Winners make the plays to win, and yes we were 17ed several times last year. Royally 17ed.
Yeah, I'm not a huge fan of just accepting adages as true. Some are and some are depending on the context, but I'm definitely not one who buys the idea that, "even though we got screwed, if we were winners we would have won anyway". That's why undefeated seasons are so rare...the best team does not always win, and often the result is due to bad calls.
Not saying you are doing that, because you did also admit we got 17ed. But there are so many people who believe "reasons" are always "excuses" and "excuses are for losers". While that is often true, I am not one who believes there are no exceptions.
In any case, it is a fact that we were very, very close, and could even argue we should have been 10-1 or 9-2 going into the Egg Bowl, and weren't because officials blew calls or kickers missed chip-shot FG's, both of which should not reflect negatively on the coaching staff, at least as far as record goes. Of course we can say for instance that we should never have been in as tight a game with Memphis where a blown call or two made the difference. But those blown calls did most likely turn a W into an L.
If we are going to judge CML on his record from last year, it is only logical & appropriate for purposes of said judgement that we do factor in the screw jobs and FG kicker chokes, and acknowledge this was a team that really should have been the aforementioned 10-1 or 9-2 at worst.