For the Golfers on the Board what are your thoughts of the LIV business model vs the PGA Business model?

Nohow

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
1,189
950
113
As far as I know, PGA Tour provides benefits, such as a pension plan and health insurance. The players are independent contractors up to a point - they can pick and choose the events they want to play on the tour but they have to maintain a certain level of performance or they lose their playing privileges.

Just a quick look-see. In 2021, the 150th ranked player in the official money stats was a guy named Vaughn Taylor. He made $649,000 over 30 events. Assume $10k per event in costs, which might be low, his profit was almost $350K. He probably had some additional revenue from clubs/balls/clothes plus he probably does corporate outings when not playing a tour event.

So the average guy does OK, but it's a grind, trying to keep your game sharp, the travel, away from family. It can be a tough road. Guys below 150, for the most part, simply aren't making it and they lose their playing privileges. Those are the guys who need to look for different employment.

The LIV tour has so much money behind it, it is too compelling to pass up, particularly for the guys who are on the downside of their careers, because it's damn hard to make it as a PGA tour player.
In other words, GREED. Poor guy trying to get by on $350k.
 

Nitt1300

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
5,015
9,486
113
Seriously? How many has the LIV tour killed? If you are talking innocent deaths the Americans have bumped off a view. Now I am not comparing the Saudi’s to us but you can’t blame a f’kn golf tour. Of course you men of principal have no Chinese products right?
sure sounds like you are comparing the Saudis to us
 

Tin man

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2021
1,862
2,369
113
Those that signed for the large bonus are pretty much on the backside of their careers. Phil probably was not going to win again in the PGA, even in this LIV field he was somewhere around 15 in the standings. So yeah, it’s all about the money that he will never see in the PGA.
 

MacNit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,231
1,222
113
So these players are only playing in a max of 12 tournaments per year (the 8 LIV plus the 4 majors if they even qualify)?

If the Saudi Gov't wasn't sponsoring this there would be no way that would be sustainable. Sponsors and TV contracts would never be able to recoup the money because there just wouldn't be enough coming in through the advertising revenue, no? Feels like a PPV service would be the only way this could work without Saudi involvement, and I don't see enough people wanting to invest in that with how poor the roster is at this time.

This is solely about the money, and I feel like it detracts from the product in general since there is no greater goal these players are playing for other than making the most money (which I could care less about).
Golf is all about the majors anyhow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roswelllion

Nitwit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,481
2,223
113
Schwartzel’s caddy got paid $475,000 for the first event, and the tour paid him - not out of the player’s earnings. He hit the mother load.
 

Tin man

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2021
1,862
2,369
113
Curious to see if they still get endorsements and commercials from golf equipment manufacturers
 

Tin man

Well-known member
Oct 29, 2021
1,862
2,369
113
Golf is all about the majors anyhow.
Yeah, but they may run out of eligibility for the majors since they are not earning any points towards them. Some are invitation only so they are conditional on being picked and since they aren’t on PGA tour they may not get invited.
 

91Joe95

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
2,843
4,067
113
I know of a pretty prominent person about to visit Saudi Arabia to schmooze. Interesting times we live in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roswelllion

Pennst8

Active member
Oct 25, 2021
351
388
63
The same as it would be if any other hate filled group bankrolled a golf league
 

Roswelllion

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
672
950
93
LIV is bankrolled by the Saudi PIF. If you have to think about the question for more than two seconds, you're spending too much time.
You don’t support the NBA? You are against the Champions League Soccer? Pleas be consistent.
 

Roswelllion

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
672
950
93
Reminds me of the old story, attributed to numerous people including WC Fields and Groucho Marx and others:

He: Miss, would you sleep with me for $100,000?
She: Well, yes, I suppose I would.
He: Would you sleep with me for $5?
She: Certainly not! What kind of lady do you think I am?
He: We've already established that, now we're just haggling over the price.

Would they play on the Saudi tour for a mere $1mm? Certainly not!
So ask yourselves this. If you are still working would you work for a Saudi or Chinese company if the business had 0 to do with politics. Maybe a hotel chain or a cruise line AND they offered you 50 times your current salary just to sign up and then a salary that is double what you earn today. If your answer is no way they have corrupt governments feel free to be against the LIV. If not check your comments on the hypocrisy meter. This what they do for a living not just to entertain us
 

Roswelllion

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
672
950
93
DJ is probably worth well over 100 million already with his endorsements. How much more does he really need? I wonder if Wayne Gretsky advised him on the situation before he made his decision.
What is the okay amount to be worth that would allow you guys to be okay with it?
 

Nohow

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
1,189
950
113
So ask yourselves this. If you are still working would you work for a Saudi or Chinese company if the business had 0 to do with politics. Maybe a hotel chain or a cruise line AND they offered you 50 times your current salary just to sign up and then a salary that is double what you earn today. If your answer is no way they have corrupt governments feel free to be against the LIV. If not check your comments on the hypocrisy meter. This what they do for a living not just to entertain us
False analogy. There is a tiny difference: The Saudis are doing it just to distract people like you from their record on human rights. It is political. The event is very high profile to achieve this distraction. It’s global pr for the Saudi rulers. So I would not assist them in that distraction.
Would you work for Hitler or Mao to polish his image?
 

NittPicker

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
4,202
8,536
113
You don’t support the NBA? You are against the Champions League Soccer? Pleas be consistent.
That's dumb. The NBA and the Champions League aren't being propped up my a multi-billion dollar government investment fund. I personally don't care where anyone plays golf. More power to those guys if they want to cash big checks. But for them to talk in circles and act oblivious is ridiculous. I wouldn't doubt if their contracts prohibit them from criticizing the Saudi government. Oil money can buy a lot of things, including silence.
 

Auxgym

Active member
Oct 13, 2021
397
469
63
Not a golfer but I expect this to alter the PGA the way the NCAA is being altered.

Shalom
Business model? LIV Tour? Doesn't a business actually have to generate enough income to begin offsetting expenses to be considered as such? I'm thinking the LIV Tour is more like one giant loss leader for other enterprises.......
 

NittanyBuff

Well-known member
Oct 30, 2021
792
827
93
I've got no problem with these guys, they are independent contractors, no clue about the business model. I think the PGA has been much like the NCAA for yrs and now they don't particularly like having to spend and spread more $ around. I'll more than likely catch some of both.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roswelllion

Roswelllion

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
672
950
93
False analogy. There is a tiny difference: The Saudis are doing it just to distract people like you from their record on human rights. It is political. The event is very high profile to achieve this distraction. It’s global pr for the Saudi rulers. So I would not assist them in that distraction.
Would you work for Hitler or Mao to polish his image?
Are you serious? I simply can not imagine anyone's opinion of Saudi Arabia changes because of a golf tour. How many of the bombers from 9/11 were from SA? And for 20 years since then we have kissed their ***. You guys should focus your energy on why our President will be on his hands and knees with lips puckered begging for oil rather than a golf league that is going to make a bunch of rich guys richer. The hypocrisy is unbelievable. Brooks K is bad because someone wants to pay him millions to play golf but because we want cheaper gas or cheap clothes from China we look the other way.
BTW what does LIV stand for? yea me neither, If folks weren't screeching about this who would know it is a Saudi backed league. How is that good PR?
So they are paying absolutely stupid money. Joe 6 pack says that is because the f'n price of oil is $120. How is that good PR?
 

Erial_Lion

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
2,151
2,632
113
I've got no problem with these guys, they are independent contractors, no clue about the business model. I think the PGA has been much like the NCAA for yrs and now they don't particularly like having to spend and spread more $ around. I'll more than likely catch some of both.
The biggest gain in “not spending” is for the charities that benefit from the PGA events (over 3 billion dollars worth to date).
 

dcf4psu

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
768
950
93
This weekend I'm more intrigued with the first LIV tournament in the states then I am with the John Deere Classic. So I'll be watching LIV on YouTube.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roswelllion

Frank3

Member
Oct 15, 2021
39
52
18
Interesting that if the Saudis did this to distract from human rights issues - it seems to have done the opposite since it brought their record back into the media and the public consciousness. Was not really thinking about it until the LIV Tour was in the news.
 

Nohow

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
1,189
950
113
Are you serious? I simply can not imagine anyone's opinion of Saudi Arabia changes because of a golf tour. How many of the bombers from 9/11 were from SA? And for 20 years since then we have kissed their ***. You guys should focus your energy on why our President will be on his hands and knees with lips puckered begging for oil rather than a golf league that is going to make a bunch of rich guys richer. The hypocrisy is unbelievable. Brooks K is bad because someone wants to pay him millions to play golf but because we want cheaper gas or cheap clothes from China we look the other way.
BTW what does LIV stand for? yea me neither, If folks weren't screeching about this who would know it is a Saudi backed league. How is that good PR?
So they are paying absolutely stupid money. Joe 6 pack says that is because the f'n price of oil is $120. How is that good PR?
You are dense. No one gets to choose where their gas comes from. And everybody knows what liv is - a SA pr move to lend a murdering monarchy legitimacy, even you, hypocrite/philistine. It’s already working judging by your comments.
 
Last edited:

Roswelllion

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
672
950
93
You are dense. No one gets to choose where their gas comes from. And everybody knows what liv is - a SA pr move to lend a murdering monarchy legitimacy, even you, hypocrite/philistine. It’s already working judging by your comments.
"nobody gets to choose where their gas from"
. well as a country that isn't entirely true
. as an individual how many cars and what kind of cars do you drive
ask ten people tomorrow what LIV is and what does it stand for. - then get back to me on the successful PR effort
 

Nohow

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
1,189
950
113
"nobody gets to choose where their gas from"
. well as a country that isn't entirely true
. as an individual how many cars and what kind of cars do you drive
ask ten people tomorrow what LIV is and what does it stand for. - then get back to me on the successful PR effort
You were speaking about people looking the other way while buying gas. Nobody buys gas “as a country”.
When they hold the tournament in SA, they will know what LIV means.
 

CDLionFL

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
1,542
2,315
113
.
BTW what does LIV stand for? yea me neither, If folks weren't screeching about this who would know it is a Saudi backed league. How is that good PR?
So they are paying absolutely stupid money. Joe 6 pack says that is because the f'n price of oil is $120. How is that good PR?
LIV - 54 in Roman numerals...the amount of holes they play each tourney. I don't know what the Arabic word for 'shotgun start' is.
 

PSUHarry

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
888
945
93
Are you serious? I simply can not imagine anyone's opinion of Saudi Arabia changes because of a golf tour. How many of the bombers from 9/11 were from SA? And for 20 years since then we have kissed their ***. You guys should focus your energy on why our President will be on his hands and knees with lips puckered begging for oil rather than a golf league that is going to make a bunch of rich guys richer. The hypocrisy is unbelievable. Brooks K is bad because someone wants to pay him millions to play golf but because we want cheaper gas or cheap clothes from China we look the other way.
BTW what does LIV stand for? yea me neither, If folks weren't screeching about this who would know it is a Saudi backed league. How is that good PR?
So they are paying absolutely stupid money. Joe 6 pack says that is because the f'n price of oil is $120. How is that good PR?
So more wrongs make a right?
 
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login