No, they don't watch our team as much as we do. However, they do watch a lot of our team, certainly more than highlights. In addition, they watch us without emotion one way or the other. When the guy makes a mistake they don't hold it against him as much as MSU fans seem to.
According to you our fans are the ultimate authority on our players, coaches, and teams, or at least that's my interpretation of what you are saying. I don't buy that in all cases. Many times we have an in-depth knowledge of our team because we have watched a lot of their play, but oftentimes we aren't able to provide an objective point of view on our teams. By the same token, there are times when an outside source isn't knowlegdable and thus is unable to provide a good point of view, such as Rick Cleveland's "told you so" after we made our run in baseball. He doesn't follow college baseball as closely as others and thus his opinion on the situation wasn't based on anything more than his perception of events rather than what really happened.
Put it this way, when coaches around the league and commentators for Raycom praise Jamont they are not doing so based on a few highlights but rather based on seeing film of our games and watching him in person. I would be less inclined to listen to a Billy Packer type who I'd wager hasn't seen a whole lot of actual game footage of our team.