Proof that Shane is a Complete Coach

Tngamecock

Well-known member
Jan 22, 2022
1,765
1,865
113
I must be missing something. We are 2-2, and a 10 point underdog for our next game, but on this thread I'm reading Complete Coach, Brillant Hire, Monster Recruiter.
Something is just not adding up.
We could be 4-0 with UK schedule……fool’s gold
 

Lurker123

Well-known member
Jan 18, 2022
3,640
3,125
113
Coastal would have taken that 2020 team to the woodshed. I can't imagine would that O would have done to our defense. But regardless, I wouldn't feel any better about adding a couple of non P5 wins to the record. We flat out sucked...13th out of 14 in the league. We gave up less than 31 points twice on the year...AU and Mizzu. We gave up 40+ 6 times.


Don't disagree that we sucked. The coach sucked, and deserved to be fired.

I just bristle at the notion of throwing out "two win season" without a clarifier. That was in no way a regular season or schedule.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

Deleted11512

Well-known member
Feb 2, 2023
4,985
3,954
113
Don't disagree that we sucked. The coach sucked, and deserved to be fired.

I just bristle at the notion of throwing out "two win season" without a clarifier. That was in no way a regular season or schedule.
For sure. I just can't help to think we would have ended up firing him mid season anyway, then doing something stupid like losing to Wofford. So I'm kind of glad for the all SEC schedule. Potentially saved us from a massively embarrassing episode. At least we can explain that one like everyone else explains failures during 2020...it was COVID!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Rogue Cock

Joined Sep 11, 2000
Jan 22, 2022
10,396
15,463
113
HITH Tanner thought someone who couldn't win at Fla could win at USC is beyond me. I agree that Tanner and Mushhead should have been shown the door together. He has now done a maybe very poor job in his MBB hire when he had a great candidate on site. He did the same with Mushhead when he could have hired Lincoln or Mack.
He couldn’t have hired Lincoln, period. Stoops had his “discussion” with LR immediately on his return and Riley took his name out of the hat. The Sooner site had several articles on it.

And several successful coaches have struggled at UF since UM left…..the expectations of the fan base and the Bull Gators is ridiculous.
 

Prestonyte

Well-known member
Jun 1, 2022
5,261
5,214
113
He couldn’t have hired Lincoln, period. Stoops had his “discussion” with LR immediately on his return and Riley took his name out of the hat. The Sooner site had several articles on it.

And several successful coaches have struggled at UF since UM left…..the expectations of the fan base and the Bull Gators is ridiculous.
This is why I have always felt the SC job was a very attractive one - expectations are not ridiculously outrageous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rogue Cock

Atlanta_Cock

Member
May 29, 2023
215
137
43
He couldn’t have hired Lincoln, period. Stoops had his “discussion” with LR immediately on his return and Riley took his name out of the hat. The Sooner site had several articles on it.

And several successful coaches have struggled at UF since UM left…..the expectations of the fan base and the Bull Gators is ridiculous.
UF is very big and very wealthy and Florida is talent rich. Gator expectations are where they should be.
 

Maccmaine12

Joined Oct 19, 2020
Jan 31, 2022
646
581
93
Everyone thought Loggains was going to fail here. People felt Coach Beamer and Ray Tanner went cheap instead of going big.

Once again Shane saw things in Dowell that the rest of us missed.

His play calling has been excellent and the television commentators are pointing that out.

He’s been a big help in getting the offensive line on track.

This was a brilliant hire.

Meanwhile, Dabo’s proving that left to his own devices he’s a horrible coach. The cheerleader is being exposed.

Shane Beamer is exactly what South Carolina needed.
I have to admit that I was frustrated that Beamer made that hire because of the NFL stats but once I heard his first presser, I was sold. You can tell how genuine, smart, and QB friendly he was from that presser. Even listening to how Shaw and Alshon endorsed him, gave me hope too. The positive reports from practice was refreshing and always thought if we could get someone in here that understand how to get his playmakers the ball then we’ll be a force.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rogue Cock

Maccmaine12

Joined Oct 19, 2020
Jan 31, 2022
646
581
93
I don‘t know if Beamer or Loggains will work, but in year 3 we shouldn’t have lost to UNC, and we should have beaten an outmanned MSU last night with room to spare. We lost some real talent from last year’s team to the portal. Maybe those guys were a cancer; I don’t know. But it seems the Lloyd departure caught Beamer by surprise. We seemed flat footed to replace all of them. So far, the replacements are not as good.

Last night’s pass D reminded me of Old Carolina. Not sure what happened, but if we can’t run the ball or defend the pass, we won’t go bowling this year, which cannot possibly help recruiting. Say what you will, but Dabo has complete control over his program. Beamer appears to be trying to emulate it. We’ll see if he has the nads to do what needs to be done.
Mack Brown is in year 5 with a more talented roster than ours. I don’t believe UNC was better than us but any team can be beaten on any given night.
 

Maccmaine12

Joined Oct 19, 2020
Jan 31, 2022
646
581
93
It does unless you are intentionally being a troll. Shane took over a 2 win team. We are 17-13 since he took over. The best coach in our history was 19-11 and he took over a 6 win team.

We lost to #1 Georgia on the road and #15 UNC at a neutral site. As those teams are a combined 8-0 no one else has figured out how to beat them.

TN is #21 and Neyland at night is one of the toughest places to play in college football. Around 100-110 teams would be 10 or more dogs to TN right now.

year 3 is often a dip year for coaches as the team is composed of bad classes from the previous hot seat/fired coach and the first 2 of the new coach (new staff and contacts etc.)

We are winning at nearly the best rate in our history after taking over a 2 win team. We are playing the toughest schedule in football. We are recruiting at the highest level in history at a time when our major recruiting competition has won 4 recent national championships.

Beamer might not work but as of right now we have very little to complain about.
Perfect response! 🐓
 
  • Like
Reactions: uscfan1981

Maccmaine12

Joined Oct 19, 2020
Jan 31, 2022
646
581
93
HITH Tanner thought someone who couldn't win at Fla could win at USC is beyond me. I agree that Tanner and Mushhead should have been shown the door together. He has now done a maybe very poor job in his MBB hire when he had a great candidate on site. He did the same with Mushhead when he could have hired Lincoln or Mack.
Only two coaches consistently won at UF and they’re some of the best coaches of all time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rogue Cock

Maccmaine12

Joined Oct 19, 2020
Jan 31, 2022
646
581
93
They were better than us then. Now that the OL is settling and Mario is getting touches I think we would take them if we played right now.
Me too. That’s why I wished we schedule them game 2 and not 1. It’s hard to know what you have without playing a real game
 

Surfincock

Member
Feb 3, 2022
41
33
18
I'm happy with the Beamer hire so far, but the OP seems like a bit of a knee-jerk reaction to last night's win. It was a win and any SEC win is a good win, but it was far from a perfectly called offensive game.
List all the perfectly called offensive games you have watched.
 

Surfincock

Member
Feb 3, 2022
41
33
18
And the two point play attempt is still stupid ....
I disagree. Our special teams should keep doing what they do best, keep the defense guessing and winning games for us. Of course we should try things like this. Makes no sense it was a good call no one expected and it was wide open.
 

Beanerball

Well-known member
Jul 17, 2023
726
526
93
Agreed, the “Brilliant” and “Monster”accolades are premature. The criticisms to me are even more premature. Sure, it’s fine to judge a play call here and there. As far as hires go, we need to see more before we can actually make an accurate assessment. Dabo went through several coordinators and built up recruiting over several years, all while we were whipping him 5 years in a row. I’m not saying we wait forever but rushing to scrap everything would only put us back at this point. Don’t see a great coach out there we could steal at this point. I realize most of us are not advocating starting over, but if you are, I believe you are totally wrong.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Harvard Gamecock