E-A-G-L-E-S EAGLES!!! Birds - Commanders NFC Championship game thread

LionJim

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
11,023
15,146
113
I don’t think Jalen Hurts will ever silence his critics
A win in two weeks would do that for him. Also, I’m glad people have stopped saying that his arm strength isn’t NFL caliber.
 

Grant Green

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,706
3,746
113
Who else learned that the officials can grant a TD to a team after repeated infractions by the defense? Crazy rule.

So, who gets credit for the TD (sports bettors want to know)?
Can the offense refuse? The defense could do this to force the TD and get the ball back without running clock.
 

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
17,772
26,802
113
Who else learned that the officials can grant a TD to a team after repeated infractions by the defense? Crazy rule.

So, who gets credit for the TD (sports bettors want to know)?
Can the offense refuse? The defense could do this to force the TD and get the ball back without running clock.

All good questions. I had never heard about that rule before.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grant Green

Tom McAndrew

BWI Staff
Staff member
Oct 27, 2021
54,635
41,063
113
Who else learned that the officials can grant a TD to a team after repeated infractions by the defense? Crazy rule.

It is a crazy rule. I had heard of it, but as it's never been called/awarded, I've never seen it applied. (I did post a nice article about it earlier in this thread.)

So, who gets credit for the TD (sports bettors want to know)?
Can the offense refuse? The defense could do this to force the TD and get the ball back without running clock.

Good question as to who gets credit for the TD.

Also a good point about how a defense could use it to force a TD to get the ball back.

My buddy and I were texting about another issue with that sequence. Hurts could have been seriously injured. The Commander landed on his back the 1st time he came flying over, and nearly did the same the 2nd time. I'm not sure what the tweak should be in the rules, but a team should not be able to get an advantage to that degree (injure a star on the other team) but blatantly violating a rule, with nothing more than a PF being called (and as the ref said, they warned the Commanders after that it could be called on the next instance after the individual had done it 2 times, so doing it once on purpose and injuring a player isn't currently a PF?).
 

Grant Green

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,706
3,746
113
It is a crazy rule. I had heard of it, but as it's never been called/awarded, I've never seen it applied. (I did post a nice article about it earlier in this thread.)



Good question as to who gets credit for the TD.

Also a good point about how a defense could use it to force a TD to get the ball back.

My buddy and I were texting about another issue with that sequence. Hurts could have been seriously injured. The Commander landed on his back the 1st time he came flying over, and nearly did the same the 2nd time. I'm not sure what the tweak should be in the rules, but a team should not be able to get an advantage to that degree (injure a star on the other team) but blatantly violating a rule, with nothing more than a PF being called (and as the ref said, they warned the Commanders after that it could be called on the next instance after the individual had done it 2 times, so doing it once on purpose and injuring a player isn't currently a PF?).
Good point on the injury potential. Almost gets into unnecessary roughness territory.
 
  • Like
Reactions: s1uggo72

Erial_Lion

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
2,320
2,823
113
Who else learned that the officials can grant a TD to a team after repeated infractions by the defense? Crazy rule.

So, who gets credit for the TD (sports bettors want to know)?
Can the offense refuse? The defense could do this to force the TD and get the ball back without running clock.
The only other time I know of that the rule was used in football was in the 1954 Cotton Bowl. A player for Rice was clear running down the sideline for a TD, and an Alabama player came off the sideline and tackled him. The referees awarded a TD on the play.

There was talk that it potentially could have been called against the Steelers a few years ago in a game where a kick (or maybe it was punt) returner was coming down the sideline and Tomlin almost made contact with him.
 

Grant Green

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,706
3,746
113
The only other time I know of that the rule was used in football was in the 1954 Cotton Bowl. A player for Alabama was clear running down the sideline for a TD, and a Rice player came off the sideline and tackled him. The referees awarded a TD on the play.

There was talk that it potentially could have been called against the Steelers a few years ago in a game where a kick (or maybe it was punt) returner was coming down the sideline and Tomlin almost made contact with him.
Dude, where did you pull that from? Impressive. I wonder if that rule was in place in 1954 (or the refs just went with a logical decision) and if it still exists in college football today. I'm kind of surprised it hasn't happened again. {EDIT: Funny, I'm listening to the Gill Alexander show and they just brought this up. Maybe it's going around Twitter}.

I do recall the Tomlin play. I remember it being very suspect. Like, he was way out in the sideline white and looking the other way.
 
Last edited:

Erial_Lion

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
2,320
2,823
113
Dude, where did you pull that from? Impressive. I wonder if that rule was in place in 1954 (or the refs just went with a logical decision) and if it still exists in college football today. I'm kind of surprised it hasn't happened again.
I remembered it was the 1954 Cotton Bowl and it was Rice/Alabama, but I had to go back and edit my post because I messed up which team it was that did it. My wife will tell you that I have a photographic memory when it comes to random crap, sports facts, 90s music, etc...but you'll probably have to remind me 4 times to do a load of laundry or call someone on their birthday.

The NCAA rule today falls under Unsportsmanlike Conduct and states...

Unsportsmanlike conduct. The referee may take any action they consider equitable, which includes directing that the down be repeated, including assessing a 15-yard penalty, awarding a score, or suspending or forfeiting the game
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grant Green

LionJim

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
11,023
15,146
113
Unhappy with the call or unhappy that your player was putting players at risk of injury?
The latter. You had to ask? This was pretty bush league, I had to turn away back to my math problems to get my head straight.