Thinking best case is sprained MCL and out 2 weeks.
Can we beat Huskies without Allar?
Can we beat Huskies without Allar?
Thoughts on Allar injury?
- Thread starter MacNit
- Start date
That’s what I was thinking also. It was a hip drop tackle because the defender was hanging on and wasn’t successful in bringing him down initially. Those tackles are illegal for that very reason. I don’t know why a) the ref didn’t blow the play dead b) it wasn’t a flag for the tackle or the facemask by the second or third guy. Regardless, I’m not sure it would be necessarily a bad thing to play with that injury, but it is pretty painful and it is his plant leg when throwing.
only old people have grandchildren who are MDsThat's what my DR. grandson believes.
There is nothing in college rules around hip drop tackles…that’s an NFL rule.
Hey can he write scrips? Asking for meThat's what my DR. grandson believes.
I thought it odd that, even on replays, the TV announcers couldn't see the injury happen. It seemed evident that his knee buckled inward
Except the NFL referees aren’t really tossing flags for it, see Chris Godwin’s dislocated ankle last weekend!
They have but it isn’t a routine call. Joe Mixon was pretty outspoken that his injury was a result of it. The players are getting fined for it even if not flagged.
Recovery time for an MCL sprain depends on the severity of the injury12345:
- Mild MCL sprains (grade one) take about 3 to 6 weeks to fully recover.
- Moderate to severe MCL injuries (grade two or grade three) may take 8 to 12 weeks.
- Healing time can vary from a few days to 9 months, depending on the category of the sprain and whether surgery is needed.
Washington scares me. They have out gained every opponent they've faced but lost 4 games because of penalties, turnovers, or missed kicks.
I can’t tell from the film what his injury may be. If it bent inwards I suppose it could be an MCL sprain, but it could also be meniscus, bone contusion or other ligament injury. Or any combination of those. Just not enough information picture/video wise to tell anything (coming from someone with years of experience in imaging of sports related injuries).
I would assume medical evaluation early in the week. we could all see the twisted knee and then a brace. could be a lot of things with different recovery outcomes.
Pure for the fun of it speculation....knee brace applied and in possession of his helmet, Allar is asked if he feels he can "go" and be effective. Allar admits he's too compromised. So my 2 cents is he was evaluated and approved to return to play. The kid knew he wouldn't be accurate given the discomfort and loss of function. Bet he feels even more discomfort today. I think he might be close to 90% by Washington.
Somewhat, yes, but someone in here made a comment a few weeks ago about untucked shirts on PSU players.
I was at the game and watched him when they came out after half time. He tried to warm up and when he stepped into his first throw, he stopped dead and flipped the ball angrily and walked to sidelines. Looked like he just couldn't plant his front foot with the knee issue. I doubt he misses two games.
PSU can beat OSU if Beau plays like he did last night vs Wisky, He looked really good-with a full week of practice the Buckeyes could go down.
Why would Franklin risk losing Allar for a prolonged amount of time when he has a more than adequate replacement in Pribula? Sure Allar's arm is stronger and probably more accurate, but Pribula isn't chopped liver. Myconcern would be Pribula's backup being thrown into the fire.
Washington scares you? C'mon, man, they'll piss in their pants at a Whiteout.
Never said he should, just that I’m not sure if it just a matter of dealing with the pain, which is inconveniently on his plant leg when throwing.
Biggest concern with Pribula is taking care of the ball. The tight pass to Trey was close to a pick. There were several mesh bobbles. Needs to play a near perfect game.
I’m very fearful of them. They live with Sasquatch and never complain.
For regular people and not athletes…depends on what the actual injury is though…obviously
here is recovery time for MCL injuries from ortho site. Recovery is to 100%, not limited and limping:
- For a mild MCL injury (Grade 1), recovery typically takes about 3 to 6 weeks
1
. - A moderate MCL injury (Grade 2) may take around 8 to 12 weeks to heal
1
. - Severe MCL injuries (Grade 3) can take 12 weeks or more for a full recovery
2
.
I thought only the Oregon Ducks do a 'Yellowout"... Yellow and white doesn't really mesh well together for a color combo on t.v.
Yeah these kids aren't regular humans and they don't have regular human doctors. If he is >75% there is no way he doesn't shoot it upo to numb the pain and give it a go for OSU. I am not saying that is right or wrong, but very likely.
75% of Allar is not as good as Beau. Another factor is this isn't a decision about what's good for Dear Old State or Big Game James. Allar is in position to be a first round draft choice. Come spring his floor looks to be $20 million and a ceiling of $35 million. Can you imagine the wrath that would be heaped on Franklin (even though this would be a medical staff decision) if a gimpy Allar gets buried and carried off the field?
While I concede that virtually no one is 100% healthy after mid season, my guess is that Allar needs to be 95% and mobile to see action as a starter.
Another thing, no fan should be deluded into thinking we're going to see the Ohio State that played Nebraska.