Ha! It's all written in the house rules and the house has the right to change those rules at any time.
Official '24 PSU - USC game thread
- Thread starter Tom McAndrew
- Start date
I think I'm most happy for CJF... Sometimes he drives me nuts but I'm glad we have him.
For sure. But that’s how it goes. Players deserve criticism when they fail to perform, and they deserve praise when they come up big. They would have been justified in benching him and busting him down the depth chart, but hopefully, this will be the start of a turnaround for him, personally, on the season.
A player has a bad half and deserves to get benched? Thank God you aren't a coach.
No, by all means, you definitely keep throwing ineffective players out there. Especially the ones that were non-factors through the first 5 games. People who subscribe to the “put the best 11 players on the field” philosophy are clearly idiots.
Using your logic, Sahaydak would still be our kicker. Let’s see you reason your way outta’ that one.
Last edited:
The PSU Roar was the Best!
SIAP,
Why does anyone listen to or acknowledge clowns like this? Merely a talking head.
One of the things that stuck with me yesterday was the decision making by Coach in taking points. I think it’s even more difficult to do that when you have an X factor with a kid having the game Warren did yesterday. I think there is a disposition to just thinking the kid will make a play somewhere and just get him the ball and let him do something.
I’m too old to go by a printout saying to do X when it’s Y situation. Too many times I’ve seen bad decisions. I’m old school, heck I’m getting closer to where there was no school but a lot of times you spend the rest of the game chasing points. I think we saw some moments yesterday when I saw some real reason and less panic. The first FG I thought he might go for it to have a splash moment. I think taking the points was more him saying we are going to be around the goal line a lot more today. The second FG deep in USC territory could have been a moment when you panic trying to get to 17-10 instead of being 17-6. I think that was the right move as well.
They punted one time as well when I thought he might go for it.
If the Nits had lost I’d still be saying the same.
I’m too old to go by a printout saying to do X when it’s Y situation. Too many times I’ve seen bad decisions. I’m old school, heck I’m getting closer to where there was no school but a lot of times you spend the rest of the game chasing points. I think we saw some moments yesterday when I saw some real reason and less panic. The first FG I thought he might go for it to have a splash moment. I think taking the points was more him saying we are going to be around the goal line a lot more today. The second FG deep in USC territory could have been a moment when you panic trying to get to 17-10 instead of being 17-6. I think that was the right move as well.
They punted one time as well when I thought he might go for it.
If the Nits had lost I’d still be saying the same.
I was shocked, as well others I know who were watching the game, that CJF actually made good in game decisions and no signature bonehead ones that he typically is apt to do. On the 4th down and short at midfield without the game on the line at the time , it appeared that he was faking going for it and trying to draw USC offsides. Unfortunately, bonehead PSU OL jumped offsides. No big deal because it gave Penn State more room to punt.
As a Southern alum i have former teammates still living in the Catawissa area. They all tell me Julian is a good kid. Let's be happy for him. Most of us knew he wasn't a #1....in spite of resident coaches who insisted that OSU'S #4 would automatically be #1 here. He's solidified the culture in the WR room and can be clutch. A good teammate.
sure but from the part of the game I saw we didn't catch any more breaks than USC
Woke up this morning and still reveling in the come from behind victory! Man what a game!
You are a complete f…ing moron!KOTELNICKI saved our offense!
I’d fire him on the TARMAC!!!!!!!!!!!!
HE SUCKS!!!!!!
Anyone else find the endless drone shots from above the Coliseum a bit annoying?
YES!!! It's one thing to use them when you come back from commercial. But they were using every camera angle imaginable to the point that they'd cut back to the actual "normal" angle right as the ball was being snapped, so you couldn't even see who was on the field, what was happening with the formation, etc. Always annoys me.
Do you, or did the win suck all of the joy out of your life?
Just my 2 cents on the coaches and rest of the season. PSU outscored USC 27-10 after halftime. While we all would much rather see them start the game with guns blazing, that is some pretty impressive halftime coaching and adjustments. Yesterday, the opening drive of the game for PSU was a masterpiece of playcalling and execution that was negated by a questionable penalty on Fleming that negated the TD. If PSU scores that TD, the flow of the game may have been different. The PSU defense allowed their first points in the third quarter yesterday. They have only allowed 3 points total in the third quarter through six games. While the Allen defense frustrates me at times, that is pretty impressive. Also, Allar grew up before our eyes yesterday. Great to see him rise to the occasion. This team has some grit. I like it. Coach K has been fantastic. Chunk plays are coming in bursts and they are coming at great times in the game. The OL is much better overall. Credit to Trautwein. I love the timing of the bye week. This team needs an extra week to recover mentally and physically. The end of the season will not be easy. Wisconsin and Minny on the road will be challenging. OSU and Washington will be tough at home. Rutgers and MD will be massive underdogs on paper, but they both make PSU their Super Bowl every year. Things are looking up for PSU, but there is a lot of work still to be done.
I thought the same. They especially liked panning across the east facade and showing a ground level shot with the southwest field entrance in the background. But I get it though. The Coliseum is a historic venue with a lot of unique qualities. Apparently the network wanted to showcase that.
They should have used the drones to showcase the USC cheerleaders! They are smoking!
Had almost zero issues with play calling and decision making yesterday (usually the case when we win
. I still don’t like Allar out as WR but they’ve been setting they up for five games and the payoff was today. Franklin deserves a lot of credit for having the team ready and playing a great game and making gutsy calls when he had to. I said it at the beginning of the season but he needs a raise (and will probably get it - soon).I’m happy they won yesterday. I give the coaches and players credit for hanging tough after being down big early.
But don’t mistake criticism for not being a fan. I want them to win a title as much as anyone. I’m a 5th-gen PSU grad and football has been a huge part of my family and life.
The criticism of this coaching staff is justified. They trailed almost the entire game after going down big early. Poor starts on the road are a chronic problem and while it was great that they gutted out a win yesterday, slow starts typically get them beat a couple of times each season.
11 years in, there is enough data to see these as long term problems that haven’t been fixed. The players have turned over. The coordinators and asst coaches too. What else gives?
Yes. And when he gets his lines sorted, USC will be poised for big things. If they give him that long…
USC should win out and then their season hangs on the ND game. They’re close - the offense is already very good to elite and recruiting has improved a ton. Riley needs two more years IMO but he’s on the right track. Minnesota loss hurt a ton.
Thing he has going for him is he will get a five star QB each and every recruiting cycle. That will keep you employed IMO.
In the past 11 years, 7 coaches have won national championships. So does that mean that Franklin and the other 100+ coaches that haven't won are terrible and should all be fired?
There was so much criticism of Harbaugh with fans and media calling for him to be fired and then he won last year and the entire narrative changed. So would your opinion of Franklin change if he was to win one? Paterno one 2 in 46 years, and it took 17 for him to win his first. I guess he should have been let go long before 1982.
I don't have any problem with some legitimate criticism. My issues with a lot of people on this board are the ridiculous expectations, their knee jerk (over) reactions to practically every play, and their inability to appreciate the fact that we have a good football team that has been better than most other teams in the country for a long time.
Hopefully, we are seeing the solution to our kicking problem taking his first big steps. Unfortunately, problems with the kicking game have not been unheard of within our program in recent memory. What I appreciate about this situation, however, is how the guy who will potentially stabilize the kicking game has multiple years of eligibility left, which hasn’t always been the case in times past.
Using your logic every great player who had a slump would be benched. And psu very well may have lost that game yesterday if you were coach.
This has been his Achilles heel his entire career. His defense usually is an afterthought to the offense. You saw it at Oklahoma and last year at SC. Now, they have an improved defense, but games are won and lost in the trenches. I listen to recruiting guys and they addressed the uphill battle that USC faces recruiting top DL players on the west coast. According to the recruiting experts, there is a big lack of talented DL players currently on the west coast. They will probably have to hit the portal in hopes of improving the DL. This was the talk last year after they collapsed down the stretch.
Agree, I really hope they throttle ND so we can stick a fork in ND for the season.