Alabama football players transferring away could have participated in bowl, Nick Saban says

Nitt1300

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
5,035
9,530
113
I thought that this was really interesting. Saban has been a pretty successful coach and if he's having this much trouble you have to wonder just how difficult coaching is in the new world of semi-pro "college" football.


NEW ORLEANS ― Alabama football will have a different roster in the Sugar Bowl from the one Nick Saban had available for the Iron Bowl a month ago.

Such is the case in the transfer-portal era.

Ten scholarship players have put their names in the portal since the Iron Bowl, and all but one have found new homes already. If the players had waited, Saban said Friday, he would have allowed them to play in the Crimson Tide's bowl game.

"Even though we didn’t have any opt-outs, we had like 10 guys that got in the transfer portal," Saban said. "I gave them all the opportunity to play in the game if they wanted to. And they didn’t. So I don’t know if that’s a good thing for players, not to have to stay committed to their team to the end of our season."

No. 5 Alabama (10-2) faces No. 9 Kansas State (10-3) on Saturday (11 a.m., ESPN) at the Superdome.

Dec 30, 2022; New Orleans, LA, USA; Alabama head coach Nick Saban speaks to the media at the Sheraton Hotel in New Orleans in the final lead up to the Sugar Bowl.

Dec 30, 2022; New Orleans, LA, USA; Alabama head coach Nick Saban speaks to the media at the Sheraton Hotel in New Orleans in the final lead up to the Sugar Bowl.
The players who have put their names in the portal since the end of the season have primarily been reserves, but a few had notable roles at one point or another. Left guard Javion Cohen is the only starter who entered the portal before transferring to Miami, but Traeshon Holden was a starter at one point in the season at receiver. JoJo Earle, who had been a contributor some when healthy, is the other more notable name.

Others are freshman receiver Aaron Anderson, backup left tackle Amari Kight, reserve lineman Tommy Brockermeyer, Tanner Bowles and Damieon George, reserve receiver Christian Leary and reserve cornerback Khyree Jackson. Jackson had been suspended from the team before he decided to transfer.

Saban said Thursday during his radio show that this had been the most enjoyable bowl practice experience he's had outside of the playoffs. Saban said sometimes it can be like pulling teeth.

"When you have guys on your team sometimes that, I call them energy vampires," Saban said. "You use all your energy on these guys, trying to get them to do what they’re supposed to. Those are the kinds of guys that don’t end up playing in bowl games and don’t end up doing the best thing to make the best choices and decisions for the team and all that because they’ve got other motives, which I’m not being critical of. But this team has really worked hard and done really, really, well."


Alabama football players transferring away could have participated in bowl, Nick Saban says (yahoo.com)
 
  • Wow
Reactions: step.eng69

VaDave4PSU

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,991
2,325
113
Saban is the elder statesman in CF right now. One of the longest careers currently and arguably the most successful to do the job ever. When he talks, people listen. It carries weight.

I don't feel bad for the guy in any circumstance where he is complaining. He's processed more kids than anybody in the name of winning. It's a matter of loyalty, however, when kids could have suited up for him to help win a bowl.
 

LionJim

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
10,657
14,726
113
Players cannot enter the portal till the season is over Jan 10, that would end a lot of non sense.
Yeah, but it’s not as if the players can afford to wait. A lot of players in the portal end up not finding a new home.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VaDave4PSU

VaDave4PSU

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,991
2,325
113
Yeah, but it’s not as if the players can afford to wait. A lot of players in the portal end up not finding a new home.

With the % who aren't ending up anywhere, are more HS seniors getting scholarships now than ever? Be curious to see that breakdown.
 

LionJim

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
10,657
14,726
113
With the % who aren't ending up anywhere, are more HS seniors getting scholarships now than ever? Be curious to see that breakdown.
No idea, but it’s likely. There’s always someone who is just as good but younger.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VaDave4PSU

LionJim

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
10,657
14,726
113
Processing, baby!
This happens with university tenure decisions too, just pointing that out. If you haven’t shown yourself to be head and shoulders above whoever is out there, you’re out on your ***.

Not sure why I felt the urge to mention this but whatever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VaDave4PSU

GrimReaper

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
6,419
8,873
113
This happens with university tenure decisions too, just pointing that out. If you haven’t shown yourself to be head and shoulders above whoever is out there, you’re out on your ***.

Not sure why I felt the urge to mention this but whatever.
The advent of the portal is not a good thing for marginal players. Players who would never see the field hung on because they had nothing better to do and didn't want the stigma that goes with being cut. Coaches didn't want to create the perception that they cut kids, bad for recruiitng. Now, the NCAA provides all parties with a graceful way out.

Even as cynical as I am, I used to believe that college football was, net-net, a good thing for most players. Not no more.
 

Auxgym

Active member
Oct 13, 2021
397
469
63
I thought that this was really interesting. Saban has been a pretty successful coach and if he's having this much trouble you have to wonder just how difficult coaching is in the new world of semi-pro "college" football.


NEW ORLEANS ― Alabama football will have a different roster in the Sugar Bowl from the one Nick Saban had available for the Iron Bowl a month ago.

Such is the case in the transfer-portal era.

Ten scholarship players have put their names in the portal since the Iron Bowl, and all but one have found new homes already. If the players had waited, Saban said Friday, he would have allowed them to play in the Crimson Tide's bowl game.

"Even though we didn’t have any opt-outs, we had like 10 guys that got in the transfer portal," Saban said. "I gave them all the opportunity to play in the game if they wanted to. And they didn’t. So I don’t know if that’s a good thing for players, not to have to stay committed to their team to the end of our season."

No. 5 Alabama (10-2) faces No. 9 Kansas State (10-3) on Saturday (11 a.m., ESPN) at the Superdome.

Dec 30, 2022; New Orleans, LA, USA; Alabama head coach Nick Saban speaks to the media at the Sheraton Hotel in New Orleans in the final lead up to the Sugar Bowl.

Dec 30, 2022; New Orleans, LA, USA; Alabama head coach Nick Saban speaks to the media at the Sheraton Hotel in New Orleans in the final lead up to the Sugar Bowl.
The players who have put their names in the portal since the end of the season have primarily been reserves, but a few had notable roles at one point or another. Left guard Javion Cohen is the only starter who entered the portal before transferring to Miami, but Traeshon Holden was a starter at one point in the season at receiver. JoJo Earle, who had been a contributor some when healthy, is the other more notable name.

Others are freshman receiver Aaron Anderson, backup left tackle Amari Kight, reserve lineman Tommy Brockermeyer, Tanner Bowles and Damieon George, reserve receiver Christian Leary and reserve cornerback Khyree Jackson. Jackson had been suspended from the team before he decided to transfer.

Saban said Thursday during his radio show that this had been the most enjoyable bowl practice experience he's had outside of the playoffs. Saban said sometimes it can be like pulling teeth.

"When you have guys on your team sometimes that, I call them energy vampires," Saban said. "You use all your energy on these guys, trying to get them to do what they’re supposed to. Those are the kinds of guys that don’t end up playing in bowl games and don’t end up doing the best thing to make the best choices and decisions for the team and all that because they’ve got other motives, which I’m not being critical of. But this team has really worked hard and done really, really, well."


Alabama football players transferring away could have participated in bowl, Nick Saban says (yahoo.com)
So the take away from this is that Nick would have allowed the players in the transfer portal to travel to the bowl game and spend much of their time sitting on the bench like they often do??

Nick is such a Sweetheart. Always so generous.......
 

GrimReaper

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
6,419
8,873
113
So the take away from this is that Nick would have allowed the players in the transfer portal to travel to the bowl game and spend much of their time sitting on the bench like they often do??

Nick is such a Sweetheart. Always so generous.......
What can you say? He was lamenting a shortage of tackling dummies for paractice. Actually, he could have beaten KSU with those tackling dummies.
 
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login