Teams which have won a Natty who aren't going bowling this year- or how the mighty have fallen

ODShowtime

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
2,678
5,466
113
Sixty years ago. Then Murray Warmath retired, the recruiting pipeline to Western PA (particularly Uniontown) dried up, and the rest is history. Now the Gophs are left with PJ and his human life preserver.

I'm going to go on faith that MN's titles were due to PA talent. I like that narrative.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catch1lion

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,447
8,516
113
in the past there were 4 NY bowls: Rose, Sugar, Orange, and Cotton. The Fiesta Bowl became a player when the moved to NYD and the Cotton lost prestige when the SWC collapsed. Making the big 4 was an accomplish. Being in a bowl game had some meaning as there were fewer bowls, a team could finish 7-4 and be left out.

Today there are essentially 8 NY bowls so yes, the standard is lower. Teams with 5-7 go to bowl games today.

Paterno’s 94 Rose Bowl win was a greater accomplishment than Franklin’s ‘23 Rose Bowl win. Paterno had to win the conference to go. Franklin backed into the game because two better conference teams went to the playoff. By 1994 standards, 2023 PSU would have been in the Citrus bowl at worst.
I’m not arguing against that, but your post insinuated that if you don’t make the final four, the rest of the bowls are meaningless. You could take it further and argue that if you don’t make the final 2, it’s meaningless, no?
 

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,447
8,516
113
Roll it back before the BCS and the major bowls, occasionally more than one, had national title implications. Granted it was messy, but messy could be fun.
Yeah, that time frame and bowl set up was a joke. Not having 1 play 2 was BS. 1994 was proof of that. There were plenty of other times where teams were crowned co champs because the top two didn’t play as a result of bowl affiliations with certain conferences. I don’t miss that disaster.
 

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,447
8,516
113
if you're not #1, it's meaningless
Agree. That’s the point I tried to make last week when I said every fan base will be disappointed except for one. But to diminish the bowl games, specifically the NY6, seems a bit of a reach. I think there’s still enough players that will suit up for the last time ever in those games that would argue it means everything to them. After years and years of practices, injuries, off season lifting, nutrition guidelines, film sessions, etc going all the way back to Pop Warner for most of them, I bet they would be more than appreciative of one last game. I think sometimes we take the human element out of this and forget that most of these players do not go on to NFL careers and make millions of dollars.
 
Last edited:

GrimReaper

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
6,419
8,872
113
I'm going to go on faith that MN's titles were due to PA talent. I like that narrative.

Yeah, that time frame and bowl set up was a joke. Not having 1 play 2 was BS. 1994 was proof of that. There were plenty of other times where teams were crowned co champs because the top two didn’t play as a result of bowl affiliations with certain conferences. I don’t miss that disaster.
Reality is the bowls didn't give a shlt. They were set up to draw tourists, still are. Conferences didn't give a **** either. They liked the money and the opportunity for their presidents to junket and hold court.

You must have really been rolling on the floor when prior to 1968 (AP) and 1974 (Coaches) the polls chose their national championship after the regular season and the bowls were just for fun. Then there was 1969, when Milhous declared Texas the national champion all by his lonesome.
 

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,447
8,516
113
Reality is the bowls didn't give a shlt. They were set up to draw tourists, still are. Conferences didn't give a **** either. They liked the money and the opportunity for their presidents to junket and hold court.

You must have really been rolling on the floor when prior to 1968 (AP) and 1974 (Coaches) the polls chose their national championship after the regular season and the bowls were just for fun. Then there was 1969, when Milhous declared Texas the national champion all by his lonesome.
The bowls did give a ****…about the money. Same with the conferences. They were locked into those bowls for big payouts.

As for the time frame you referenced, before my time.
 

GrimReaper

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
6,419
8,872
113
The bowls did give a ****…about the money. Same with the conferences. They were locked into those bowls for big payouts.

As for the time frame you referenced, before my time.
Bowls are not-for-profit. The only people that make money are a handful of administrators.And their local underwriters hope that their rooms, tables, and showrooms are full of free-spenders.

Schools? Now that's a different story. So much for educational leadership.
 

Bvillebaron

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,637
1,785
113
Saw Aaron Rodgers on the Pat McAfee show today . He said today there’s too much of a rush to create a hero or vilify someone . Said CJ might be really good , but who knows what year two brings . Once teams have film on him , Stroud is going to have to reinvent himself . Bryce Young might be great but he’s dead and buried in many articles . Went on to say it’s ridiculous Frank Reich got fired already . Guys a great coach .
I’m sure this extends to Rhule . One year in is too early to call him a bust .
One year may be too early to call Rhule a bust, but he has done nothing at any of his coaching stops to call him a “great” coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grant Green

Bvillebaron

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,637
1,785
113
I agree Rhule has a good track record of resurrecting and fixing programs if you give him time. Especially if you look at their starting roster. They were starting a ton of underclassmen. IIRC they graduate 2 seniors on offense and 3 on defense. I am sure like he did at Temple and Baylor told the administration to be patient, they will take their lumps the first year but will take large steps up after that.
We shall see. Not many great players in Nebraska and the bloom has been off the Nebraska rose for quite a while now.
in the past there were 4 NY bowls: Rose, Sugar, Orange, and Cotton. The Fiesta Bowl became a player when the moved to NYD and the Cotton lost prestige when the SWC collapsed. Making the big 4 was an accomplish. Being in a bowl game had some meaning as there were fewer bowls, a team could finish 7-4 and be left out.

Today there are essentially 8 NY bowls so yes, the standard is lower. Teams with 5-7 go to bowl games today.

Paterno’s 94 Rose Bowl win was a greater accomplishment than Franklin’s ‘23 Rose Bowl win. Paterno had to win the conference to go. Franklin backed into the game because two better conference teams went to the playoff. By 1994 standards, 2023 PSU would have been in the Citrus bowl at worst.
Of course it was. The 1994 team was one of the best teams in college history.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bwifan

PhillyBillyReprise

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2021
581
996
93
Bowls have been a chance to play an extra game against a good opponent. They were pluses for players, coaches and fans. The Gator Bowl in ‘67 was not for any great prize but it was basis for ‘68 & ‘69.
Relax. Hope Penn State goes to a good bowl with great weather and formidable opponent and wins. And if you have the time and money, go and have fun. [We have been to 7!bowl games]
 
  • Like
Reactions: ODShowtime and LB99

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,447
8,516
113
Bowls are not-for-profit. The only people that make money are a handful of administrators.And their local underwriters hope that their rooms, tables, and showrooms are full of free-spenders.

Schools? Now that's a different story. So much for educational leadership.
This is an older article from 2017, but the point remains that there is A LOT of money changing hands in bowl season. As we all know, money talks.

 

GrimReaper

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
6,419
8,872
113
This is an older article from 2017, but the point remains that there is A LOT of money changing hands in bowl season. As we all know, money talks.

Article is an unfocused pile of crap. So lets get to cases, taking the 2021 Rose Bowl as an example:

1. Yes, a lot of money changes hands (duh!). That year the Committee had $106mm of cash inflows and $107mm of outflows.

2. Who gets what (of the $107mm):
a. the main beneficiaries were the Big 10 and Pac 12, evenly splitting $84mm
b. salaries and benefits totaled $4.4mm. The highest paid employee took home about $ 450k, nice money, but not great. Six other employees pull down between $150k and $300k.
c. expenses to promote and run the bowl total $23mm.

So?
 

leinbacker

Well-known member
Oct 13, 2021
2,075
3,355
113
I’m not arguing against that, but your post insinuated that if you don’t make the final four, the rest of the bowls are meaningless. You could take it further and argue that if you don’t make the final 2, it’s meaningless, no?

In 1978 there were 15 bowls, today there are over 40. Would you value a coach that took his team to 10 consecutive bowls today than one who did the same in the 1970s.

same with making the playoffs this year vs next year.
 

STPGopherfan

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2021
629
911
93
I don't like it, but for all of his warts, Fleck has the team going to class and for the most part staying out of trouble(992 APR IIRC). The bowl game will be the 2023 version of the toilet bowl anyway, so why not let them get the extra practices. Lord knows the team needs it. I wish that we could have convinced coach Ciarrocca to stay as OC.
 

STPGopherfan

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2021
629
911
93
Sandy Stephens, second in the Heisman voting, and Bill Munsey (Chuck's brother. Yes, I know the last names are spelled differently). Judge Dickson from Clairton

Later, Ray Parson from Uniontown.
Related to Sandy Stephens by marriage (he married a family member). Last time I talked to Judge Dickson was in 07. He was at a game (Gophers vs FAU). Nice man.

MSU and Notre Dame get much credit for expanding college football, but the Gopher teams from 59'-68'. Produced some great players including NFL Hall of Famers: Bobby Bell, and Charlie Sanders.

Yes our program has fallen a mighty long way.
 

Catch1lion

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,013
3,124
113
PJ rows for free..........
According to USA Today, Fleck will not receive an extra payday for the victory, because his team had not automatically qualified for the bowl.
 

Metal Mike

Member
Oct 28, 2021
134
223
43
A note about 1960 Minny national championship. Minny lost their Bowl Game that year. They were the last national champ to lose the bowl game.
Up to 1960 the final polls were taken at the end of the regular season. The bowl games were treated as an exhibition game. Passing and running stats were not added to the regular season stats.
 

TiogaLion

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2021
1,583
2,423
113
A note about 1960 Minny national championship. Minny lost their Bowl Game that year. They were the last national champ to lose the bowl game.
Up to 1960 the final polls were taken at the end of the regular season. The bowl games were treated as an exhibition game. Passing and running stats were not added to the regular season stats.
in 1973 Alabama was crowed the UPI champ after the regular season. They lost to Notre Dame in the Sugar Bowl and the AP crowed Notre Dame their champ.
 

Charlie1978

Active member
Dec 8, 2022
303
358
63
So, interesting point on Nebraska and Rhule. The XM college football guys were doing a stock up, stock down segment today. They called out Rhule for his stock being down. The reason is that he had Nebraska at 5-3 after eight games this season. He needed to coach them to just one more win in their final four games to have Nebraska make a bowl for the first time since 2016. Unfortunately, they finished 0-4 with losses to Sparty, MD, Wisconsin, and Iowa. They also pointed to the 3 point loss to Minny to open the season as a bad game. Nebraska finished 5-7 and 3-6 in conference. They also made it a point to say Rhule makes $9 million/yr.
Great thread overall, great place to jump in. When Pryor left PA for the bad guys in Columbus in 2008, he said "State College was too country". Thanks to NIL the two most "country" schools of any import, Texas Tech and Nebraska, are making news with the incoming talent. Blue bloods like us and O$U struggle with getting the final parts through the portal. People, this is not good and we probably have 1-2 years to either step in and regulate the jet-jobs (Al McGuire saying from the 1980's that I love) or be prepared to become IOWA, phuckin IOWA. IOWA is a 1950 landfill. What's that look like for us? 10-15 ranked recruiting classes, stepping stones for up and coming coaches, the occasional heated bowl game against Kansas State. Its why I absolutely hate the TA hire. Our best hope is that JCF realizes his only way to the other side until we get our NIL in order is to recruit his @$$ off. In the mean time, we have Abdul Carter, Sutton and those two new safeties who play like Paterno would want them to play.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: TiogaLion
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login