You may not agree, but I explained it pretty clearly. I'll try another approach:
Fiat doesn't mean
not backed by gold. It means
by decree.
View attachment 653753
I know what 'fiat' means from a financial perspective. And so if the definition of fiat is known, then the opposite is also known. If fiat money is valued by decree, then non-fiat money(commodity money) is valued intrinsically.
My initial point was that btc is not commodity money, so it is effectively the same as fiat money since it is valued off of not metal/commodity. It is then no better than the very thing that so many btc supporters hate on.
No, I said what makes bitcoin fundamentally different is that it is not created or controlled by a government and does not derive its value from government decree. I think you are still struggling with what fiat actually means.
I still understand what 'fiat' means. I am taking take the term and applying the results of the term to other terms that share those results.
Yes, I understand btc isnt created or controlled by a government. That is a distinction without a difference though, at least when it comes to value, since both btc and USD rely on market dynamics for value. Market dynamics absolutely determine the value of USD. I gave an example, its was a spot on example, and I even cited the reality that the common complaint of that example doesnt hold up when other instances in history are considered.
In reality, USD does not derive its value from government decree. It simply doesnt. The value of USD is directly tied to other currencies and to market dynamics. The US Government can claim a $100 is worth $100, but that is no different from claiming 1btc is worth...1btc. Uhoh, btc is tied to USD. Hmm...seems like a bit of a fatal flaw, huh?
All seriousness though, markets determine what USD and other currencies are actually worth.
This is the infinite pizza theory. As long as I can slice my pizza up into smaller and smaller pieces, I don't have a fixed supply of pizza.
Yes, except with pizza you do eventually get to a point where you physically cant divide it up any further. With electronic currency, those decimals can keep going on forever, so it actually could be infinite.
Best of luck continuing to argue that btc is better than USD because its value isnt determined by Government decree, even thought the value of USD is absolutely determined by market forces, and the value of btc is directly tied to the value of USD.
That right there is the real infinite loop.