte

Well-known member
Jun 1, 2022
5,261
5,214
113
Because you want to reinstate that rule and they are currently fighting the single transfer rule in court. There is an injunction right now allowing everyone to transfer as much as they want. The ncaa is powerless.
Transferring is one thing and should not be restricted - transferring and playing NCAA football is another and should be regulated by the NCAA.
 

SuperCock99

Member
Dec 11, 2023
158
115
43
If they kick anyone out for under performing. Hopefully, Vanderbilt will be the first and only initial target.

I don’t have much faith in our Univ. fighting that fight with Tanner at lead. If you ask me, he is to happy-go-lucky to be a D1 Athletic Director.
 
Last edited:

Big JC

Well-known member
May 12, 2023
1,240
905
113
You understand there are only 65 P5 teams in the country right? What you are proposing is literally what we have right now, more or less. The only difference is that the G5 would have their own championship, which is probably a good idea.
I'm not proposing anything, there is already talk of something like that happening. If you think all the current P5 programs will be in the new super conference and none of the current G5 programs will move up, you will likely be surprised. I can assure you Illinois, Rutgers, Vandy, Wake Forest, Stanford, etc. will not be in the super conference and USC's football history doesn't put it in the top tier of football programs.
 

Yard_Pimps

Well-known member
Jul 11, 2022
1,050
557
113
Transferring is one thing and should not be restricted - transferring and playing NCAA football is another and should be regulated by the NCAA.
I get what you’re saying, I just don’t know if the court is going to see it that way. We will have to wait and see. That case is working its way through right now. If the court rules players can transfer as many times as they like I don’t see how you regulate it at all.
 
Nov 27, 2022
28
43
13
The NIl
And Portal combined
Is gonna kill the sport anyway.
Until ESPN starts paying the players equally l.

The SEC will not get rid of SC, for one the best teams have to have someone to beat.
If you took the top 20 and put them in the same conference at the end
Of the year 10 of the teams would have bad records. Now what I see is SC becoming a feeder to the bigger schools. Honestly ring independent isn’t a bad idea. If you have good leadership.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
I'm not proposing anything, there is already talk of something like that happening. If you think all the current P5 programs will be in the new super conference and none of the current G5 programs will move up, you will likely be surprised. I can assure you Illinois, Rutgers, Vandy, Wake Forest, Stanford, etc. will not be in the super conference and USC's football history doesn't put it in the top tier of football programs.
It’s not about success on the field. None of this is. It’s all about $$.
 

mchuckyz

Joined Nov 27, 2004
Feb 2, 2022
495
1,081
93
I don't think a conference can be successful if it is highly top heavy with strong teams. How will they get to the playoff if they are beating each other.
 

Big JC

Well-known member
May 12, 2023
1,240
905
113
It’s not about success on the field. None of this is. It’s all about $$.
You are absolutely correct and success on the field leads directly to more money. Vanderbilt is loaded with money, so is Stanford but neither one is going to be in a super conference of top tier football programs because they don't have huge fan bases and tv audiences. Carolina is not a big money program and doesn't draw a huge tv audience. The tv draw is as big or bigger a factor than the money the school has. Be honest, what tv audience does Carolina football really draw? I would venture Clemson is a bigger tv draw than Carolina. Miss St and UK are in the same boat when it comes to college football.
 

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
You are absolutely correct and success on the field leads directly to more money. Vanderbilt is loaded with money, so is Stanford but neither one is going to be in a super conference of top tier football programs because they don't have huge fan bases and tv audiences. Carolina is not a big money program and doesn't draw a huge tv audience. The tv draw is as big or bigger a factor than the money the school has. Be honest, what tv audience does Carolina football really draw? I would venture Clemson is a bigger tv draw than Carolina. Miss St and UK are in the same boat when it comes to college football.
We are consistently top 20-30 in value/revenue. Unfortunately, our on the field success hasn't lined up with that. 247 had a ranking at the end of 2021 that had us at 16. Clem was 25. It's OK to say positive things about the program you're a fan of sometimes, I promise.

 

VZVZ

Garnet Trust Supporter
Jun 20, 2023
2,359
3,776
113
Nobody is getting culled. USC is a major program.
 

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
The P5 just needs to break away from G5 in football. It makes zero sense that App St is competing for the same national championship as Bama.

And further to that point, $$ is destroying championship hopes for a lot of these teams. App St, for example, won 3 straight FCS championships in the mid 2000s. They moved to FBS in 2014. Since then, they've had 5 10+ win seasons. Sounds great. Their award for those seasons were Gasparilla Bowl, New Orleans Bowl, and Boca Raton Bowl wins against other G5 teams. App St moving to FBS secured their future for NEVER winning a NC again. The whole system is broken, and needs to be revamped.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mickray