your two favorite all time players, offense and defense?
- Thread starter Nitt1300
- Start date
Defense: Dennis Onkotz
Offense: Saquon Barkley
Offense: Saquon Barkley
Onkotz may have been the best LB we've ever had. Jack is my favorite both for his playing and for being a genuinely nice guy
Dennis was ineligible to play as a freshman, made 2nd team All American as a Sophomore, and Consensus 1st team as a Junior and Senior.
Offense - The Backup QB
Defense - The stud defensive recruit.
Defense - The stud defensive recruit.
For defense, I'll probably say Jack Ham
For offense, just can't skip on the only PSU player I personally know, Gary Klingensmith. But coming in close 2nd is John Urschel because he is a mathematician like @LionJim and me.
For offense, just can't skip on the only PSU player I personally know, Gary Klingensmith. But coming in close 2nd is John Urschel because he is a mathematician like @LionJim and me.
After nearly 60 years of "do or die Penn State Football," narrowing the field to only 2 is almost impossible for me. But I'm a team player ... so
Offense: Ki-Jana Carter
Defense: Mike Reid
Offense: Ki-Jana Carter
Defense: Mike Reid
and for dominant duo (offense): Sean Farrell and Mike Munchak
Bobby Engram is near and dear to me. Watched him haul in two bombs right in front of me at MSU in 93 for a huge comeback win then we watched him catch the game winner at UM a year later.
Defense? #11.
Defense? #11.
I think we’re supposed to vote for OSUs tiramisu (who cares how you spell it) based upon the other bucknut thread wanting us to claim him the greatest of all time. 
Whoever said it above I agree with. It’s way too hard to pick only one on each side of the ball.
If forced to pick:
Curt Warner
Shane Conlan.
I was just too young to be able to watch Reid or Ham live but they are certainly worthy. Same with Onkotz.
Whoever said it above I agree with. It’s way too hard to pick only one on each side of the ball.
If forced to pick:
Curt Warner
Shane Conlan.
I was just too young to be able to watch Reid or Ham live but they are certainly worthy. Same with Onkotz.
Only because I am forced to limit to two:
O - Daryll Clark
D - Courtney Brown
O - Daryll Clark
D - Courtney Brown
Mike Robinson was a hell of a leader, none better.
He Led by example and played where the team needed him. He loved JoePa too. That was evident. I always thought JoePa should’ve rode off into the sunset after that Orange Bowl win. It was so special.
I remember a noteworthy Aaron Harris Appreciation Thread way way back when we had Thread View. It went on for pages, all of which Marsh CE printed out to give to AH’s parents, who he would see at church. Cool story, tbh.
Last edited:
That’s fantastic. One of those kids that if they would have never been injured they would have had a very nice pro career
I can't. It's asking me who is my favorite child. I just won't do it.
Yeah, a great person too, great teammate. He had a Courtney Brown-type mindset, if that makes any sense.
Mike Reid and Franco Harris - both in part for what they did off the field after football, but they were among our greatest players as well.
Get unlimited access today.