Would you rather have a defensive or offensive minded head coach?

Would you rather have an offensive or defensive minded head coach?

  • Offensive

    Votes: 13 65.0%
  • Defensive

    Votes: 7 35.0%

  • Total voters
    20

SChopeful

Well-known member
Nov 18, 2022
358
734
93
Had a debate and bringing to the masses. Would you prefer an offensive-minded head coach or a defensive-minded head coach. Your head coach will likely call plays whether it's defense or offense, which leaves needing another coach to call plays on the other side of the ball. It feels like there are more young and "up-and-coming" offensive coaches that fall under the same branch of strategy. This means there are theoretically more candidates to replace offensive coordinators if your coach leaves. Compare that to an offensive head coach, where there may not have as many defensive options to replace an outgoing coach. A defensive coach should theoretically have a better chance of sustaining success over a longer period of time right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRealFarmer_Dawg

Tuamuchspeed

Well-known member
Jul 15, 2022
3,012
4,147
113
Defensive gurus are far more rare than offensive gurus. Head coaches are the staple of your program, they won't go anywhere. Good defense is the backbone of a program and good offense is the catalyst that can elevate your program from good to great. I would rather deal with attrition on offense than defense. It's easier to replicate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRealFarmer_Dawg

Hugh Jasso

Well-known member
Jun 30, 2023
481
623
93
Offensive minded. A system like Heupel’s is a magnet for talent that wants to put up big numbers. All you need when you have a fast offense is a defense that gives up more than you score. It doesn’t have to be a shut down defense to win a lot of games.
 

sdave

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2021
4,256
5,799
113
Had a debate and bringing to the masses. Would you prefer an offensive-minded head coach or a defensive-minded head coach. Your head coach will likely call plays whether it's defense or offense, which leaves needing another coach to call plays on the other side of the ball. It feels like there are more young and "up-and-coming" offensive coaches that fall under the same branch of strategy. This means there are theoretically more candidates to replace offensive coordinators if your coach leaves. Compare that to an offensive head coach, where there may not have as many defensive options to replace an outgoing coach. A defensive coach should theoretically have a better chance of sustaining success over a longer period of time right?
Buddy of mine in college was a 3 year starting OG.

He argued the best head coaches was always on offense. I think he ment offensive line men
 

TheRealFarmer_Dawg

Active member
May 2, 2023
385
294
63
There's a reason Corch left the SEC. I'm curious to see how long Heupel and Freeze 2.0 stroll. When you get good on good you better be able to play defense or reinvent your offense every 3 years.
 

Latest posts

Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login