Yay or Nay....1978 was the best year in music....

Colt2169

Well-known member
Dec 13, 2021
639
750
93
What? I see no mention of KISS - the Hottest 🥵 Band in the World in the 70s and the band that literally spawned the entire decade of the 80s music 🎶 wise !

Personally I like 70s and 80s about equal- 60s has some good stuff as did the 90s but both behind 70s/80s for sure.

Like someone else said everything since 2000 has been “Meh”.
 

EricStratton-RushChairman

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
1,526
3,840
113
Although it was released very late in 1977, "Never Mind the Bollocks, Here's the Sex Pistols" was one of the most impactful albums in 1978. Their U.S. tour in early 1978 (only 7 shows) was covered by mainstream media as the beginning of the end of civilization.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: LionJim

ODShowtime

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
2,672
5,456
113
What? I see no mention of KISS - the Hottest 🥵 Band in the World in the 70s and the band that literally spawned the entire decade of the 80s music 🎶 wise !

Personally I like 70s and 80s about equal- 60s has some good stuff as did the 90s but both behind 70s/80s for sure.

Like someone else said everything since 2000 has been “Meh”.

Awe man, I forgot about Alive II. Another towering live album from '78. Except side 4 which is kinda doody.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSU2169

STPGopherfan

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2021
625
909
93
Questlove, from The Roots, is a great source of music history. He thought the 80's were the best, musically,
This is what he said about the '80'
>>This decade was the best for both pop and metal. This decade was ruled by the pop king, and the best pop musician Michael Jackson. As well as by Madonna and Prince. But these are only the most famous artists of this decade. If we dig deeper, we'll see synthpop ( the best pop subgenre along with indie-pop, art-pop and dance-pop). Magical sounds. If we speak about rock, I consider it the best decade for metal. NWOBHM bands were pretty cool both lyrically and musically, it was really new for rock, and very different from traditional hard-rock. It also spawned Metallica the most popular metal band, and probably my favourite one, as well as spawning thrash metal to a full potential, although proto-thrash songs like Stone cold crazy by Queen were released in 70s. There is much more to say about 80s music, but I think these explanations would be enough.

I think there's one reason why I like the 80s musicwise. It's all those hidden gems that were forgotten by the sands of time and then dug back up again by hardcore popular music enthusiasts. Many artists like Kim Wilde, Animotion, Level 42, Spandau Ballet and the like are some great hidden gem artists from the 80s. However, I am more intrigued by the more popular artists of the time. It's no wonder these music artists were mostly forgotten, that's mostly because of people that chose to ignore all those underrated musicians and go with something else instead. But that's just my opinion. In the end, the 80s had so many underrated songs and musicians that were almost completely overshadowed by the more popular artists of the time.<<

His thoughts on the "70's
>>
Absolutely fantastic Decade for music. You have such a broad list of different musical genres. It was such transformative decade for music. I would say that the only time period to have such diverse music would only be the early eighties. Rock split into many new genres from popular progressive rock to the far reaching enthusiasm of classic and hard rock. Furthermore, though disco gets a lot of hate due to its repetitive nature, disco music not only kick-started the now disturbingly simplistic electronic and rap music industry, it was one of the most inclusive genre of music since Jazz. Many people honestly forget this decade due to its lack of music videos which the eighties had. It had True music you could dance to. It really was spectacular. Does that mean I would want to live in those times, maybe not. But I pray more artists pay tribute to this decade of music, as did Daft Punk and some others...

Honestly, I like 70s music more than 80s music. Even if Classic-jack radio stations are slowly letting them go now, they're the most timeless songs that I've listened to. Music through the 70s really progressed and grew into a bigger inspiration among many throughout what came, and even for what's there to come. The Eagles, Steve Miller, Queen, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, the Cars, Elton John, Boston, Isley Brothers, Bob Marley, Fleetwood Mac, Aerosmith, Commoders, and so many more influential artists became famous since the 1970s. Even if the decade had an unfortunate beginning with the Beatles splitting up in 1970, it really shows that music shows growth from inspiration, and the best of what we can all enjoy.

70s was best. I listed all the best songs I ever heard and grouped them by decade of release. 70s was by far the best. 80s and 60s were next. I think many people who say the 80s don't realize most of those great 80s songs were released in the 70s.
And it doesn't matter what year the band started. I think it should be the year the songs were released when you categorize music by year or decade. For example, Led Zeppelin started in 60s but most of their songs/great songs were release in 70s, so I thing they contributed more to the decade of the 70s. Same with a lot of other great bands.

Pink Floyd Dark side of the moon, Led Zeppelin's physical graffiti, Queen's a night at the Opera, John Lennon's imagine. Deep Purple's machine head, Meat Loaf's bat out of hell, Clash's London Calling, Black Sabbath's paranoid, Joy Division's unknown pleasures, never mind the bollocks here's the sex pistols, the who's who's next, Elton John's goodbye yellow brick road, rolling stone's sticky fingers, Bob Dylan's blood on the tracks, eagles hotel California, Rush's 2112, ramones' rocket to Russia, AC⚡DC's highway to hell, wire's Pink flag, beatles' let it be, Fleetwood Mac's rumours, Blondie's parallel lines, Saturday night fever, and so much more.<<
Music has such a vast/ deep universe. 70's to 80's also saw shifts in Jazz/ Jazz fushion in addition to the "birth" of house music as well. Also many spin-offs from people like Frank Zappa (George Duke). I look at your amazing list, and even that isn't complete. What list could be? You have to stop somewhere. Earth, Wind, and Fire jumped out at me. I am sure there are many others.

Great discussion.
 

Tgar

Well-known member
Oct 13, 2021
4,827
10,815
113
I didn't "miss" anything...I provided a list and asked for others to chime in.

Perhaps you should do less drugs.

Youtube Look GIF by Rosanna Pansino

Perhaps. My apologies. Thanks for getting the conversation started.
 

Ludd

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,650
2,160
113
Everybody’s musical tastes are different and your choice of decade all depends on your preferences. However, the 80’s offered a much greater variety of genres than any other decade and brought a lot of different genres into the mainstream, so for that, I say the 80’s was the best decade for music…but I also like a lot of music from the 60’s and 70’s.
 

NewEra 2014

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
487
852
93
I think if you look at the pop culture influence of music, it probably peaked at some time between 1976 and 1984. So if you pick a year during that timeframe, 1978 is not a bad year to choose as the peak. I was only 13-14 years old at the time, but I have a great appreciation for the music of 1978. But personally, my pop culture peak was probably 1984-86.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob78 and bbrown

[email protected]

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
529
636
93
Might go with 1969

my favorite Beatles, Stones, and zep albums

abbey road
Let it bleed
Led zep II

also stand by sly
Everybody knows this is nowhere
The band, the band
Dylan Nashville skyline
In the court of the crimson king
Tommy
Velvet underground
Space oddity
CSN,csn
Credence bayou country
Led zep (I)
Blind faith,blind faith
Cash-at San Quentin
Allman bros-the allman bros
Jefferson airplane volunteers
Dusty in memphis
Hot buttered soul
 

ODShowtime

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
2,672
5,456
113
Might go with 1969

my favorite Beatles, Stones, and zep albums

abbey road
Let it bleed
Led zep II

also stand by sly
Everybody knows this is nowhere
The band, the band
Dylan Nashville skyline
In the court of the crimson king
Tommy
Velvet underground
Space oddity
CSN,csn
Credence bayou country
Led zep (I)
Blind faith,blind faith
Cash-at San Quentin
Allman bros-the allman bros
Jefferson airplane volunteers
Dusty in memphis
Hot buttered soul

Great list 1969 is another TOWERING year. The live performances to go along with all those albums...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob78

Meat Lab

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
347
571
93
Albums released

The Who - Who Are You
The Rolling Stones - Some Girls
Van Halen - Van Halen I
The Cars - The Cars
The Police - Outlandos d'Amour
Dire Straits- Dire Straits
Bruce Springsteen - Darkness on the Edge of Town
Bill Joel - 52nd Street
Elvis Costello and The Attractions - This Year's Model
Rush - Hemispheres
Genesis - ....and then there were three.....
Funkadelic - One Nation Under Groove
Warren Zevon - Excitable Boy


Wot Say You?
Not bad but there was something special about 1969:
(Edit: Sorry Ro, didn’t see your earlier comments on69)

Beatles -Abbey Road
The Who - Tommy
Led Zeppelin- I
Led Zeppelin- II
Rolling Stones - Let it Bleed
CSN - Crosby, Stills & Nash
The Band - The Band
Credence Clearwater - Green River
King Crimson - In the Court of the Crimson King
 

Nitwit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,481
2,224
113
You guys have too much free time. Who’s even heard of half of these bands?
 

Bob78

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,431
3,208
113
As with any "the best of the best" for me, I am not prone to selecting one single person or team or band or here, year, as an absolute. I enjoy the discussions immensely. (And today being my bday, a terrific start to the day!).
But, for me, I tend to lump the 4 or 5 year span of 1969 thru 1963 as my personal fave, by far, of the classic rock era. Even a good portion of pop music from that time was and is really good stuff.

But as said, great music is in the ear of the beerholder, so I appreciate the thoughtful reasoning offered here, even if (wrongly) not in agreement with me!
Lots of great music to go around.

Classic Rock on Sirius XM 26 is my go to, besides my aging but still beloved iPod!
 

NewEra 2014

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
487
852
93
As with any "the best of the best" for me, I am not prone to selecting one single person or team or band or here, year, as an absolute. I enjoy the discussions immensely. (And today being my bday, a terrific start to the day!).

Classic Rock on Sirius XM 26 is my go to, besides my aging but still beloved iPod!
Happy Birthday!

I enjoy the Deep Tracks channel on SXM. We have all heard the big hits from classic artists hundreds of times. That channel plays some great rarities from those artists, and the DJs seem to love their work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob78

ODShowtime

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
2,672
5,456
113
Embarrassed I forget to mention another killer live album; Aerosmith Live Bootleg.

I think a case could possibly be made that 1978 was the best year for live albums. A case could be made...

Pfunk Eath Tour might have been 78 as well but that album is weird.

And Zappa in New York which is awesome.
 

razpsu

Well-known member
Oct 19, 2021
8,091
10,330
113
As with any "the best of the best" for me, I am not prone to selecting one single person or team or band or here, year, as an absolute. I enjoy the discussions immensely. (And today being my bday, a terrific start to the day!).
But, for me, I tend to lump the 4 or 5 year span of 1969 thru 1963 as my personal fave, by far, of the classic rock era. Even a good portion of pop music from that time was and is really good stuff.

But as said, great music is in the ear of the beerholder, so I appreciate the thoughtful reasoning offered here, even if (wrongly) not in agreement with me!
Lots of great music to go around.

Classic Rock on Sirius XM 26 is my go to, besides my aging but still beloved iPod!
I was going to lump years as well as they really defined each decade but I was trying to stay within the rules. 🤣
64-66
77-79
82-84
90-92
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bob78

psuro

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
7,994
17,418
113
As with any "the best of the best" for me, I am not prone to selecting one single person or team or band or here, year, as an absolute. I enjoy the discussions immensely. (And today being my bday, a terrific start to the day!).
But, for me, I tend to lump the 4 or 5 year span of 1969 thru 1963 as my personal fave, by far, of the classic rock era. Even a good portion of pop music from that time was and is really good stuff.

But as said, great music is in the ear of the beerholder, so I appreciate the thoughtful reasoning offered here, even if (wrongly) not in agreement with me!
Lots of great music to go around.

Classic Rock on Sirius XM 26 is my go to, besides my aging but still beloved iPod!
Happy Birthday Snl GIF
 
  • Love
Reactions: Bob78
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login