Honestly, why is there such toxic negativity about our football season?

OG Goat Holder

Well-known member
Sep 30, 2022
9,400
8,726
113
Dude, we were up by what, 21, at home, against a Cadillac Williams coached AU team, and were fortunate to escape with an OT victory. You call that NOT caving? Interesting.

I mean, I'm glad we won, but caving is exactly what we did in that game. They just out-sucked us by a hair.
You do realize that we had to also get up by 21 too? That means we did some good things and obviously have the potential to be a good team.

Funny, if we manage to beat Ole Miss, all you clowns will suddenly STFU.
 

She Mate Me

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
10,287
7,055
113
Because so many old State fans cling to sucking. They've accepted it. They have no hope beyond "this is our history". They apply no logic beyond that. When's baseball season start?

There's a wisdom that comes with age.

At least there is for folks who don't let their inner idiot dominate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jethreauxdawg

KentuckyDawg13

Active member
Aug 15, 2006
1,822
469
83
Simple, MSU is NOT competitive with the teams that are ranked AT ALL. In the past, MSU would be in a battle with them with a chance to win until the end. This current team has no chance against elite defenses AT ALL.
In addition, see last two um games and bowl games results. Weak.
 

The Cooterpoot

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2022
4,842
8,139
113
There's a wisdom that comes with age.

At least there is for folks who don't let their inner idiot dominate.
Nah, old guys get bitter with age. They feel like they're in their spot in the world and they're too old to give a ****. We've got a lot of "don't give a ****" in our fan base.
 

Ranchdawg

Well-known member
Dec 13, 2012
3,530
2,751
113
Arkansas lost to Liberty. They're the only .500 team in the west.
Yeah, and a guy that smoked lived until he was 104. Guess I should start smoking. Seems like Liberty was ranked too. Hum, they fall outside the 20%? Liberty has a good team and I know they lost last week so don't come back with that weak response.
 

She Mate Me

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
10,287
7,055
113
Simple, MSU is NOT competitive with the teams that are ranked AT ALL. In the past, MSU would be in a battle with them with a chance to win until the end. This current team has no chance against elite defenses AT ALL.
In addition, see last two um games and bowl games results. Weak.

LSU is ranked about #6 right now and won the West over the perennial "best team in the nation".

We led them 16-10 heading into the 4th Quarter. I'm gonna call that competing, even if they did dominate that last quarter.
 

The Cooterpoot

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2022
4,842
8,139
113
Yeah, and a guy that smoked lived until he was 104. Guess I should start smoking.
Maybe you should. A&M lost to App St, AU lost to Penn St. Even the division champs lost to FSU. Down year in the west. Worst since Saban arrived.
 

She Mate Me

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
10,287
7,055
113
Nah, old guys get bitter with age. They feel like they're in their spot in the world and they're too old to give a ****. We've got a lot of "don't give a ****" in our fan base.

Well, at least you don't stereotype people based on age.

I'd be happy to take a poll here as to who is more bitter, me or you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ibdancin

KentuckyDawg13

Active member
Aug 15, 2006
1,822
469
83
LSU is ranked about #6 right now and won the West over the perennial "best team in the nation".

We led them 16-10 heading into the 4th Quarter. I'm gonna call that competing, even if they did dominate that last quarter.
UGa too, right? Those teams don't even try to win, yet do over MSU now based on talent level.
My hate is strong because I get to go to one game a year, usually the UK game since I live 700 miles away from Starkville. The one game where I bought multiple tickets for friends to share the MSU love...and what happens, Leach's team sh|ts the bed. Again.
 

She Mate Me

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
10,287
7,055
113
UGa too, right? Those teams don't even try to win, yet do over MSU now based on talent level.
My hate is strong because I get to go to one game a year, usually the UK game since I live 700 miles away from Starkville. The one game where I bought multiple tickets for friends to share the MSU love...and what happens, Leach's team sh|ts the bed. Again.

That seems like a logical analysis.**
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ibdancin

Ibdancin

Well-known member
Feb 9, 2018
2,625
1,218
113
UGa too, right? Those teams don't even try to win, yet do over MSU now based on talent level.
My hate is strong because I get to go to one game a year, usually the UK game since I live 700 miles away from Starkville. The one game where I bought multiple tickets for friends to share the MSU love...and what happens, Leach's team sh|ts the bed. Again.
Yeah... Like I said earlier. Walk up to Sharpe. Johnson, and Marks and tell them exactly how they suck and caused you misery because they got injured. Maybe tell them you want you money back???
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigDawg0074

Thumbs Down

Active member
Sep 29, 2022
101
414
63
I disagree that the KY win would have made all of this go away. There is a segment of our fan base on this site and others who just do not want Leach and they are very vocal about it. Just the opinion of a member of the Class of '62
New York Yankees Reaction GIF by MLB
 

She Mate Me

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
10,287
7,055
113
My thoughts on the matter. I’ve seen this posted before on here but it’s true. Leach is a high floor coach. Go back and look at his year by year record. Except for the first few years at WSU, when he was pulling that program out of the abyss, he’s won between 7 and 9 games almost every season. He had one 11-win season at Tech and one at Wazzu, but almost every other year was between 7 and 9 wins. Throw out the Covid year, and that’s exactly what he’s done here. We have a stable program with Leach that will likely win 7 to 9 games a year with a potential double digit type win season if things break right. If some MSU fans aren’t happy with that, then they won’t be happy with Leach.

Or anyone else who coaches here.
 

Seinfeld

Well-known member
Nov 30, 2006
10,142
4,868
113
This . . . and I'll add one more:

4. Based upon Leach's demeanor, body language, etc., it appears that he is not really into winning football games. A coach that cares deeply about winning football games is not as "laid-back" as Leach during games, practices, press conferences, etc. Nothing great was ever achieved without enthusiasm.

I don't really care what Ole Miss does . . . except when we play them.
This really doesn’t get brought up enough. A big part of eventually getting over the proverbial hump to reach 10+ wins in this conference is having a head coach that is both willing to do what it takes to get there himself while also inspiring those around him to do the same. There isn’t a thing that Leach says or demonstrates to make me think that he possesses this quality
 
  • Like
Reactions: peewee.sixpack

FlotownDawg

Well-known member
Aug 30, 2012
6,005
5,422
113
Simple, MSU is NOT competitive with the teams that are ranked AT ALL. In the past, MSU would be in a battle with them with a chance to win until the end. This current team has no chance against elite defenses AT ALL.
In addition, see last two um games and bowl games results. Weak.
Did you just become a State fan last year???? In the past we would be in a battle with ranked teams until the end? Look at Dan Mullen’s games against ranked teams. We got blown out quite a bit. Even in 2017, probably our second best season under Mullen, we lost back to back games to Georgia and Auburn by scores of 31-3 and 49-10. We lost to Alabama by scores of 51-3, 38-7, 31-6 and 30-10. Lost to LSU by scores of 29-7, 37-17 and 59-26. We got beat down by OM just about anytime they were ranked. This romanticizing of our past like we were some really good program and Leach has torn it down really ticks me off. Mullen had plenty of crappy games against ranked teams and unranked teams, but some here forget about those and act like we just started sucking this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ranchdawg

The Cooterpoot

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2022
4,842
8,139
113
Well, at least you don't stereotype people based on age.

I'd be happy to take a poll here as to who is more bitter, me or you.
Eh, it is what it is. The older crowd gets set in their ways. It's not like I'm 20 either. But I'm a change things kind of person. Im not simply content with my "place in this world". Especially after damn near dying a couple years ago.
 

OG Goat Holder

Well-known member
Sep 30, 2022
9,400
8,726
113
Simple, MSU is NOT competitive with the teams that are ranked AT ALL. In the past, MSU would be in a battle with them with a chance to win until the end. This current team has no chance against elite defenses AT ALL.
This is stupidity. Mullen's teams were largely inept against good defense. Even in 2014, Alabama and Ole Miss stymied our ***. In 2017 Georgia and Auburn did the same. I'm sure you'll bring up Alabama, who did win the natty, but were without like ALL of their linebacking 2-deep that day. 2010 and 2015 also got punched in the face by elite defense.

The only 'past' you could be talking about was King Jackie's tenure that ended 19 years ago after the most embarrassing 3 year period in our modern history. Hardly relevant to today's game.

Again, if you Leach-haters would just be factual, we could talk.
 

Ranchdawg

Well-known member
Dec 13, 2012
3,530
2,751
113
This really doesn’t get brought up enough. A big part of eventually getting over the proverbial hump to reach 10+ wins in this conference is having a head coach that is both willing to do what it takes to get there himself while also inspiring those around him to do the same. There isn’t a thing that Leach says or demonstrates to make me think that he possesses this quality
Leach preaches to his team not to get too up or down for what happened on one play. The reason he does this is to make sure they are consistently doing what they are taught in practice and run the next play. He demonstates that behavior on the field coaching. How can he preach that and then jump around on the sidelines like a deranged ape???
 

Ibdancin

Well-known member
Feb 9, 2018
2,625
1,218
113
Leach preaches to his team not to get too up or down for what happened on one play. The reason he does this is to make sure they are consistently doing what they are taught in practice and run the next play. He demonstates that behavior on the field coaching. How can he preach that and then jump around on the sidelines like a deranged ape???
Yeah... and that wasn't Leach yelling at them on the sideline. LOL! It wasn't him folding chairs!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grover777

BigDawg0074

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2016
1,353
689
113
Did you just become a State fan last year???? In the past we would be in a battle with ranked teams until the end? Look at Dan Mullen’s games against ranked teams. We got blown out quite a bit. Even in 2017, probably our second best season under Mullen, we lost back to back games to Georgia and Auburn by scores of 31-3 and 49-10. We lost to Alabama by scores of 51-3, 38-7, 31-6 and 30-10. Lost to LSU by scores of 29-7, 37-17 and 59-26. We got beat down by OM just about anytime they were ranked. This romanticizing of our past like we were some really good program and Leach has torn it down really ticks me off. Mullen had plenty of crappy games against ranked teams and unranked teams, but some here forget about those and act like we just started sucking this year.
Exactly what I’ve been trying to say. Dudes really have rose colored glasses when it comes to Mullen. He averaged a losing conference record and got blew the 17 out on the regular by elite teams. This Mike Leach team is easily on par with most of the teams that Mullen produced in Starkville. Ole Miss sucked butt half the time Mullen was here too so he had some easy wins over Johnny Reb.
 

Grover777

Active member
Nov 1, 2022
515
341
63
Mullen sec record first five years 3-5,4-4,2-6,4-4,3-5

Mullen in the egg bowl when ole miss had 8 wins 0-2

Mullen in the egg bowl when ole miss had 5 or more wins 3-4

Leach will win 9-10 games next year. He’s doing better than Mullen.

most of the posters that have an ax to grind with Leach are either loser podcasters, local media types or ole miss trolls.

Life is about to change dramatically for the detractors.
 
Last edited:

NotCadaver

Member
Oct 17, 2022
29
46
13
You do realize that we had to also get up by 21 too? That means we did some good things and obviously have the potential to be a good team.

Funny, if we manage to beat Ole Miss, all you clowns will suddenly STFU.
It was Auburn. They have no coach. We were at home. They suck. I'm supposed to praise us for getting up 21 and blowing it? Good Lord.

And yes, "potential to be a good team" is right. So when will it pay off if not when all of these guys are veterans? Like this year. You just admitted with that phrase that we AREN'T a good team.

And yes, if Leach manages to beat Ole Miss it will stop a lot of my complaints. But not just bc it's Ole Miss....

Because he would finally beat his rival, which he has shown zero ability to do in 10+ years

Because he would manage to show up for a road game in this conference, which he hasn't shown.

Because he would manage to compete with a team that is above .500 this year.

All things he hasn't done, so it would make me very happy.

But let's face it, we aren't beating Ole Miss. Because we aren't improving, and we aren't progressing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

IBleedMaroonDawg

Well-known member
Nov 12, 2007
24,277
8,445
113
No, Caving would have resulted in a loss.


Just like those teams you want to jump and and down and demand we not count them because the teams are 5-5. That's laughable. Taking a step forward means winning those games and we did. By alot. and had we not won they would have winning records and you would have a point.... BUT we won.. your point is moot.
You might as well find something else to waste energy on. TaintQueef and the rest of that crowd have convinced themselves that they are fighting the good fight and that the Cigar Boys are discussing their opinions over single malts and Cubans every night while reading and re-reading every post they make about our Coach in hopes their phones will ring next Friday to decide who is going to be the successor to Leach.

They are ready to lead us out of the wilderness where our team will win 9-11 games each year just because we by damn demand it. No matter our level talent, coach, schedule, or act of God we will by god

You cannot change their minds... negotiate any middle ground... just stand back and watch them change coaches every couple of years until they get what they want and win the coaching and program lottery.

Let's just stand back and watch them lead the way. I know I am from now on.
 

Grover777

Active member
Nov 1, 2022
515
341
63
You might as well find something else to waste energy on. TaintQueef and the rest of that crowd have convinced themselves that they are fighting the good fight and that the Cigar Boys are discussing their opinions over single malts and Cubans every night while reading and re-reading every post they make about our Coach in hopes their phones will ring next Friday to decide who is going to be the successor to Leach.

They are ready to lead us out of the wilderness where our team will win 9-11 games each year just because we by damn demand it. No matter our level talent, coach, schedule, or act of God we will by god

You cannot change their minds... negotiate any middle ground... just stand back and watch them change coaches every couple of years until they get what they want and win the coaching and program lottery.

Let's just stand back and watch them lead the way. I know I am from now on.
They are living in a fantasy world on the internet

they are less than insignificant
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ibdancin

LimaoCabeca

Active member
Nov 17, 2022
181
330
63
By all accounts we are having a pretty good season. After Saturday, we will be 7-4 with three of our four losses against teams currently ranked in the top 10. It’s a typical MSU of the past 12 years type of season. Dan Mullen had this same type of season almost every year. But there is such relentless negativity on this board by many people that you’d think we were on our way to a 4-8 season or something. Why is that? I’m genuinely curious. Is it that some just hate Leach’s personality so much that anything short of a 10 win season is not good enough? Did you raise your expectations when he was hired? What is it?
This team is about where I though they’d be. I’m disappointed because I feel like there’s no fire in the coaches or the players. If they can’t sleepwalk through a game, they have no chance.
 

Grover777

Active member
Nov 1, 2022
515
341
63
All of these criticisms are subjective nonsense like “poor body language” “doesn’t pass the eye test” “they don’t have fire”

because they can’t counter the facts : 3 of four losses have been to #1 Georgia and top ten teams Alabama and LSU on the road. Historically this program is not going to do any better than 7-4 with This schedule and most years worse.

our offensive production against Georgia was the second best of any team they have played this year and it was 17-12 at half. We did much better against LSU on the road than ole miss (sos #55) who were blown out 45-3 after the first quarter.
 

NotCadaver

Member
Oct 17, 2022
29
46
13
All of these criticisms are subjective nonsense like “poor body language” “doesn’t pass the eye test” “they don’t have fire”

because they can’t counter the facts : 3 of four losses have been to #1 Georgia and top ten teams Alabama and LSU on the road. Historically this program is not going to do any better than 7-4 with This schedule and most years worse.

our offensive production against Georgia was the second best of any team they have played this year and it was 17-12 at half. We did much better against LSU on the road than ole miss (sos #55) who were blown out 45-3 after the first quarter.
So far I've seen that I should be happy with getting up 21 points over a **** team, even if we blew said lead....

that I should be happy "losing by less than Ole Miss did to LSU"....

that I should be happy that we did better offensively against Georgia than most others, even though we lost by 20+.

oh yeah, and "our history" and "Mullen" keep getting brought up...as if that means we shouldn't expect more. Did y'all think 13 straight bowls was possible when Croom was our coach?? Then why is it criminal of us to think we can do better than no wins versus teams above .500, and double digit losses in every single loss? Just because somebody comes from a poor family, doesn't mean they should also have to be poor.

Want facts? Every coach we have had since Sherrill has won at least 8 games in a season here. Maybe we aren't the ones being unrealistic...maybe you guys are just devaluing how good our program is capable of being.
 

Grover777

Active member
Nov 1, 2022
515
341
63
so what Coach in our history beats that #1 Georgia team we played and top ten Alabama and LSU teams on the road ?

I’ll hang up and listen

you want a bcs playoff caliber team in Leachs second full season after Covid. Do you think that’s realistic for any coach ?
 

Ibdancin

Well-known member
Feb 9, 2018
2,625
1,218
113
So far I've seen that I should be happy with getting up 21 points over a **** team, even if we blew said lead....

that I should be happy "losing by less than Ole Miss did to LSU"....

that I should be happy that we did better offensively against Georgia than most others, even though we lost by 20+.

oh yeah, and "our history" and "Mullen" keep getting brought up...as if that means we shouldn't expect more. Did y'all think 13 straight bowls was possible when Croom was our coach?? Then why is it criminal of us to think we can do better than no wins versus teams above .500, and double digit losses in every single loss? Just because somebody comes from a poor family, doesn't mean they should also have to be poor.

Want facts? Every coach we have had since Sherrill has won at least 8 games in a season here. Maybe we aren't the ones being unrealistic...maybe you guys are just devaluing how good our program is capable of being.


HAHAHA!!! So Leach will not win 8 here? Can you tell me who will win the the National title while you look in the crystal ball?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grover777

QuaoarsKing

Well-known member
Mar 11, 2008
4,939
1,018
113
Simple, MSU is NOT competitive with the teams that are ranked AT ALL. In the past, MSU would be in a battle with them with a chance to win until the end. This current team has no chance against elite defenses AT ALL.
In addition, see last two um games and bowl games results. Weak.

Say what?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grover777

chuckster.sixpack

Well-known member
Mar 26, 2015
738
575
93
Yeah... Like I said earlier. Walk up to Sharpe. Johnson, and Marks and tell them exactly how they suck and caused you misery because they got injured. Maybe tell them you want you money back???
Walk up to Kylin Hill and tell him how you aren’t surprised the Packers cut him.
 

BulldogBlitz

Well-known member
Dec 11, 2008
11,894
10,096
113
By all accounts we are having a pretty good season. After Saturday, we will be 7-4 with three of our four losses against teams currently ranked in the top 10. It’s a typical MSU of the past 12 years type of season. Dan Mullen had this same type of season almost every year. But there is such relentless negativity on this board by many people that you’d think we were on our way to a 4-8 season or something. Why is that? I’m genuinely curious. Is it that some just hate Leach’s personality so much that anything short of a 10 win season is not good enough? Did you raise your expectations when he was hired? What is it?
Because we have always been a perennially top 10 program*******


***top 10 on the sec
 

BigDawg0074

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2016
1,353
689
113
So far I've seen that I should be happy with getting up 21 points over a **** team, even if we blew said lead....

that I should be happy "losing by less than Ole Miss did to LSU"....

that I should be happy that we did better offensively against Georgia than most others, even though we lost by 20+.

oh yeah, and "our history" and "Mullen" keep getting brought up...as if that means we shouldn't expect more. Did y'all think 13 straight bowls was possible when Croom was our coach?? Then why is it criminal of us to think we can do better than no wins versus teams above .500, and double digit losses in every single loss? Just because somebody comes from a poor family, doesn't mean they should also have to be poor.

Want facts? Every coach we have had since Sherrill has won at least 8 games in a season here. Maybe we aren't the ones being unrealistic...maybe you guys are just devaluing how good our program is capable of being.
We want more but we aren’t crapping a brick because it may not happen this year. Mullen is the measuring stick because he’s the last coach who flirted with greatness here and virtually nobody was dead set that he needed to be fired. Remember that firing Leach is the underlying premise here and that’s a ridiculous notion on it face at this point in his MSU tenure. Make no mistake though, if Leach drops the next three and Will Rigers gets knocked out by Tyrus Wheat during bowl practice Leach would be gone. He’s not untouchable, but it’s comical to think the program has not made progress on par with teams we have deemed acceptable before.
 

Grover777

Active member
Nov 1, 2022
515
341
63
HAHAHA!!! So Leach will not win 8 here? Can you tell me who will win the the National title while you look in the crystal ball?
What’s funny is, if you look at next years much more reasonable schedule, leach will win 8 in his sleep.

then the braying jackasses will start screeching why didn’t we win the sec west and blah blah blah

same people who don’t give a nickel to NIL
 

NotCadaver

Member
Oct 17, 2022
29
46
13
HAHAHA!!! So Leach will not win 8 here? Can you tell me who will win the the National title while you look in the crystal ball?
Who said Leach wouldn't win 8? 8 has become something every coach can do here now. That was my point. Part of yours and Grover's problem is that you can't read and comprehend.

I said I want us to take the next step. The next step doesn't mean beating #1 Georgia, or Top 10 Bama. But it could mean competing with them. Not losing by 25+ every time we play them. Not losing every road game in the league. Not losing to a bad UK team. Not blowing a 21 point lead to a coachless team on our home field.
You guys act like we're expecting a SEC Title. We aren't...or I'm not anyway...I'm just wanting to take a step up from where we are now, where we don't have to automatically concede any chance at beating a good team, or even competing with them. I don't feel like that's asking too much. But it's something that a one dimensional approach, with no adjustments, no enthusiasm, and no creativity will likely not be able to change.

Oh, and Grover is the most obvious troll ever by the way. I couldn't care less, just letting those of you that are agreeing with him know, you're being played.
 
Last edited: