Penn State ranked (for Academics) number 66 out of the 132 schools that have D1 (FBS) Football

Catch1lion

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,033
3,160
113
What bothers me most is that PSU seems to consistently place low in just about every one of these sort of rankings which come down the pike. Maybe I’m overlooking something but this ranking seems to be completely on brand.
On the good news side, all the recent PSU grads I know have gotten good jobs or a good grad school program . No shortage of kids wanting to go there either from what I can tell . No one is saying gee their US News ranking is sliding I’m not going there .
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

step.eng69

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,836
3,995
113

And Neeli just got a raise.

we are MEDIOCRE!

Seems like PSU tends to suffer on ROI comparisons . I would guess debt is higher . . Not sure on the other metrics .

Interesting numbers from our "BOT Watch Dog" news letter
Thank you partner. 👀

Link:
1708349942280.png
 
Last edited:

Catch1lion

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,033
3,160
113
True, and that's a resounding number 1. No other institution is close, and it's so admirable.
We were not about to get out bid by UL .
_______
My purpose as Penn State’s president is leverage the transformative power of higher education to improve the lives of our students , their families, and communities (and my wallet)
—- DrNB
 

fairgambit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,765
5,797
113
Nobody cares about what College Football News has to say about a school’s academics. USNEWS is the only ranking people even remotely care about.
Perhaps, and if so, we are 11th in the current BigTen.
There was a time when I thought I was fortunate to be accepted by Penn State given my high school academics. Were I applying today I think they would be lucky to get me.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Nits74

Catch1lion

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,033
3,160
113
Hard to know the motivations, for sure. But 80% of the kids PSU offers admission to are choosing to go elsewhere, for some reason or another.
What's the trend in this department? Typically, I only see refenced the rate of acceptance by the college, but not the percentage accepted offers by the candidates that convert into enrollment. Do you know this rate at other B1G schools? TY.
 
Last edited:

Nits74

Well-known member
Oct 19, 2021
1,103
1,774
113
Perhaps, and if so, we are 11th in the current BigTen.
There was a time when I thought I was fortunate to be accepted by Penn State given my high school academics. Were I applying today I think they would be lucky to get me.
You probably would not have applied. The way things are now, I'm sorry to say that it's the school from which I graduated. The University has become a disgrace.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: fairgambit

LionJim

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
11,017
15,131
113
What's the trend in this department? Typically, I only see refenced the rate of acceptance by the college, but not the percentage accepted offers by the candidates that convert into enrollment. Do you know this rate at other B1G schools? TY.
One likely factor in the 80% is that with the Common Application kids are applying to more schools than they used to.
 

PSUFTG2

Well-known member
Jul 1, 2023
700
1,569
93
What's the trend in this department? Typically, I only see refenced the rate of acceptance by the college, but not the percentage accepted offers by the candidates that convert into enrollment. Do you know this rate at other B1G schools? TY.
I know PSU, as of last report, had the lowest yield in the conference. I'd have to check for exact numbers.
 

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
17,676
26,682
113
What's the trend in this department? Typically, I only see refenced the rate of acceptance by the college, but not the percentage accepted offers by the candidates that convert into enrollment. Do you know this rate at other B1G schools? TY.

PSU is always worse. Always.

😞
 

Catch1lion

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,033
3,160
113
One likely factor in the 80% is that with the Common Application kids are applying to more schools than they used to.
That's what I was trying ot account for in the question. College Board recommends applying to four to eight schools. My kids only applied to Schreyer. So I don't have much personal experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

Catch1lion

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,033
3,160
113
I know PSU, as of last report, had the lowest yield in the conference. I'd have to check for exact numbers.

I would guess the sticker shock sets in after the applicant gets the financial aid package from PSU.
 
Last edited:

PSUFTG2

Well-known member
Jul 1, 2023
700
1,569
93
One likely factor in the 80% is that with the Common Application kids are applying to more schools than they used to.
No doubt, just about every school sees lower yields since the common app (that's pretty much a mathematical certainty :) )
So it is important - if one wants any informative data - to look at numbers relative to others in the same time frame.
In that regard, PSU was/is lowest in the B10.
 

fairgambit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,765
5,797
113
You probably would not have applied. The way things are now, I'm sorry to say that it's the school from which I graduated. The University has become a disgrace.
Sadly, I must agree. Dear Old State has been trending down for years. I have memories of happier times, both before and after, graduation, but what keeps me on this board are the people here, not Penn State.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitt1300 and Nits74

LafayetteBear

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
647
792
93
I believe - strongly - that ranking Penn State at #66 of the 132 CFB schools that play D-1 football is a joke. Realistically, Penn State should slot in somewhere near 30th, at worst. And that's only because some quality private schools are in the mix in this ranking (e.g., Stanford, Duke, Notre Dame, Vanderbilt, Northwestern, USC). PSU was the No. 7 public university, academically, as recent as 2014. I simply don't accept that the school fell that far that fast. I'm honking the B.S. Horn on that one.
 

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
17,676
26,682
113
PSU used to get a pantload of applications compared to other schools. We often led the league in that department. Is that still the case?
 
Last edited:

PSUFTG2

Well-known member
Jul 1, 2023
700
1,569
93
PSU used to get a pantload of applications compared to other schools. We often lead the league in that department. Is that still the case?
I am not sure of exactly where it would fit in nationally, but the # of applications received by PSU is very high - and I think would be among the highest in the nation.
In any event, PSU has historically received a very high number of applications (as you point out), and still does receive a large number (even relative to other peer schools). What has changed is the ability to turn "application" into "enrollment".

Having the largest enrollment, largest alumni base, and - as is often cited - the largest population within 300 miles of campus of any university (or whatever figure gets cited) all work in favor of a lot of applications. Not requiring test scores is another (and I think PSU may have the lowest percentage of applicants submitting test scores of any in the Big Ten - though I couldn't say for 100% sure OTTOMH)
Of course, having a lot of applications from underqualified candidates, and/or a lot of applications from more qualified candidates (who opt not to enroll) doesn't really help much (which is a large part of the reason for PSU's precipitous decline in so many academic metrics and ratings).
 

CyphaPSU

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
880
1,414
93
It was not that long ago PSU would consistently enjoy very respectable rankings among public universities. The amount of research that comes out of the university in combination with a number of highly rated departments/programs used to make a big impact. Similarly, I was always told that a Penn State degree looked impressive to many employers. But this past decade has been a stead diet of disappointment in terms of these rankings. I assume some of it is definitely warranted but some of it also may be a product of a shift in ranking methodologies from what used to be. The disparity between PSU's rankings in the various publications is somewhat telling in regards to methodologies. In reality, is PSU less academically respected in society than all of the schools ranked ahead of it in this list? Highly doubtful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catch1lion

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
17,676
26,682
113
It was not that long ago PSU would consistently enjoy very respectable rankings among public universities. The amount of research that comes out of the university in combination with a number of highly rated departments/programs used to make a big impact. Similarly, I was always told that a Penn State degree looked impressive to many employers. But this past decade has been a stead diet of disappointment in terms of these rankings. I assume some of it is definitely warranted but some of it also may be a product of a shift in ranking methodologies from what used to be. The disparity between PSU's rankings in the various publications is somewhat telling in regards to methodologies. In reality, is PSU less academically respected in society than all of the schools ranked ahead of it in this list? Highly doubtful.

We Are…Expensive!
 

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
9,852
15,702
113
It was not that long ago PSU would consistently enjoy very respectable rankings among public universities. The amount of research that comes out of the university in combination with a number of highly rated departments/programs used to make a big impact. Similarly, I was always told that a Penn State degree looked impressive to many employers. But this past decade has been a stead diet of disappointment in terms of these rankings. I assume some of it is definitely warranted but some of it also may be a product of a shift in ranking methodologies from what used to be. The disparity between PSU's rankings in the various publications is somewhat telling in regards to methodologies. In reality, is PSU less academically respected in society than all of the schools ranked ahead of it in this list? Highly doubtful.

Used to read US News & World Report Rankings religiously and PSU used to sit anywhere from 35 - 45 in National Rankings. Well above OSU, Pitt, WVU, and other peer schools. I don't think the quality of education or 'product' at PSU is inferior now, but it's absolutely not a good value/ROI compared to other peer institutions. Honestly, the best thing PSU has going for it is downtown State College and while unfortunate, I think the Sandusky scandal still stings. I wouldn't send my kids there (too big, almost Wal-Mart-esque, leadership/spending is terrible, reputation is stale) but I did enjoy my time there and my kids love Penn State athletics.
 

Catch1lion

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,033
3,160
113
Cut the fat and downsize. Hard to be elite when you have such a ginormous enrollment.

RankNameClassificationLocationEnrollment
U.S. Department of Education Fall 2020 Enrollment[2]
1Western Governors UniversityPrivateOnline147,866
2Southern New Hampshire UniversityPrivate, Non-profitNew Hampshire134,345
3Grand Canyon UniversityPrivate, For-profitArizona103,427
4Liberty UniversityPrivateVirginia93,349
5The Pennsylvania State UniversityPublicPennsylvania89,816
6University of Phoenix-ArizonaPrivate, For-profitArizona89,763
7Arizona State University Campus ImmersionPublic research universityArizona74,795
8Dallas CollegeTBCTexas74,781
9University of Central FloridaPublicFlorida71,881
10Texas A & M University-College StationPublicTexas70,418
 

CyphaPSU

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
880
1,414
93
Cut the fat and downsize. Hard to be elite when you have such a ginormous enrollment.

U.S. Department of Education Fall 2020 Enrollment[2]
RankNameClassificationLocationEnrollment
1Western Governors UniversityPrivateOnline147,866
2Southern New Hampshire UniversityPrivate, Non-profitNew Hampshire134,345
3Grand Canyon UniversityPrivate, For-profitArizona103,427
4Liberty UniversityPrivateVirginia93,349
5The Pennsylvania State UniversityPublicPennsylvania89,816
6University of Phoenix-ArizonaPrivate, For-profitArizona89,763
7Arizona State University Campus ImmersionPublic research universityArizona74,795
8Dallas CollegeTBCTexas74,781
9University of Central FloridaPublicFlorida71,881
10Texas A & M University-College StationPublicTexas70,418
Well, a good part of that right there is a product of a large online-only student population (something like 15,000). PSU was one of the first public universities to go big on its world campus. Look at many of the names on that list and they have done the same.
 

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
17,676
26,682
113
Cut the fat and downsize. Hard to be elite when you have such a ginormous enrollment.

U.S. Department of Education Fall 2020 Enrollment[2]
RankNameClassificationLocationEnrollment
1Western Governors UniversityPrivateOnline147,866
2Southern New Hampshire UniversityPrivate, Non-profitNew Hampshire134,345
3Grand Canyon UniversityPrivate, For-profitArizona103,427
4Liberty UniversityPrivateVirginia93,349
5The Pennsylvania State UniversityPublicPennsylvania89,816
6University of Phoenix-ArizonaPrivate, For-profitArizona89,763
7Arizona State University Campus ImmersionPublic research universityArizona74,795
8Dallas CollegeTBCTexas74,781
9University of Central FloridaPublicFlorida71,881
10Texas A & M University-College StationPublicTexas70,418

What the hell is Dallas College?

Anyway, we can’t rest until we’re bigger than WGU.
 
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login