Paul Finebaum rips College Football Playoff committee over Georgia ranking

The latest College Football Playoff selection committee rankings are out and they’re not without controversy. In particular, ESPN’s Paul Finebaum took major issue with the rankings, ripping the committee over Georgia in particular.

While making an appearance on Get Up on Wednesday morning, Finebaum was critical of Georgia being ranked 10th, which is good enough to make it into the Playoff but isn’t as high as it seems like they should be to Finebaum.

“It’s the Georgia Bulldogs because when you showed that graphic,” Paul Finebaum said. You saw Georgia’s opponents all over the place, including Texas, the number three team in the country. They only beat Texas in Texas. Look, they played at Alabama. They lost at Ole Miss. They beat Tennessee. When you look at everyone else, Indiana doesn’t have a ranked team, they’ll get one this weekend. Penn State has lost to one. Every time I get on here every Wednesday morning I say to myself, ‘Calm down. Don’t be an angry guy. Get off your lawn.'”

This season, Georgia has losses to Alabama and Ole Miss. Both of those were road games to teams ranked within the current top 10. Georgia has also, as Finebaum noted, beaten Texas and Tennessee, who are in the top 12 of the rankings

“But this committee is not serious,” Finebaum said. “There are football coaches on this committee and there is no way those football coaches can tell me or anyone else with a straight face that they really think Indiana, Penn State, Miami, schools like that are better than Georgia. It’s not possible.”

At that point, insider Heather Dinich explained some of the logic from the College Football Playoff selection committee. To this point, there has been more emphasis on losses and the eye test, as is exemplified by Indiana, than there seems to be on metrics like strength of record.

“We shouldn’t [be fine with that logic]. Listen, just because there are new members on the committee doesn’t mean they have to do a lousy job and, so far, they have done a lousy job. What they’ve really done is they’ve put Georgia in a box because Georgia doesn’t have another quality opponent, although they’re playing a team in two weeks that beat Miami. They don’t have a route to get higher,” Finebaum said. “Why is that important? Yeah, they’re in the Playoff, but they’ll start the Playoff on the road at Penn State, at Indiana, at one of these schools that, in my opinion, really haven’t done anything. If Indiana has a great game Saturday, good for them, but I don’t think they will and they should not be where they are based on their schedule so far because they have beaten no one so far.”

Georgia has two regular season games remaining against UMass and Georgia Tech. Assuming that the Bulldogs win both of those games, they’ll be in a good position to make the Playoff but there could be some concerns about seeding.