How's this for an all time NCAAF FB College Team: (No PSU included, b/c it would be too difficult)

[Mr. Potter]

Basing this team only by the accomplishments in college not the NFL.

Offense:

QB: Tim Tebow
RB: Jim Brown (*Heart wanted Barry Sanders)
FB: Mike Alstott
WR: Randy Moss
WR: Larry Fitzgerald
TE: Jeremy Shockey
OT: Orlando Pace
OT: Bill Fralic
C: Barrett Jones. (Chuck Bednarik
G: Steve Hutchinson.
G: Chris Samuels

Defense:

DE: Hugh Green
DE: Reggie White
DT: Warren Sapp
DT: Ndamukong Suh (Almost went Casey Hampton or Wilfork)
LB: Lawrence Taylor
LB: Dick Butkus
LB: Mike Singletary
Safety: Ed Reed
Safety: Troy Polamalu
CB: Charles Woodson
CB: Deon Sanders

K: Sebastian Janikowski
P: Matt Araiza

KR/PR: Raghib Ismail and Reggie Bush. (Interchange the two however you desire.)
P: Matt Matt Araiza

 

[psuro]

QB: Tim Tebow
RB: Jim Brown (*Heart wanted Barry Sanders) OJ Simpson
FB: Mike Alstott
WR: Randy Moss Jerry Rice
WR: Larry Fitzgerald Fred Biletnikoff
TE: Jeremy Shockey
OT: Orlando Pace
OT: Bill Fralic
C: Barrett Jones. (Chuck Bednarik Dave Rimington
G: Steve Hutchinson.
G: Chris Samuels

Defense:

DE: Hugh Green
DE: Reggie White
DT: Warren Sapp
DT: Ndamukong Suh (Almost went Casey Hampton or Wilfork)
LB: Lawrence Taylor
LB: Dick Butkus
LB: Mike Singletary
Safety: Ed Reed
Safety: Troy Polamalu
CB: Charles Woodson
CB: Deon Sanders

K: Sebastian Janikowski
P: Matt Araiza

KR/PR: Raghib Ismail and Reggie Bush. (Interchange the two however you desire.)


Just a couple thoughts. It's not easy to match different eras.

But, not sure why Tebow. I mean - Shaffer had a better win percentage than Tebow. Lots of guys threw more yards and touchdowns. But, I guess his Rock Star persona is key. You could have success Kyler Murray, Joe Burrow or Baker Mayfield. Heck, Spurrier was a heck of QB in college.

 

[LionJim]

The greatest college football player I’ve seen was Jerome Brown.

 

[s1uggo72]

Basing this team only by the accomplishments in college not the NFL.

Offense:

QB: Tim Tebow
RB: Jim Brown (*Heart wanted Barry Sanders)
FB: Mike Alstott
WR: Randy Moss
WR: Larry Fitzgerald
TE: Jeremy Shockey
OT: Orlando Pace
OT: Bill Fralic
C: Barrett Jones. (Chuck Bednarik
G: Steve Hutchinson.
G: Chris Samuels

Defense:

DE: Hugh Green
DE: Reggie White
DT: Warren Sapp
DT: Ndamukong Suh (Almost went Casey Hampton or Wilfork)
LB: Lawrence Taylor
LB: Dick Butkus
LB: Mike Singletary
Safety: Ed Reed
Safety: Troy Polamalu
CB: Charles Woodson
CB: Deon Sanders

K: Sebastian Janikowski
P: Matt Araiza

KR/PR: Raghib Ismail and Reggie Bush. (Interchange the two however you desire.)
P: Matt Matt Araiza

Mike Alstott wasn’t a FB. LT wasn’t that good in college lot better to choose from

 

[WSTLion87]

I know he played for the evil empire, but I would go with Dorsett at RB. The second half of the game with Pitt in '76 was like nothing I've seen before or since.

 

[IrishHerb]

QB: Tim Tebow
RB: Jim Brown (*Heart wanted Barry Sanders) OJ Simpson
FB: Mike Alstott
WR: Randy Moss Jerry Rice
WR: Larry Fitzgerald Fred Biletnikoff
TE: Jeremy Shockey
OT: Orlando Pace
OT: Bill Fralic
C: Barrett Jones. (Chuck Bednarik Dave Rimington
G: Steve Hutchinson.
G: Chris Samuels

Defense:

DE: Hugh Green
DE: Reggie White
DT: Warren Sapp
DT: Ndamukong Suh (Almost went Casey Hampton or Wilfork)
LB: Lawrence Taylor
LB: Dick Butkus
LB: Mike Singletary
Safety: Ed Reed
Safety: Troy Polamalu
CB: Charles Woodson
CB: Deon Sanders

K: Sebastian Janikowski
P: Matt Araiza

KR/PR: Raghib Ismail and Reggie Bush. (Interchange the two however you desire.)


Just a couple thoughts. It's not easy to match different eras.

But, not sure why Tebow. I mean - Shaffer had a better win percentage than Tebow. Lots of guys threw more yards and touchdowns. But, I guess his Rock Star persona is key. You could have success Kyler Murray, Joe Burrow or Baker Mayfield. Heck, Spurrier was a heck of QB in college.

even Jim McMahon, Archie Manning, and many others.

 

[STPGopherfan]

IMHO Defense is harder. If it was a odd numbered front, I'd throw Michael Carter in the mix. He was such a dominant Nose tackle. Running Back is hard for me because there were so many good ones. Eric Dickerson, Marcus Allen, and Eddie George were hard backs to judge. The were striders and made their attempts look effortless. Never saw film of Payton in college.

Ki-Jana Carter was a terror for one season, but that entire team was great offensively.