Interesting read:
- Thread starter PSUFTG2
- Start date
So after ten years Franklin is still digging out of that hole? Then he needs to dig faster. But maybe not and PSU is poised to challenge for conference and national championships? Check back this time next year.
Is an occassional win against a top 10 team too much to ask for? Especially when we match up well in everything outside of play calling?
Since 2016 Penn State's average recruiting ranking is 13.
Since 2016, Penn State's winning percentage puts them at #8 in the country.
By that measure, Franklin is outperforming his recruiting efforts and is "underpaid" if he is "only" the 10th highest paid coach.
If people want us to go from #13 to top 5 in recruiting and hold Franklin's feet to the fire with expectations of top 5 results, then start sending money to our NIL collective, because that's the name of the game these days.
FYI, I don't contribute to hazy, non-transparent organizations that use funds to bribe Johnny 5 star to come to Penn State instead of Ohio State. I accept that decision means maybe Penn State will never be a consistent top 5 (top 10, top 15, top 20 team). Instead, I choose to send some of my discretionary funds to organizations that help people who have been less fortunate in the roulette wheel of life than I have been. To each their own.
I’m not sure this is the point you want to make? He also lost the toughest two games on his schedule by multiple scores including a shellacking of a 52-17 loss to UGa. Their season this year pretty much mirrors what PSU did last year. Nice 10-2 regular season and a win over a top 10 team in a bowl. With that said, I think Ole Miss was a pretty good team this year, but outsiders probably said the same about PSU last year and many of us weren’t happy with the results.
Last edited:
Here’s the bottom line for many, I guess. If you want Franklin gone, start raising money for his buyout. If you want to play with the big boys, start contributing to NIL. The portal and top rated recruits are being largely influenced by NIL. If PSU can’t contribute more in that capacity, don’t expect to get better players. If you can’t, or won’t, contribute to either, not much point in complaining.
True. To me the measure is whether the extent to which a coach meets his employer's, the school's, expectations. Impossible to fully know, but a good indicator his whether he keeps his job (e.g. Ferentz) or gets fired (e.g. Fisher).
But he's also responsible for those recruiting rankings. And I read that NIL was fixed and haven't heard Franklin complain about them recently. But is is a New Year .......................
There is a little complication with all of these pleas for NIL contributions. Let's take the proverbial John Smith. John loves his college football team and could easily write a check for $100k toward NIL. But John is in a business/profession where he has no use for his school athletes, or anyone else for that matter, promoting it. John also doesn't want the junk his school's NIL collective offers. So what is John supposed to do?
Nothing in the 2021 BOT minute records showing they approved this contract, including November meeting.
What did John do before NIL? If John had the means to donate then, he probably did in some way. Maybe continue that, or not? My point is, coming to this board complaining isn’t going to change anything.
And if he did write a check for $100K, who's to say $75K isn't skimmed off the top for 'administration' fees?
When I stopped caring about results produced by athletes a third my age, my life improved substantially. I still watch Penn State games but dispassionately. The transfer portal, NIL, and the endless self adulation and pomposity displayed after nearly every play, has made the sport anathema to me. Instead of watching Michigan/Alabama I will play my guitar or work on a watercolor painting I started before Christmas. My wife and I took up the guitar and painting in our 60s and the results bring more satisfaction than any football game ever did. I don't condemn those who are still passionate fans. I was once in your number. I only point out the obvious. There Is more to life than football.... a lot more.
Happy New Year to all and many God bless us, every one.
Which is one of the reasons college football has worn me out. The absurd salaries for coaches, NIL, transfer portal, "commitments", "opt-outs", full-time coverage of high school kids.....No mas.
Fantastic post fair. Congrats on continuing to learn and grow as human. I admire your continued pursuit of happiness in life. Happy New Year!
Fans everywhere have been whining about "game day coaching" forever- and some think every poor play is evidence.
I almost always enjoy your posts, however “coping with disastrous year…”
Come on man!
And on one of your later posts about will we keep up with NIL. I have stated several times we will not. It is going to be the sad reality. I am actually surprised so many think that we will somehow excel at it.
Thanks for the kind words. Like so many my age, I had a lot of dreams in my youth that will never be realized, but I'm determined to accomplish some that are still there for the taking.
That’s commendable. Some of the smartest, most interesting people I know are those that continue to challenge their brains and grow well into adulthood. I, too, have some things I’d like to pursue in due time when I get closer to retirement. Guitar maybe? Travel to some places I’ve never been like Italy, Greece, and Switzerland, and maybe some other things like learning a second language. However, for now, I’m in the daily routine of trying to be the best father and husband I can be, while getting two teenage boys through high school and college, and paying the mortgage. I’m pretty lucky, but there’s still things to do. Anyway, enjoy your endeavors.
You're avoiding the question, but I'll play. Before NIL, John contributed $300k to the Athletic Department's general fund. Now he's being asked to contribute an additional $100k to NIL. He's happy to oblige, but how does he do it? His business doesn't lend itself to having an athlete promote it, nor does he want the junk the NIL cooperative offers.
A legitimate concern. While your example might be high, wouldn't surprise me that some NIL cooperatives are profiteering in a big way.
I’m not avoiding anything. I really don’t give a sh*t. If some rich guy wants to donate, he’ll find a way. If the complainers on here want things to change, they’ll need to pony up.
There is no more noble calling than being a good father and husband. In many ways those are the biggest challenges of all and certainly none are more important. All the best in your efforts LB.
I know of one "rich guy" who can't figure it out and neither the collective or athletic department can help.
It’s going to 12 teams…how many years would it have taken Franklin to get into a 12 team playoff…year 3.
We’re not doing anything. If he makes it he makes it, if not then he doesn’t. He’s still not going anywhere.
If a Franklin team ran a QB draw into that UM front on fourth and goal in OT down by 7 all the grocery stores in the Northeast USA would run out of tissues. Carry on.
Get unlimited access today.