You're correct about that, because you're coming after me, as if I have some weird view about it. So I'll humor you, and hopefully you'll understand better.
I love baseball. I want to see it succeed. I wanted, for so long to see it become the #1 sport in America and remain that way. I loved the baseball card era. What we did up to 1994 worked, the system was good, from youth ball to high school to college to pro. But since then, baseball seems to be a crusade to destroy itself. The strike, steroids and then the analytics era. Then all that's happened with youth sports. College is still largely the same I'd think, maybe slightly better. I'm glad to see a little NIL infusion there to help with costs for the players. But anyway, THAT is why, because I care about it, but that care is eroding.
You know, I went by the local high school last night, and they had more people watching a lacrosse game than the baseball game? They were on adjacent fields, so it was easy to see. That's crazy to me, and a signal that something is grossly wrong.
And I'm not as concerned about the lessons and such - parents can pay their money for whatever they want. And at the end of the day, that's what you're paying for with travel ball - more games, and all the ancillary stuff that comes with that. And honestly, I've backed off of the specialization part, because there's a ton of ways to work around that (strength training, etc.).
But.........
My favorite are the stories about travel ball teams going across the country to be in same bracket as a team 10 miles away.
Has travel ball benefitted anyone other than the coaches, tournament organizers or Residence Inns?
Ever noticed how the tournaments are weekend only? Because that's the only time they can convince folks to travel and cram as many games in a weekend, to get the most money. Turf the fields so you can play in the rain. Also, that's really the reason why you have fall ball - because it's too hot to play during the summer all day long on Saturday/Sunday.
I don't know why we can't come up with a summer ball system, where they play games during the weeknights, all summer long (you know, like the actual colleges and pros do). Why do we have to do weekend tournaments in youth and high school? Well, besides money for tournaments and showcases, another big part of it is that folks are recruiting metrics now and not stats (analytical era).
All that to say, nobody seems to be changing it, so baseball will continue to degrade, kids will quit and there will be less fans, slowly but surely. It'll never bottom out though, so I certainly plan to make a little money in it for a while, and that's why I umpire games.