There were a lot of State fans that were skeptical about Lemonis. A ton of Indiana fans felt he was a good recruiter and decent game day coach. But they said he really struggled to develop talent.
Did Lemonis bring us the Natty finally? Yes.
Are we seeing exactly what Indiana described as his deficiencies? Yes.
It was considered very underwhelming at the time, considering we could’ve had other similar coaches at the time that were and have been considered better than Lemonis.
Now none of that negates that fact that he did a fantastic job navigating the program the first 4 years with fairly established guys.
What changed? Seems we started recruiting a different type of player than we were. These guys don’t seemingly have a ton of grit about them. When they fail they freak out.
This also doesn’t explain a seemingly lack of development of the players outside of a few. Kellum Clark is virtually the same guy he was 3 years ago.
I mean something certainly changed around middle of last year. Big time. But for the first 3.5 years, recruiting, coaching, development, and culture were all happening at the same clip as they always did for every successful stretch of MSU baseball.
Recruiting - Lemonis staff brought in Bednar, Harding, Preston Johnson, Stone Simmons, and Scotty Dubrule who were all critical pieces of the natty team. RJ Yeager and Colton Ledbetter were great portal finds on these teams that of course aren’t so great.
Coaching - I mean, any critical blunders in the first 3 years anywhere?
Development - TA, Foscue, Westburg, Rowdey, Landon Sims, Kam James, and many others from the first few seasons all got better every year. Most of those only played significantly under the Lemonis staff. Even last year, RJ Yeager came in and put up significantly better numbers against SEC competition than he did against the teams in whatever the hell conference Mercer is in.
Culture - we won the national title in Year 3, after losing 2 MLB first round picks and a 2nd round pick who got 1st round money. That means we had great culture sustained for at least 3 seasons. That doesn’t happen by accident. Had he won it in Year 1 maybe you could argue we had culture issues the whole time. Not the case. The staff has obviously lost the team now and aren’t getting them back, so its fair to say this has been the biggest area of deterioration in years 4 and 5.
We all know what has to happen. This sucks. But the tenure was still generally great for MSU for obvious reasons.