Notre Dame legend Tim Brown on Tommy Rees leaving: 'This is a great day for Irish football'

Tommy Rees made waves this weekend with his decision to leave Notre Dame and take the offensive coordinator job at Alabama. However, while some see it as a negative to lose your offensive coordinator at this point heading into the spring, Tim Brown sees it as a real positive.

Brown was blunt about his thoughts on Rees leaving for Tuscaloosa on Twitter. He says he thinks it’s ‘a great day for Irish football’ considering how ‘predictable’ the offense looked and how they can move on from playing ‘hero ball’.

@NDFootball This is a great day for Irish football and maybe even a better day for Tommy Rees. I've been around a lot of offenses, but the Irish offense last year, with maybe the exception of the North Carolina game, was extremely predictable. Seeing the offense struggle told me

— Tim Brown (@81TimBrown) February 5, 2023

Him the hero. If that doesn't work you lose. I was at a couple of games where it took everything in me not to go knock on the booth window and say give me the call sheet!!! Lol! I truly wish him well, he's gonna need it! Let's Go Irish!

— Tim Brown (@81TimBrown) February 5, 2023

Rees spent the last three seasons in South Bend as the Fighting Irish’s OC. In that time, they finished 42nd, 20th, and 30th in the country with an average of 33.5 points per game.

Even so, Brown’s criticisms went on, including a jab saying Rees was obviously reliant on Brian Kelly.

Brown can have his opinion but, at the end of the day, Saban hired him for a reason. Now we’ll have to wait and see if Notre Dame prospers on offense while Alabama struggles or if the Tide are the ones who came out on top with this one.

Finebaum believes NIL issues played a role in Rees’ decision to leave Notre Dame

Nick Saban made an interesting splash Friday when he lured Notre Dame offensive coordinator Tommy Rees away from his alma mater to become the new offensive coordinator at Alabama. The hire has led to plenty of reaction, especially considering where the Fighting Irish offense ranked last season under Rees.

Paul Finebaum thinks it says more about Notre Dame than it does about Rees, though.

Finebaum reacted to Rees’ decision to leave for Alabama and said it speaks to the current landscape in college football with NIL. He thinks the Crimson Tide — and bigger public schools, for that matter — are in better position than private schools such as Notre Dame in the current landscape because they can get bigger contributions for NIL. That, in turn, better helps programs not only retain players, but recruit high-caliber prospects, as well.

“What it tells me is that he wanted out of Notre Dame,” Finebaum said on The Paul Finebaum Show Friday shortly after the news broke. “Notre Dame’s a private school, and I don’t think private schools can compete any longer in the NIL place because their alumni are not going to contribute to the same degree as the bigger schools.”

Last season, Notre Dame ranked 60th in the nation in total offense with 396 yards per game and 41st in scoring offense with 31.8 points per contest. But the Fighting Irish saw multiple questions come up at quarterback after starter Tyler Buchner went down with an injury and backup Drew Pyne took over for the rest of the season.

Then, Rees and Notre Dame head coach Marcus Freeman landed a big fish in the transfer portal this offseason by bringing in Sam Hartman — the No. 1 quarterback to hit the portal this cycle, according to the On3 Transfer Portal Rankings. Rees is now leaving the ACC’s all-time passing touchdown leader behind to go to Alabama and the SEC, and Finebaum said he has quite a task ahead now.

“Let me say this. Young guy. I mean, whether Notre Dame fans are happy or not, I don’t know,” Finebaum said. “I think there’s some mixed opinions. He’s in the same spot that we’ve seen people like Jim McElwain, Lane Kiffin, Steve Sarkisian, Brian Daboll. These are some major names. In no way has he proven himself to be in the same league as any of them.

“That doesn’t mean he won’t be successful. The real challenge is he’s leaving behind a proven quarterback in Sam Hartman.”