FC/OT: New Bond cast???

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,639
15,389
113
Love Aaron Taylor Johnson but wrong for Bond IMO.



 
  • Like
Reactions: IrishHerb

Bwifan

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,509
2,744
113
Love Aaron Taylor Johnson but wrong for Bond IMO.




At least it's not a woman like was rumored for awhile.... may sound chauvinist but I like sticking to the original books and story line . I am fine having a female type of James Bond but not anything really remotely close to the Bond character or name. Think they could do better for the next Bond than Aaron Taylor but I will still give it a chance with him.
 

Woodpecker

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
3,395
6,514
113
At least it's not a woman like was rumored for awhile.... may sound chauvinist but I like sticking to the original books and story line . I am fine having a female type of James Bond but not anything really remotely close to the Bond character or name. Think they could do better for the next Bond than Aaron Taylor but I will still give it a chance with him.
I thought that people didn't like that a woman was the new 007 in the last movie, not that she was James Bond.
 

PSU87

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,666
3,388
113
Pietro Maximoff cannot be Bond. Ughhhh...

Should be Idris Elba.

I hope this Aaron Taylor-Johnson thing is just a feint, a trial balloon gone bust...
I personally think a character from books, especially a well established series of books, should remain true to the author's hard work and cast someone that looks like the author's vision, but I'm a big book fan. "Good actor" or "popular actor" shouldn't be the only criteria.

It's one of the reasons I didn't like Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher and loathed Matthew McConaughey as Dirk Pitt (and I like both of them as actors).

I'm probably in the minority there....
 

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,639
15,389
113
I personally think a character from books, especially a well established series of books, should remain true to the author's hard work and cast someone that looks like the author's vision, but I'm a big book fan. "Good actor" or "popular actor" shouldn't be the only criteria.

It's one of the reasons I didn't like Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher and loathed Matthew McConaughey as Dirk Pitt (and I like both of them as actors).

I'm probably in the minority there....

I'm in the middle. I mean, one of the best alt casting choices ever was Zendaya as Mary Jane Parker....but, it can go the other way too.

 
  • Like
Reactions: pioneerlion83

psuro

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
7,777
17,001
113
At least it's not a woman like was rumored for awhile.... may sound chauvinist but I like sticking to the original books and story line . I am fine having a female type of James Bond but not anything really remotely close to the Bond character or name. Think they could do better for the next Bond than Aaron Taylor but I will still give it a chance with him.
Bond was never going to be a woman. A woman got the 007 designation in the last film, because Bond "retired" (or some such thing).

The key elements of Bond's persona are that he is male, caucasian, British, a loner, drinks too much, and is relatively capable of a number of skills from flying a plane to always being in shape to run down the bad guys while wearing a top notch suit. Plus he beds women.

He is an exxagerated version of Sir Ian Fleming.

And he always should be.
 

PSU87

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,666
3,388
113
I'm in the middle. I mean, one of the best alt casting choices ever was Zendaya as Mary Jane Parker....but, it can go the other way too.

You're right. And while my post was hard over on "follow the authors vision" if I thought hard enough I could probably come up with some examples like yours where a "change" worked.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

PSU87

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,666
3,388
113
Bond was never going to be a woman. A woman got the 007 designation in the last film, because Bond "retired" (or some such thing).

The key elements of Bond's persona are that he is male, caucasian, British, a loner, drinks too much, and is relatively capable of a number of skills from flying a plane to always being in shape to run down the bad guys while wearing a top notch suit. Plus he beds women.

He is an exxagerated version of Sir Ian Fleming.

And he always should be.
True. But Fleming also once said that his vision of Bond was Hoagy Carmichael.
1670528436780.png
 

psuro

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
7,777
17,001
113
Ian Fleming



I can see where Hoagy has a bit of a resemblance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSU87

pap

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
6,984
4,660
113
Bond was never going to be a woman. A woman got the 007 designation in the last film, because Bond "retired" (or some such thing).

The key elements of Bond's persona are that he is male, caucasian, British, a loner, drinks too much, and is relatively capable of a number of skills from flying a plane to always being in shape to run down the bad guys while wearing a top notch suit. Plus he beds women.

He is an exxagerated version of Sir Ian Fleming.

And he always should be.
Not quite. Ian Flemming actually worked for the British secret service and left when they left the top agent Sidney Reilly , out to dry during the Russian revolution after WW1 . Reilly was a genius at espionage and tried to stop the Bolshevic revolution , but was caught and later executed .

Flemming liked Reily but after what happened he left . He later created the character as James Bond . The rest has been history . PBS made a special miniseries , hosted by Vincent Price , Reilly ace of spies . Catch it if you can .
 

pioneerlion83

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
4,466
6,264
113
I personally think a character from books, especially a well established series of books, should remain true to the author's hard work and cast someone that looks like the author's vision, but I'm a big book fan. "Good actor" or "popular actor" shouldn't be the only criteria.

It's one of the reasons I didn't like Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher and loathed Matthew McConaughey as Dirk Pitt (and I like both of them as actors).

I'm probably in the minority there....
I've read all the Ian Fleming books and shorts, and Bond is mostly serious, deadly-when-necessary operator; very dry sense of humor. Which is why I think Idris Elba would be good in the role. He's a fantastic actor, great range, gravitas, physically can do the action and stunts. He was floated at the time of Craig's selection, along with Clive Owen and others. But to my changrin these candidates in my mind are becoming too old for Bond, who should be in his early-mid 30's or so, per the novels. But Pietro Maximoff?
 
Last edited:

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,639
15,389
113
I've read all the books, and Bond is mostly serious, deadly when necessary operator. Which is why I think Idris Elba would be good in the role. He's a fantastic actor, great range, gravitas, physically can do the action and stunts. He was floated at the time of Craig's selection, along with Clive Owen and others. But most of these other candidates in my mind are becoming too old for Bond, who should be in his early-mid 30's or so, per the novels. But Pietro Maximoff?

Issue for me with Johnson (who is an impressive physical actor) is he's too boyish. My personal vote was for Tom Hardy, but he's probably too short for the role. Happy to give Johnson a chance, but Elba I think would have been inspired casting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pioneerlion83

pioneerlion83

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
4,466
6,264
113
Bond was never going to be a woman. A woman got the 007 designation in the last film, because Bond "retired" (or some such thing).

The key elements of Bond's persona are that he is male, caucasian, British, a loner, drinks too much, and is relatively capable of a number of skills from flying a plane to always being in shape to run down the bad guys while wearing a top notch suit. Plus he beds women.

He is an exxagerated version of Sir Ian Fleming.

And he always should be.
Or in other words...he is @psuro 2.0!!!! 🤣
 

pioneerlion83

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
4,466
6,264
113
Issue for me with Johnson (who is an impressive physical actor) is he's too boyish. My personal vote was for Tom Hardy, but he's probably too short for the role. Happy to give Johnson a chance, but Elba I think would have been inspired casting.
Yes, Johnson seems too boyish. Bond is not boyish.

I also agree with you that Tom Hardy would have been a good choice.
 

pioneerlion83

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
4,466
6,264
113
Not quite. Ian Flemming actually worked for the British secret service and left when they left the top agent Sidney Reilly , out to dry during the Russian revolution after WW1 . Reilly was a genius at espionage and tried to stop the Bolshevic revolution , but was caught and later executed .

Flemming liked Reily but after what happened he left . He later created the character as James Bond . The rest has been history . PBS made a special miniseries , hosted by Vincent Price , Reilly ace of spies . Catch it if you can .
Without googling, I think Sam Neill (another fine dramatic actor, who could do the physical parts and stunts in his younger days) played Reilly, right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

LionJim

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
10,657
14,725
113
Not quite. Ian Flemming actually worked for the British secret service and left when they left the top agent Sidney Reilly , out to dry during the Russian revolution after WW1 . Reilly was a genius at espionage and tried to stop the Bolshevic revolution , but was caught and later executed .

Flemming liked Reily but after what happened he left . He later created the character as James Bond . The rest has been history . PBS made a special miniseries , hosted by Vincent Price , Reilly ace of spies . Catch it if you can .
Fleming was born in 1908; Reilly died in 1925. But, yes, Fleming did base Bond on Reilly.
 

pap

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
6,984
4,660
113
Fleming was born in 1908; Reilly died in 1925. But, yes, Fleming did base Bond on Reilly.
I know . When you watch the miniseries on PBS you will find out all the info at the end of the series . I did
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

LionJim

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
10,657
14,725
113
I know . When you watch the miniseries on PBS you will find out all the info at the end of the series . I did
“Reilly, Ace of Spies?” I saw that back in 1983, still remember it.
 

84lion

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
432
682
93
I was really impressed with Elba in Pacific Rim (which I thought was a fun movie), but Bond? I dunno. I agree with 'ro:

The key elements of Bond's persona are that he is male, caucasian, British, a loner, drinks too much, and is relatively capable of a number of skills from flying a plane to always being in shape to run down the bad guys while wearing a top notch suit. Plus he beds women.

He is an exxagerated version of Sir Ian Fleming.

And he always should be.

Elba is a great actor and has a great presence...but he's not Fleming's Bond.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSU87

interrobang

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
674
1,197
93
Not quite. Ian Flemming actually worked for the British secret service and left when they left the top agent Sidney Reilly , out to dry during the Russian revolution after WW1 . Reilly was a genius at espionage and tried to stop the Bolshevic revolution , but was caught and later executed .

Flemming liked Reily but after what happened he left . He later created the character as James Bond . The rest has been history . PBS made a special miniseries , hosted by Vincent Price , Reilly ace of spies . Catch it if you can .

Fleming is a character in the true story mini series Operation Mincemeat on Netflix
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login