Keep hiring Coordinators....

Bullldawg78

Well-known member
Aug 30, 2018
1,201
761
113
Why do we keep hiring Coordinators as head coaches? We need people with head coaching experience manning the ship! Look at our track record for coordinators over the last 25 years versus head coaches! Like leach or not we were having success under him. Why can freaking Indiana figure out that the HEAD coach at James Madison knows how tobe a HEAD coach. Look at them this year. They didn't hire the special teams coach or wife receivers coach at JMU they hired a HEAD coach! Ok I'm done but this just really burns my a$$! And yes I know what Mullen did he is an outlier.
 

Thebulldogcountry1

Active member
Nov 6, 2022
249
462
63
Being a State fan is feeling more and more like voluntarily paying taxes to another governement entitly. The rich seems to get to make the real decisions, and those in charge are either powerless or just incompetent. We are expected to pay for all of it without any explanation or accountability. We never get any real answers about anything.

I think, at a minimum, we deserve to know why a DC with no experience was paid a million dollars and given a multi-year contract.
 

HumpDawgy

Well-known member
Apr 6, 2010
4,581
1,624
113
Agree 100%. I don't want to see another first time head coach hired again. I would rather go into DII for a head coach to hire than hire another coordinator with no head coaching experience to learn on the job against the SEC. Dan Mullen was the only one I can remember being successful. Maybe you can throw in Tyler, but that was a different game then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: was21 and patdog

patdog

Well-known member
May 28, 2007
48,746
12,741
113
Supposedly Barry Odom really wanted the job.

I'd like to know how true this is. If he interviewed and if yes, why he wasn't selected.
No one else was considered. And of course Barry Odom would have wanted the job. As well as a number of other experienced coaches at G5 or I-AA levels.
Agree 100%. I don't want to see another first time head coach hired again. I would rather go into DII for a head coach to hire than hire another coordinator with no head coaching experience to learn on the job against the SEC. Dan Mullen was the only one I can remember being successful. Maybe you can throw in Tyler, but that was a different game then.
im not against ever hiring a coordinator. Kirby Smart was a coordinator. Dan Mullen was a coordinator. But in the situation we were in, we needed an experienced head coach. Because there was, and still is, a very real risk of our football program becoming a train wreck we can’t recover from for close to a decade.
 
Last edited:

The Peeper

Well-known member
Feb 26, 2008
12,243
5,540
113
Supposedly Barry Odom really wanted the job.

I'd like to know how true this is. If he interviewed and if yes, why he wasn't selected.
I don't know if he was interested or interviewed but at the time he was 25-25 at Mizzou 13-19 in conference and 0-3 in bowls. But, considering it was at Mizzou maybe not too bad a record.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

Dawgzilla2

Well-known member
Oct 9, 2022
902
1,052
93
I'm not sure head coaching experience is required, but they do need to have experience that shows they are ready to lead an SEC program. Coaches like Mullen and Kirby Snart spent several years as coordinators under successful head coaches before making the move to SEC head coach.

Being an SEC HC is hard, and having HC experience on your resume still does not necessarily prepare you for success. Moorhead had HC experience. Mullen's HC experience did not prepare him for success at Florida.

Felker, Croom, and Arnett were just bad hires. It wasn't just the lack of HC experience; there was nothing on their resume to replace the lack of HC experience. They arguably deserved a shot at leading smaller programs, but nothing indicated they were ready to be SEC HC's.

Moorhead, OTOH, had a great resume. The only thing he lacked was extended D1 experience, which turned out to be important.
 

Dawgbite

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2011
6,296
4,825
113
Ok, I’ll play devils advocate. Sitting head coaches learned their craft in the old college football. That no longer exists. What we have now is uncharted territory. We need someone young, innovative, and adaptable and most head coaches are none of the above therefor We hire coordinators. It’s only a bad hire if it fails. I don’t know if I believe this anymore than some of the other BS posted on here. I just don’t know anymore!
 
  • Like
Reactions: was21 and RockyDog

Dawgzilla2

Well-known member
Oct 9, 2022
902
1,052
93
Imagine where our program would be today if the Giants had not saved us from Joe Judge.

We may have reached our current level of incompetence by 2022...only we might still have Cohen as our AD since hiring Judge might have kept Auburn from wanting him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Cooterpoot

johnson86-1

Well-known member
Aug 22, 2012
12,280
2,502
113
Why do we keep hiring Coordinators as head coaches? We need people with head coaching experience manning the ship! Look at our track record for coordinators over the last 25 years versus head coaches! Like leach or not we were having success under him. Why can freaking Indiana figure out that the HEAD coach at James Madison knows how tobe a HEAD coach. Look at them this year. They didn't hire the special teams coach or wife receivers coach at JMU they hired a HEAD coach! Ok I'm done but this just really burns my a$$! And yes I know what Mullen did he is an outlier.
Because Joe Moorhead was good?

I'm with you that all else equal I would prefer a G5 head coach to a P4 coordinator. But G5 head coaches that show any amount of promise are snatched up faster than in the past and by better programs. Billy Napier leveraging being a less successful Hudspeth into the Florida job is just surreal and I don't think would have happened 20 years ago. Or if it happened, everybody would have thought the AD was crazy rather than just thinking the AD got worked in negotiation over salary and guarantee.

I think you're going to see more coaches get more time before getting fired (mainly because of wanting to save money for NIL) and you'll probably see some more retreads get better job offers when they were fired in less than 4 years (partly to save money and partly because it's going to take a second before there is a decent stable of coaches at G5 with long enough track records to justify big time jobs).
 

L4Dawg

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2016
6,428
3,652
113
I'm not sure head coaching experience is required, but they do need to have experience that shows they are ready to lead an SEC program. Coaches like Mullen and Kirby Snart spent several years as coordinators under successful head coaches before making the move to SEC head coach.

Being an SEC HC is hard, and having HC experience on your resume still does not necessarily prepare you for success. Moorhead had HC experience. Mullen's HC experience did not prepare him for success at Florida.

Felker, Croom, and Arnett were just bad hires. It wasn't just the lack of HC experience; there was nothing on their resume to replace the lack of HC experience. They arguably deserved a shot at leading smaller programs, but nothing indicated they were ready to be SEC HC's.

Moorhead, OTOH, had a great resume. The only thing he lacked was extended D1 experience, which turned out to be important.
Moorhead had a fantastic resume. You just never know. It's not just about being a good coach. There is that unmeasurable intangible called FIT. Mullen just fit here. Moorhead did not. Mullen didn't fit at Florida.
 

Maroon13

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2022
1,872
1,892
113
he was 25-25 at Mizzou 13-19 in conference and 0-3 in bowls. But, considering it was at Mizzou maybe not too bad a record.
Yeah that was the argument last December. When he was awarded Mountain West coach of the year. Now he is 6-2 this year, total 15-7 at UNLV.

Also he is former DC. Which is what is needed at MSU. If you are a halfway decent coach, You can recruit athletes here and build a defense.

But I digress. We better hope Lebby works out. We can't fire another HC after 1-2 years. Nobody will touch this job if we do
 
  • Like
Reactions: 85Bears and patdog

Seinfeld

Well-known member
Nov 30, 2006
9,635
3,759
113
No one else was considered. And of course Barry Odom would have wanted the job. As well as a number of other experienced coaches at G5 or I-AA levels.

im not against ever hiring a coordinator. Kirby Smart was a coordinator. Dan Mullen was a coordinator. But in the situation we were in, we needed an experienced head coach. Because there was, and stop is, a very real risk of our football program becoming a train wreck we can’t recover from for close to a decade.
Especially when you consider that during the prior decade, we’d made the following HC hires:

1) Acting HC (Leach) - generally successful 3 year run
2) Coordinator hires (Moorhead & Arnett) - Utter disasters

So of course we decide to hire a coordinator. What could possibly go wrong?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 85Bears

OG Goat Holder

Well-known member
Sep 30, 2022
7,980
7,567
113
Ok, I’ll play devils advocate. Sitting head coaches learned their craft in the old college football. That no longer exists. What we have now is uncharted territory. We need someone young, innovative, and adaptable and most head coaches are none of the above therefor We hire coordinators. It’s only a bad hire if it fails. I don’t know if I believe this anymore than some of the other BS posted on here. I just don’t know anymore!
Fundamental aspects of season preparation and gameday coaching still exists. We aren't getting any of that currently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

patdog

Well-known member
May 28, 2007
48,746
12,741
113
But I digress. We better hope Lebby works out. We can't fire another HC after 1-2 years. Nobody will touch this job if we do
So how many years of 2-10 does it take before our job becomes attractive to good candidates? We're not firing Lebby this year, and we shouldn't (barring an unthinkable loss to UMass). But next year, he has to show real improvement. There will always be decent candidates for a job in the SEC that pays what we can.
 

Maroon13

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2022
1,872
1,892
113
So how many years of 2-10 does it take before our job becomes attractive to good candidates? We're not firing Lebby this year, and we shouldn't (barring an unthinkable loss to UMass). But next year, he has to show real improvement. There will always be decent candidates for a job in the SEC that pays what we can.
Yeah I think if worst case scenario happens next year, 2-10 and recruiting not looking good, the AD works the back channels with agents to get some feedback on the interest in the job. You make the decision based on if any viable candidate is interested.
 

StateCollege

Well-known member
Oct 17, 2022
501
761
93
There is just no silver bullet. Look back at the 2018 HC hire cycle.

Hired with prior HC experience:
  • Scott Frost to Nebraska - Looked like an absolute slam dunk and he failed miserably.
  • Jimbo Fisher to TAMU - Was 83-23 at FSU with a national title
  • Mullen to Florida - We all know the story here
  • Chip Kelly to UCLA - Eventually turned them around in Year 4, but left for an OC job
  • Willie Taggart to FSU - Had some decent success of turning WKU and USF around prior, but was a dumpster fire at FSU
  • Chad Morris to Arky - Had turned SMU around, but a disaster in Fayetteville.
  • Kevin Sumlin to Arizona - Was very average at TAMU, but awful at Arizona
  • Herm Edwards to Arizona State - Yeesh
  • Sonny Dykes to SMU - Did well at SMU
  • Mario Cristobal to Oregon - Had been at FIU before with minimal success, but obviously has figured things out since
No prior HC experience:
  • Moorhead - No explanation needed
  • Matt Luke - Kind of a unique situation here with the Freeze stuff, but ultimately was meh and fired.
  • Josh Heupel to UCF - Obviously worked out pretty well for him
  • Jeremy Pruitt to UT - Another disaster
  • Billy Napier to ULL - Solid at ULL, obviously not cut out for SEC
  • Jonathan Smith to Oregon St - Did great things at OSU before bolting
ETA - Forgot about Moorhead's time at Fordham. So technically had been a HC, just not in major CFB.
 
Last edited:

HomeBoyDawg

Active member
Oct 22, 2013
936
542
73
Supposedly Barry Odom really wanted the job.

I'd like to know how true this is. If he interviewed and if yes, why he wasn't selected.
tom cruise GIF
 

The Peeper

Well-known member
Feb 26, 2008
12,243
5,540
113
The only thing he lacked was extended D1 experience, which turned out to be important.
He lacked the ability to accept constructive criticism or the ability to admit when he was wrong too. He was going to do it his way regardless of what anyone elsethought i.e. hard headed
 

The Peeper

Well-known member
Feb 26, 2008
12,243
5,540
113
Yeah that was the argument last December. When he was awarded Mountain West coach of the year. Now he is 6-2 this year, total 15-7 at UNLV.

Also he is former DC. Which is what is needed at MSU. If you are a halfway decent coach, You can recruit athletes here and build a defense.

But I digress. We better hope Lebby works out. We can't fire another HC after 1-2 years. Nobody will touch this job if we do
If he had been hired here w/ just an overall .500 record and 13-19 in the SEC there would have been a mutiny among supporters. You can't consult the crystal ball to see what they do in the future, you can only go on what they've done in the past and to that point he hadn't gotten it done.
 

The Cooterpoot

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2022
4,294
7,083
113
Why do we keep hiring Coordinators as head coaches? We need people with head coaching experience manning the ship! Look at our track record for coordinators over the last 25 years versus head coaches! Like leach or not we were having success under him. Why can freaking Indiana figure out that the HEAD coach at James Madison knows how tobe a HEAD coach. Look at them this year. They didn't hire the special teams coach or wife receivers coach at JMU they hired a HEAD coach! Ok I'm done but this just really burns my a$$! And yes I know what Mullen did he is an outlier.
Mullen was fine as a coordinator, Moorhead was trash with HC experience. Leach was a great HC at one time and left us no talent because he stopped recruiting. AU has hired a couple HCs the last couple times and they've struggled. Vandy hired an assistant and let him build the program.
FL is close to firing multiple proven HCs in a row. Imagine if Indiana played our schedule. It would be ugly.
 

johnson86-1

Well-known member
Aug 22, 2012
12,280
2,502
113
Especially when you consider that during the prior decade, we’d made the following HC hires:

1) Acting HC (Leach) - generally successful 3 year run
2) Coordinator hires (Moorhead & Arnett) - Utter disasters

So of course we decide to hire a coordinator. What could possibly go wrong?
It was at a lower level, but Moorhead was a head coach.

Now if it's true that the Furman basically offered athletic scholarships and the other schools in their conference did not, that head coaching experience shouldn't count for anything. If that's true, Moorhead had no business being offered. Failing at UConn and then being successful with at PSU with a generational talent at RB and a good NFL prospect at QB and WR doesn't tell you anything about how somebody can be a head coach at an SEC school period, much less a have-not school.
 

HumpDawgy

Well-known member
Apr 6, 2010
4,581
1,624
113
I want a guy who has been in charge of a successful football program at some point in their careers. I don't think that is asking for too much for an SEC head coaching job.
 

DesotoCountyDawg

Well-known member
Nov 16, 2005
22,306
9,930
113
There is just no silver bullet. Look back at the 2018 HC hire cycle.

Hired with prior HC experience:
  • Scott Frost to Nebraska - Looked like an absolute slam dunk and he failed miserably.
  • Jimbo Fisher to TAMU - Was 83-23 at FSU with a national title
  • Mullen to Florida - We all know the story here
  • Chip Kelly to UCLA - Eventually turned them around in Year 4, but left for an OC job
  • Willie Taggart to FSU - Had some decent success of turning WKU and USF around prior, but was a dumpster fire at FSU
  • Chad Morris to Arky - Had turned SMU around, but a disaster in Fayetteville.
  • Kevin Sumlin to Arizona - Was very average at TAMU, but awful at Arizona
  • Herm Edwards to Arizona State - Yeesh
  • Sonny Dykes to SMU - Did well at SMU
  • Mario Cristobal to Oregon - Had been at FIU before with minimal success, but obviously has figured things out since
No prior HC experience:
  • Moorhead - No explanation needed
  • Matt Luke - Kind of a unique situation here with the Freeze stuff, but ultimately was meh and fired.
  • Josh Heupel to UCF - Obviously worked out pretty well for him
  • Jeremy Pruitt to UT - Another disaster
  • Billy Napier to ULL - Solid at ULL, obviously not cut out for SEC
  • Jonathan Smith to Oregon St - Did great things at OSU before bolting
Thank you for this. I was going to do the same.
 

Maroon13

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2022
1,872
1,892
113
If he had been hired here w/ just an overall .500 record and 13-19 in the SEC there would have been a mutiny among supporters. You can't consult the crystal ball to see what they do in the future, you can only go on what they've done in the past and to that point he hadn't gotten it done
He did not have one losing season at Missouri. Regardless, in 2023 he was 9-3 at UNLV and named Mountain West COY.......a few days after our search.
 

mcdawg22

Well-known member
Sep 18, 2004
11,083
5,164
113

I don’t think some of you realize what a crapshoot HC hires are. For those that don’t want to look there were 9 coaches on this list that were B or better and all were fired except for Chip Kelly who was probably going to be. Also of note were two c+ or worse Johnathan Smith and Josh Heupel.
If you look at the six most consistent teams in the last 10 years OSU, UGA, and Clemson hired ACs. Bama and Mich hired NFL HC. Oregon hired two HCs one of which failed. And two ACs, one of which has them #1 in the country and the other one failed.
If you want to say well they are blue bloods look at other schools that weren’t consistent. FSU, UF, USC, AU, Tenn, Texas, Oklahoma Miami all have hired HCs and ACs with wildly varying levels of success.
 

85Bears

Well-known member
Jan 12, 2020
1,488
1,327
108
I want a guy who has been in charge of a successful football program at some point in their careers. I don't think that is asking for too much for an SEC head coaching job.
A guy with HC experience can oversee the entire program, has experience hiring coaches, has connections to bring in decent people, it’s a big advantage over a guy who has never done it. Some coordinators are not cut out to be head coaches even if they are good coordinators.

SEC just isn’t a good place to learn on the job when having to do a rebuild on a budget. You have too many variables there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HumpDawgy

OG Goat Holder

Well-known member
Sep 30, 2022
7,980
7,567
113
There’s a little thing called fit. You want a coach who has done it at similar programs with similar circumstances. This isn’t hard.
 

BoDawg.sixpack

Well-known member
Feb 5, 2010
4,382
1,454
113
There’s a little thing called fit. You want a coach who has done it at similar programs with similar circumstances. This isn’t hard.
Even then it's not guaranteed. Truth be told the administrative skill set that it takes to be a head coach in the SEC is turning out to be too much for a lot of candidates who had success out of conference and WOULD have had success in the SEC 10-15 years ago. You have to be a CEO, an administrative head, have to understand social media and marketing, have to be good at evaluating talent, you have to know x's and o's, and at times you have to have enough knowledge of mental health issues to preempt friction inside the team. The requirements of the job have outgrown the ability of a majority of candidates to learn to adapt in that environment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: was21

Dawgzilla2

Well-known member
Oct 9, 2022
902
1,052
93
He lacked the ability to accept constructive criticism or the ability to admit when he was wrong too. He was going to do it his way regardless of what anyone elsethought i.e. hard headed
LULZ! I didn't realize hard headedness was a category on coaching resumes.

ETA: I believe having faith in your system and ignoring criticism is a necessary aspect of being a successful head coach. You think Leach was open to constructive criticism? What about Mullen, who kept his country club employed and basically dared anyone to question him.
 
Last edited:
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login