In PSU FB History what recruit did you think was a lock that never panned out?

Ceasar

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
3,936
9,134
113
Ron Graham. RJ Luke, Bruce Branch, Titcus Pettigrew, Corey Jones, Christian Hackenberg, Shane Simmons, Antonio Logan-El, Floyd Wedderburn….
I thought Bruce Branch was a really good player for PSU and one of the best punt returners in PSU history. Just my .02.
I always feel like Quintas gets a bit of a bad rap. I understand why as he was that era's version of a 5*. But he was a multi-year starter or key contributor at PSU and played several years in the NFL. When I think of guys who did not "make it", I don't think of guys who had NFL careers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob78 and LionJim

PhillyBillyReprise

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2021
574
981
93
Joel Holler never had the privilege of playing a snap in Beaver Stadium.

A 4-star recruit and one of the best high school offensive linemen in the country, scouts labeled Holler as one of the best offensive line prospects in the nation in 2003. Unfortunately for Penn State and Holler, that label never translated to success at the college level. He transferred to Delaware.
 
Last edited:

Bvillebaron

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,589
1,713
113
I thought Bruce Branch was a really good player for PSU and one of the best punt returners in PSU history. Just my .02.

I always feel like Quintas gets a bit of a bad rap. I understand why as he was that era's version of a 5*. But he was a multi-year starter or key contributor at PSU and played several years in the NFL. When I think of guys who did not "make it", I don't think of guys who had NFL careers.
Maybe you are right. On the other hand, he was the consensus No 1 player in the country when he was recruited. He certainly didn’t play at that level at PSU.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ceasar

Bvillebaron

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,589
1,713
113
In the legendary '91 we had two USA Today All-Americans Stephen Pitts and an offensive lineman from Ohio named Scott Stratton. Pitts had a solid career but could never emerge from Carter's shadow. Stratton was passed by another lineman from Ohio in the same class named Jeff Hartings.

I often wonder what could've been with Conestoga Valley's Corey Jones especially if he a QB. That kid was FAST! He was the second-ranked receiver in the country his senior year behind some Randy Moss guy who I heard was okay.
If I recall correctly, Jones had trouble getting off the line of scrimmage against press coverage.
 

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,197
8,127
113
Silas Redd!
Respectfully disagree. It was evident he was talented as a true freshman. His sophomore year at PSU he had over 1,200 yards and 7 TDs. He never panned out at USC after he transferred but he was productive at PSU. He made a big mistake transferring. He would have been the feature back and a major part of the offense at PSU under BO’B. Zwinak reaped the benefits of him transferring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob78 and Bison13

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,602
15,307
113
Nick Sukay, Chris McKelvy, JB Walton, Eric Shrive, Sam Ruhe, Chris Bell, Tim Johnson, Joel Holler, Jerome Hayes, Shamar Finney, Garrett Sickles, Brandon Beachum,, Shawn Oakman, Evan Hailes, Andre Robinson, Brandon Snow….
 

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,197
8,127
113
Nick Sukay, Chris McKelvy, JB Walton, Eric Shrive, Sam Ruhe, Chris Bell, Tim Johnson, Joel Holler, Jerome Hayes, Shamar Finney, Garrett Sickles, Brandon Beachum,, Shawn Oakman, Evan Hailes, Andre Robinson, Brandon Snow….
That’s quite a list. I always thought Jerome Hayes was a pretty good player. Unfortunately, I think he blew out both knees during his time at PSU. Oakman was a beast…..at Baylor. Sickels was a solid contributor in 2016. Hailes had to retire due to a medical condition if I remember correctly?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Bison13

Well-known member
Oct 13, 2021
1,943
3,303
113
Nick Sukay, Chris McKelvy, JB Walton, Eric Shrive, Sam Ruhe, Chris Bell, Tim Johnson, Joel Holler, Jerome Hayes, Shamar Finney, Garrett Sickles, Brandon Beachum,, Shawn Oakman, Evan Hailes, Andre Robinson, Brandon Snow….
I never got the JB Walton love. Hes from southern md and I saw him play. Beat up on crap teams, didn't have a good body frame, sloppy in the middle. Moved well for a big guy but never thought of him as a mauler OG.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,602
15,307
113
I never got the JB Walton love. Hes from southern md and I saw him play. Beat up on crap teams, didn't have a good body frame, sloppy in the middle. Moved well for a big guy but never thought of him as a mauler OG.

He was highly rated though.
 

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,602
15,307
113
That’s quite a list. I always thought Jerome Hayes was a pretty good player. Unfortunately, I think he blew out both knees during his time at PSU. Oakman was a beast…..at Baylor. Sickels was a solid contributor in 2016. Hailes had to retire due to a medical condition if I remember correctly?

Hayes had a decent career but recall he was close to a 5* recruit; injuries did him in though as you noted. Had the privilege of watching him sack Jimmy Clausen a couple times though. Worth it.
 

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,197
8,127
113
Hayes had a decent career but recall he was close to a 5* recruit; injuries did him in though as you noted. Had the privilege of watching him sack Jimmy Clausen a couple times though. Worth it.
Yeah, he played his butt off in that game. Nothing better than seeing him cream Clausen a few times. That game is one of my favorites. They owed ND from the year before and I’m not a Charlie Weis fan.
 

WSTLion87

Well-known member
Oct 10, 2021
747
1,591
93
Anyone remember Greg Harrison from '03? I think he was the third-rated lineman in the country or something like that... Mark Farris (North Hills) was another big swing and miss,

As an aside... When you look back at the Y2K class and believe me I am not the knowledgeable recruiting follower but it seems that class was put together so quickly and dare I say carelessly that it was filled up by September 99 and signing day was not until February 00. IMHO... The 1999 and 2000 Recruiting Classes are what led PSU football to the dark ages. In '99 (The we missed out on Chris Simms class...) we took something like 11 kids with Bryan Scott and Bryant Johnson as the only ones who flourished. In 2000, we took something like 30 with Cameron Wake as the only player who made a significant contribution in the NFL. Although, Sean McHugh did get a Super Bowl ring with the Steelers.
 

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
6,197
8,127
113
Anyone remember Greg Harrison from '03? I think he was the third-rated lineman in the country or something like that... Mark Farris (North Hills) was another big swing and miss,

As an aside... When you look back at the Y2K class and believe me I am not the knowledgeable recruiting follower but it seems that class was put together so quickly and dare I say carelessly that it was filled up by September 99 and signing day was not until February 00. IMHO... The 1999 and 2000 Recruiting Classes are what led PSU football to the dark ages. In '99 (The we missed out on Chris Simms class...) we took something like 11 kids with Bryan Scott and Bryant Johnson as the only ones who flourished. In 2000, we took something like 30 with Cameron Wake as the only player who made a significant contribution in the NFL. Although, Sean McHugh did get a Super Bowl ring with the Steelers.
Jay was the recruiting coordinator during those years you speak of. He only held that title for a short time after this.
 

BW Lion

Well-known member
Oct 14, 2021
3,103
2,436
113
I nominate the guy who, on film, could jump out of a 4’ deep swimming pool but later knocked up his girlfriend. Dakota Royer.?

Years later another recruit, Saquon Barkley, also easily jumped out of a swimming pool.

Oops, he also knocked up his girlfriend. Coincidental?

Modern Aesop says “don’t jump up out of pools”.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

Lacklions

Well-known member
Dec 23, 2021
3,551
11,019
113
Nick Sukay, Chris McKelvy, JB Walton, Eric Shrive, Sam Ruhe, Chris Bell, Tim Johnson, Joel Holler, Jerome Hayes, Shamar Finney, Garrett Sickles, Brandon Beachum,, Shawn Oakman, Evan Hailes, Andre Robinson, Brandon Snow….
Shawn Oakman did have 11 sacks in a season at baylor though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LB99 and Midnighter

Jason1743

Well-known member
Oct 20, 2021
2,581
4,888
113
As far as I can remember he was the only 5 star DB that Joe ever recruited.

Eric Renkeys recruitment was a bitter battle with Pitt abd I think one other school. Not only did he not do anything on the field he was barely eligible -and he was a smart kid. He finished out ok but not what what he could have been if he applied himself earlier in his career. On and off the field.
Justin King was a five star db recruit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psuro

lemonears

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2021
307
545
93
Michael Timpson -- arguably the fastest player ever to play at Penn State. A wide receiver in the late 1980s. Every pass seemed to just fall off the tips of his fingers.
 

PSUFTG

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
1,458
2,264
113
I never got the JB Walton love. Hes from southern md and I saw him play. Beat up on crap teams, didn't have a good body frame, sloppy in the middle. Moved well for a big guy but never thought of him as a mauler OG.
He may have been the kid with severe learning disabilities - but my memory could be less than 100% there.
If it is the one I am thinking of, that pretty much precluded him from ever having much of a shot on the field, and hopefully he was able to work through those issues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

Classof09

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
952
1,969
93
I thought Justin was a better WR than DB.
Absolutely agreed. I wonder how much of that, like for 95% of our DB’s lack of success, was/is due to the technique. An 8 yard cushion with a turn and run style doesn’t lend itself to many big plays.
 

Bison13

Well-known member
Oct 13, 2021
1,943
3,303
113
He may have been the kid with severe learning disabilities - but my memory could be less than 100% there.
If it is the one I am thinking of, that pretty much precluded him from ever having much of a shot on the field, and hopefully he was able to work through those issues.
Yes that was him. He played at Lackey HS in southern MD, not much of a football power and really back then none of those teams outside of 1 or 2 in their whole conference were any good. Back then SoMd was still all tobacco, beef, soybean, oyster farming, a lot of those kids just got passed through the system because they were just going to go back to the family farm or work on someones farm. Moved very well and was 'country' strong but it was all natural, nothing from work out stuff. Tape was him beating up on scrubs and he had no technique.

Over the last 15 years though that area has blown up, I think 3 new HS down there since then and already a need for another. Guys like Rasheed Walker are from down that way and the coaching level has gone up some along with better youth programs
 

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,602
15,307
113
If I recall correctly, Jones had trouble getting off the line of scrimmage against press coverage.

He was small too; maybe 5'9" if being generous. He had good hands and some wheels, but was probably way overrated coming out of HS. He was ranked as high as Randy Moss (same year).
 

pamdlion

Well-known member
Dec 2, 2021
3,134
5,755
113
Antonio Logan-El

Jim Kelly and Jeff Hostetler... oops...never mind
 
Last edited:

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,602
15,307
113
Absolutely agreed. I wonder how much of that, like for 95% of our DB’s lack of success, was/is due to the technique. An 8 yard cushion with a turn and run style doesn’t lend itself to many big plays.

King led the Big Ten in passes defended one year. But he was small. That Indiana receiver tore him up.
 

PSU1993

Member
Oct 29, 2021
25
47
13
Joel Holler never had the privilege of playing a snap in Beaver Stadium.

A 4-star recruit and one of the best high school offensive linemen in the country, scouts labeled Holler as one of the best offensive line prospects in the nation in 2003. Unfortunately for Penn State and Holler, that label never translated to success at the college level. He transferred to Delaware.
Holler transferred to Delaware and couldn't make it there. The guy just didn't have the football mentality or toughness. Just a huge guy so everyone assumed he should love football. He eventually left the UD team early as well. Story I heard is that he got so broken down that he sat on the practice field at UD and started crying. His locker was cleaned out the next day.
 

PSU1993

Member
Oct 29, 2021
25
47
13
Shamar Finney is the one who always jumps out at me. Really thought he was the next Lavar. Didn't work out for him. Justin King is another who I thought would have a better career.
 

WSTLion87

Well-known member
Oct 10, 2021
747
1,591
93
Josh Marks out of Southern Columbia and if I am correct he's the last So Col recruit to play at PSU. Makes me wonder if that had any bearing on you know who not coming here...
 
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login