Your last statement is from an overall fan enjoyment perspective (I.e. not really in contention), but incorrect in regards to NHL standings and draft picks.My point was, if you go back to the top of the thread, that one (not the only reason) for the Pens success was getting lucky in the draft-specifically the draft lottery. I haven't moved that bar at all. It's a heck of a lot easier to pick good players when you are picking first or second overall four years running. Sure the Pens had bad seasons. But that's not luck--good or bad, The Jackets have had equally as horrid seasons--over a much longer period of time--but no lottery pick luck.
The seasonal point total numbers you provided earlier for the CBJ were not as bad as those for the Penguins. Which leads to…
In only one of the seasons in the ‘01-‘04 span did the CBJ finish as low as 2nd worst record in the league. The other years had multiple teams with worse records. If you are going to argue the specifics that first or second overall draft picks make such a difference, then the CBJ never “deserved” to have multiple picks of that type.