Yet you view Gonzaga, who has never won a title to be a blueblood. They aren't and can't be considered as one till they do. Now tell me, would you rather be a fan of UConn or Gonzaga based off their overall success? One more thing, nobody outside of fans of the schools involved remembers much about conference titles or conference tournament titles in basketball. The NCAA tournament in basketball means more than it does in any other NCAA sport. When it comes to BLUE BLOODS, it's ALL that matters.
I am a fan of Gonzaga- got into them back in '05 when they would play a late night 11pm central game on ESPN. So to answer your question, I would rather be a fan of Gonzaga. And to further answer your question, I would rather be a fan of Gonzaga based on their overall success.
If I were to select my fandom based not on overall success, but on NCAA Tournament success, I would choose UConn.
...but being a fan isnt really based on that. And being a fan of Gonzaga would have allowed me to follow my team for every single NCAA Tournament since UConn won their title in the 90s. That is opposed to following UConn less than 2/3 of the time come March.
Gonzaga since UConn won their title in the 90s- 24 NCAA Tournament appearances, 8 Sweet 16, 2 Elite 8, 2 Title Games, 22 Conference Titles, 20 Conference Tournament Titles.
I am not claiming Gonzaga to be better than UConn, to be clear. I am just listing why I view Gonzaga as an elite program that has been elite for so long that I view them as equal to the traditional bluebloods. Polls back it up, regular season success backs it up, and NCAA Tournament success backs it up.
As for your claim that nobody outside of fans of the schools remembers conference titles...I disagree. I think that fans of college basketball know and remember various regular season and conference tournament titles. I still remember the 2009 quarterfinal BigEast game where Devendorf hit a game winning 3 and jumped on a table in celebration, only to find out it left after time expired and they proceeded to play 6 overtimes. Syracuse won, they won the next day in OT, then lost in the finals. I 'member.
Its cool that you dont though. There is no single way to be a fan of a sport and we all have different levels of interest and passion.